Port !997 from v1.0 onto the context-aware master recovery lifecycle. Preserve master logging and resolver APIs while adding macOS default-route DHCP detection, temporary DNS-target cleanup, and atomic recovery ownership.
Includes parser, lifecycle, failure, and concurrency regressions plus the corrected macOS QA helper. Relates to #533 and #597.
A host carrying orphaned WFP filters from a ctrld build that predates
session-scoped ownership cannot recover on its own. In Firewall Mode those
filters block all non-allowlisted outbound traffic machine-wide, which denies
the replacement ctrld's own API bootstrap. API-managed startup then sits in the
resolver-config retry loop forever and never reaches startWFPFilters, where the
only stale-sublayer cleanup lived. Cleanup needs startup, startup needs the
network, the network needs cleanup - the host stays locked out until a reboot.
Add cleanupStaleDNSInterceptState() and call it early in run(), before the
network-up wait and before the API preflight. On Windows it deletes ctrld's WFP
sublayer, which takes its child filters with it, so a previous process's
enforcement is gone before this process makes its first connection. Objects
owned by a live session cannot be deleted, so a running ctrld is unaffected and
"nothing to clean up" stays at debug level; an actual removal logs a warning,
since it means a previous ctrld left machine-wide enforcement installed.
macOS and the other platforms get no-op implementations: pf enforcement does not
outlive the process, and startDNSIntercept already flushes the anchor and
removes a stale anchor file before loading rules.
The cleanup inside startWFPFilters stays as a second line of defense.
The cleanup session is deliberately NOT dynamic. FwpmSubLayerDeleteByKey0 is
documented to fail with FWP_E_DYNAMIC_SESSION_IN_PROGRESS when called from a
dynamic session for an object that was not added in one, and the only orphans
that can exist are exactly those: a ctrld predating session-scoped ownership
added its sublayer statically. Anything a newer ctrld leaves behind is removed by
the OS when its session ends. Opening this session dynamically would have made
the cleanup a no-op in the one case it exists for, while still logging "no stale
WFP state".
A concurrently running ctrld is protected by documented ownership rather than by
the child-filter question below: a session-scoped ctrld's sublayer belongs to a
different dynamic session, so the delete fails with FWP_E_WRONG_SESSION. That
matters because this call is made unconditionally at startup, in every intercept
mode, so an interactive "ctrld run" alongside a healthy service reaches it.
A ctrld predating session scoping has no such protection: it holds a non-dynamic
sublayer, which is exactly what this targets and is indistinguishable from an
orphan. Two guards cover that instead. Elevation, because opening a WFP engine
and deleting ctrld's sublayer must not be reachable from an unprivileged local
process - FwpmEngineOpen0 is expected to fail without elevation, but that is a
property of the API rather than something this code checked, and it was the only
barrier. And interactive invocation, since a service start is not interactive: the
deadlock case still gets cleaned, while a hand-run "ctrld run" beside a live
service does not strip its enforcement. That second guard requires positive
evidence of absence - ctrldServiceLiveness answers unknown for an unreachable SCM
or a service mid-stop, and unknown skips the cleanup exactly as running does,
because "could not be observed" is not "not there".
Both are asserted against the deletion itself, not only against the predicate: a
caller-level test substitutes the WFP delete and the guard inputs, so a future
change that stops consulting the guard, or consults it and deletes anyway, fails
rather than staying green.
Delete failures are no longer collapsed into "nothing to clean up". Only
FWP_E_SUBLAYER_NOT_FOUND means that; any other code means state exists under our
GUID that we could not remove, which is the lockout condition itself, so it is
logged as a warning naming the code.
Whether deleting the sublayer is sufficient is left explicitly UNRESOLVED rather
than asserted. It is sufficient only if the delete also removes the filters
inside it. FwpmSubLayerDeleteByKey0's Remarks say nothing about child filters
either way, while object management states that an object cannot be deleted until
everything referencing it has been - and FWP_E_IN_USE exists for that. Whether a
filter's subLayerKey counts as such a reference is not documented, and this code
cannot be exercised off-Windows, so the earlier claim that the delete "takes its
child filters with it" is removed from the comment here and from
docs/wfp-dns-intercept.md, which carried it from before this branch.
The behaviour is safe under both readings: the delete is attempted, and
FWP_E_IN_USE is reported rather than counted as success, so a support log
distinguishes "cleared it" from "could not clear it". If a live Windows check
shows FWP_E_IN_USE against orphaned filters, the cleanup must enumerate and
delete those filters first. That is deliberately not written blind:
FWPM_FILTER_ENUM_TEMPLATE0 has no sublayer field, so selecting ctrld's own
filters means reading subLayerKey at a computed offset in FWPM_FILTER0, and
getting that offset wrong would delete other software's filters - a worse failure
than not cleaning up.
Refs: https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/win32/api/fwpmu/nf-fwpmu-fwpmsublayerdeletebykey0
Refs: https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/win32/fwp/object-management
macOS Firewall Mode blocked forwarded/NATed VM/container egress: a guest
resolves DNS through a path host ctrld does not observe, so the guest-resolved
public IP never enters <ctrld_allowed> and the blanket outbound block drops the
guest's TCP/443.
