feat(preamble): add "Handling 5+ options — split, never drop" rule

Agents repeatedly hit Conductor's 4-option AskUserQuestion cap and
silently drop one option to fit, shrinking the user's decision space.
This rule names the bug and gives two compliant shapes: batch into
≤4-groups (for coherent alternatives) or split into N sequential
per-option calls (for independent scope items, default).

Inline preamble subsection is ~15 lines (rule + buckets + pointer).
Full reference with worked examples, Hold/dependency semantics, and
final-summary validation lives in docs/askuserquestion-split.md.
The agent loads the docs file on demand when N>4.

Per-option call shape: D<N>.k header, ELI10, Recommendation, kind-note
(no completeness score — decision actions, not coverage), Include /
Defer / Cut / Hold buckets. Hold stops the chain immediately; the
final D<N>.final call validates dependencies and confirms the
assembled scope.

question_ids: <skill>-split-<option-slug> (kebab-case ASCII, ≤64
chars). Also fixes orphan "12. " prefix on the existing CJK rule.

Tier-2+ skills inherit via the existing resolver. SKILL.md regenerated
for all 41 affected skills + 3 golden fixtures. Net diff per SKILL.md:
~34 lines (vs ~110 for the full inline version).

6 tests pin the inline contract (4-option cap, buckets, D-numbering,
docs pointer, runtime AUTO_DECIDE gate reference, orphan 12 regression).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Garry Tan
2026-05-26 22:27:44 -07:00
parent cf50443b63
commit f2e2ef15d9
47 changed files with 1743 additions and 45 deletions
+42
View File
@@ -119,3 +119,45 @@ describe('generateAskUserFormat — v1.7.0.0 Pros/Cons format', () => {
expect(out).toMatch(/Per-skill instructions may add/);
});
});
describe('generateAskUserFormat — 5+ option split rule (slim inline + docs pointer)', () => {
const out = generateAskUserFormat(makeCtx());
// 5 highest-signal pins. The full rule lives in
// docs/askuserquestion-split.md; this contract only checks what the
// inline subsection MUST surface so the agent can act without
// reading the docs file for routine 5-option splits.
test('forbids dropping options to fit the 4-option cap', () => {
expect(out).toMatch(/caps every call at \*\*4 options\*\*/);
expect(out).toMatch(/NEVER\s+drop, merge, or silently defer/);
});
test('names the Include / Defer / Cut / Hold buckets', () => {
expect(out).toMatch(/A\) Include/);
expect(out).toMatch(/B\) Defer/);
expect(out).toMatch(/C\) Cut/);
expect(out).toMatch(/D\) Hold/);
});
test('specifies D<N>.k child numbering and D<N>.final summary', () => {
expect(out).toContain('D<N>.k');
expect(out).toContain('D<N>.final');
});
test('AUTO_DECIDE is gated at runtime, not just collision-resistance', () => {
expect(out).toContain('bin/gstack-question-preference');
expect(out).toContain('*-split-*');
expect(out).toContain('never AUTO_DECIDE-eligible');
});
test('points to docs/askuserquestion-split.md for the full rule', () => {
expect(out).toContain('docs/askuserquestion-split.md');
expect(out).toMatch(/Read on demand when N>4/);
});
test('regression: orphan "12." prefix removed from CJK rule', () => {
expect(out).not.toContain('12. **Non-ASCII');
expect(out).toContain('**Non-ASCII characters');
});
});