Make VM/container guests first-class Firewall Mode clients by forcing their DNS
through ctrld. The trusted source subnets are the UNION of:
- Auto-detected VM/NAT networks (default, no config): interfaces that are up,
carry an RFC1918 IPv4 address, and whose VM ownership can be proven either
by a vendor-specific name (vnic/vboxnet/vmnet) or by being a bridge* whose
member list contains a vendor VM interface (typically vmenet*). Each keeps
its ingress interface, and its pf rules are scoped "on <iface>" so an
unrelated interface on the same private range is never affected.
- service.firewall_forwarded_sources (opt-in): explicit IPv4 CIDRs, matched on
the source CIDR alone, for stacks whose ownership cannot be proven. Config
adds only; an invalid or non-IPv4 entry is dropped with a warning.
Checking bridge membership is what makes the common case work without config.
Every vmnet.framework stack - UTM and other Virtualization.framework guests,
Docker Desktop, Multipass, Fusion 12.1+ NAT - puts the RFC1918 gateway address
on a bridge10x interface and attaches the vendor-named vmenet* interface as an
address-less member, so matching on interface name alone never sees them.
Membership is the ownership proof a bridge name lacks: macOS shares that
namespace with Thunderbolt/aggregated links (ctrld's own tunnel-change code
treats bridge0 as physical), and such a bridge has en* members, so it stays
untrusted however private its address. Members are read with ifconfig, and only
for a bridge that already carries an RFC1918 IPv4 address, so a host with no VM
running executes no subprocess.
Per source subnet, plaintext DNS (53) is force-routed through ctrld (route-to
lo0 -> existing rdr-on-lo0) so guest resolutions are policy-enforced and
populate the allowlist; guest egress to allowed IPs is then permitted by the
existing <ctrld_allowed> rule. DoT (853) is blocked so guests cannot swap in an
alternate resolver. DoH/443 is a documented limitation.
Rules are emitted strictly per address family. Sources are IPv4 (interception
targets ctrld's IPv4 listener), so only inet rules are generated: pf rejects an
entire anchor over a single "inet6 ... from 192.168.x.0/24" mismatch, which
would take DNS interception down with it. Guest IPv6 DoT is covered by the
blanket IPv6 block instead, since such a resolver never enters <ctrld_allowed>.
firewall_forwarded_sources is deliberately not validated with `cidr`. Entries
are checked where they are parsed and a bad one is dropped while the rest of the
set still applies. A hard validator would make one typo in an MDM-pushed subnet
fatal at startup - validateConfig exits the process - taking DNS service down
for the whole host over a line that only ever widened a firewall allowance. The
warning fires when the set of unusable entries changes rather than on every
parse, since config is re-read on every anchor build and every watchdog tick.
Reconcile the trust set at runtime, since VM interfaces appear and disappear
while ctrld runs and no existing path rebuilds an intact anchor for that
(ensurePFAnchorActive returns early, checkTunnelInterfaceChanges tracks only
tunnels, pfInterceptMonitor rebuilds only after a failed host probe). On a
change, rebuild the anchor and drop the pf states of the affected subnets
(targeted pfctl -k, not a global state flush), because rules govern only new
states: a stopped guest would otherwise keep using states created while it was
trusted, and a newly trusted one would keep bypassing interception until its
states expired. Reconciliation runs on interface appear/disappear, on network
changes, on the delayed post-change re-checks (a VM network often gets its
address after its interface appears), and on the pf watchdog tick, which bounds
guest start/stop convergence to one interval even with no network event.
Convergence is not latched on failure: the applied set advances, and states are
killed, only after pf has accepted the new anchor. reloadForwardedSourceAnchor
reports write/pfctl failures to the caller, which then keeps the previous set
recorded and logs a warning, so the next reconcile retries the same transition
instead of going quiet with the old anchor still installed. The whole
compare-reload-record sequence is serialized so a watchdog tick and a network
change cannot both rebuild or interleave snapshots.
Every anchor rebuild records the forwarded-source set it installed, and takes
that set as a parameter rather than re-detecting internally. Otherwise a rebuild
triggered by something else (tunnel change, watchdog restore, VPN DNS
exemptions, forced reload, startup) leaves the snapshot at the older set and the
next reconcile "discovers" the same change again: another rebuild, another round
of killed guest states, and a transition logged for something already in effect.
Passing the set in also means what pf loaded is exactly what gets recorded, so
an interface appearing mid-reconcile cannot leave the snapshot describing a set
that was never installed.
The anchor file is replaced atomically (temp file plus rename). Seven paths
rebuild it from timers and network-change callbacks in their own goroutines with
no lock between them, and os.WriteFile truncates before writing, so a pfctl -f
racing that window could read a partial ruleset and reject the anchor - taking
DNS interception down until the next watchdog restore.
Report the effective trust set at startup and on every change, naming each
subnet's origin ("192.168.64.0/24 (configured)" vs "(auto-detected on
bridge100)"), and say so explicitly when the set is empty, including what
auto-detection requires. Configured entries previously produced no log output at
all, so an admin who set firewall_forwarded_sources could not confirm it had
taken effect without reading pf rules. Per-source detection logging is at debug,
since detection re-runs on every anchor build.
Explicit, per-subnet trust boundary (RFC1918-only auto-detect, proven VM
ownership, interface-scoped rules, config adds only), not an interface-wide
permit: direct public IPs the guest never resolved through ctrld stay blocked.
Tests cover rule generation and its interface scoping, the no-blanket-permit
boundary, single-family emission (no inet6 rule for an IPv4 source, IPv6 sources
skipped), a real pfctl -n -f parse of both the forwarded-source rules alone and
the full anchor (group-scoped rules stripped, since _ctrld exists only where the
service is installed), invalid/duplicate/non-IPv4 config entries, that a bad
entry does not fail config validation, the union set and its signature, a
deterministic guest start/stop lifecycle asserting both the rebuild points and
which subnets' states must be dropped, anchor-reload failure followed by a
successful retry, that reconcile is inert outside firewall mode, ifconfig member
parsing against real bridge output, and the trust decision per interface -
including everything that must NOT qualify: a Thunderbolt bridge, a
public-range VM bridge, an IPv6-only bridge, an address-less vendor interface, a
physical uplink and a VPN tunnel. docs/firewall-mode.md documents the boundary,
what auto-detection can and cannot prove, the address-family constraint, the
lifecycle/retry behavior, how to confirm the trust set from the log, and that a
resolver running inside the guest is not supported (its encrypted upstream
leaves the host nothing to allowlist).
Restore the previously merged macOS VPN DNS post-settle refresh,
unchanged-exemption suppression, forced pf state flush, and self-upgrade
test after they were removed by the firewall-mode merge.
Also keep Windows NRPT pointed at loopback when the listener is configured
on a wildcard address.
When IPv6 is available locally but the selected IPv6 DoH endpoint is
unroutable (e.g. dialing [2606:1a40::22]:443 returns "no route to host"
while IPv4 stays usable), ctrld re-bootstrapped and re-dialed the endpoint
every ~2s. A weekend soak produced ~46.7k "no route to host" lines, with
the dial/health-check loop dominating the log during bad windows.
Add bounded backoff/suppression for network-unreachable endpoints at two
levels:
- ParallelDialer (internal/net): track dial addresses that fail with
ENETUNREACH/EHOSTUNREACH and skip them for an exponentially growing,
bounded window (5s -> 60s). A successful dial clears the entry
immediately, so recovery is preserved when the route returns. When every
candidate is suppressed the dial fails fast and quietly instead of
hammering known-unroutable addresses.
- Upstream recovery loop (cmd/cli): demote unreachable check failures to
debug and back off the retry cadence (2s -> 60s) for an unreachable
streak; any other failure resets to the base cadence.
The new IsUnreachable classifier lives in internal/net and is reused by
cmd/cli's errNetworkError, so the unreachable-errno matching has a single
definition. Note the explicit winsock constants (10051/10065) are required
on Windows: syscall.ENETUNREACH/EHOSTUNREACH are Go's portable "invented"
values and never equal the raw WSA codes a failing connect surfaces.
Suppression and backoff are always bounded, so IPv6 is never disabled until
restart and recovers on its own once the route is back. Split-stack
selection and the #549 macOS intercept recovery work are untouched.
Adds unit tests for the classifier, the dialer's suppression tracker, and
the recovery backoff schedule.
When WFP loopback protect is active, the upstream.os healthcheck will
always fail because an external WFP block filter is interfering with
plain DNS. This demotes those expected failures to debug level and
returns errOsHealthcheckSuppressed so the recovery loop treats them
as non-fatal, eliminating the log spam described in #526.
When port 53 is taken (e.g. by mDNSResponder), ctrld failed with
'could not find available listen ip and port' instead of falling back
to port 5354. Root cause: tryUpdateListenerConfig() checked the
dnsIntercept bool, which is derived in prog.run() AFTER listener
config is resolved.
Fix: check interceptMode string directly (CLI flag + config fallback)
in a new tryUpdateListenerConfigIntercept() that tries 127.0.0.1:53
then 127.0.0.1:5354.
Also updates buildPFAnchorRules() to use the actual listener IP/port
from config instead of hardcoded 127.0.0.1:53, so pf rules redirect
to wherever ctrld is actually listening.
- Update comment in ensurePFAnchorReference: pfctl -sn returns
rdr-anchor only (nat-anchor not used by ctrld)
- Update nat-anchor table entry in pf-dns-intercept.md
- Add pf nuances 10-16 from investigation: cross-AF redirect,
block return, sendmsg EINVAL, nat-on-lo0, raw sockets, DIOCNATLOOK,
and the pragmatic IPv6 block solution
Dev Scribe