qa-only rendered the /qa line 'Put it in the 8e.5 record (/qa) or under each
proposed test (/qa-only)'; judge samples for 'qa-only/SKILL.md workflow'
(actionability at the 4.0 gate in run 37151477069, 3.67 in 36907895813)
flag the /qa-only-irrelevant 8e.5 record. The qa-mode bar now renders the
invoking skill's location; both skills get shorter.
Judge rationales for 'plan-eng-review/SKILL.md sections' (actionability 3.67
in periodic run 37151477069, clarity 3 in 36385945043 and 35567915613) cite
two concrete tensions: 'do not add findings before Scope Challenge C' versus
the ledger saves C itself performs, and 'Recommendation: A when a branch diff
exists' versus 'do not probe for session state'. The write policy now says
findings first enter through Scope Challenge C's ledger saves; the selector
says its Recommendation line advises the user and needs no repository
inspection. The pinned sentence becomes the new meaning-level regex.
Periodic run 37151477069 (plan-eng-review-artifact): a non-interactive review
recorded every Test review choice as pending and never wrote the QA test
plan, because Step 5 said to write the artifact 'when these test and eval
choices are resolved' while the artifact section says to list unresolved
choices as pending. Both now say to write it after the decision gate, with
unanswered choices under Pending Decisions. The pinned sentence becomes a
meaning-level check.
Periodic run 37151477069 refused 'Existing-caller migration and helper
hardening stay out of scope' as a hardening proposal: the actor had two
partial exclusion rules (unanchored is/are/remains outside, and an anchored
list that only stays unchanged), the third refusal at this boundary after
36633323521 and 36776104571. One anchored predicate now covers a bare list
of scope nouns (hyphenated compounds included) with is/are/stays/remains and
unchanged/untouched/excluded/out of scope/outside/not part; any other verb
in the clause is still read as a proposal. Adds the real capture and two
adversarial controls.
Docker's default seccomp profile blocks the user namespaces bubblewrap needs,
so every Codex command in a paid eval failed with 'bwrap: No permissions to
create a new namespace' (codex-review-findings, run 37151477069). Reproduced
in the CI image locally: default profile fails, seccomp=unconfined runs the
command. The runner stays non-root.
validateCodexReview accepted codex-review-findings in periodic run 37151477069
although its only command failed in bwrap ('I couldn't run the review'); it
now requires execution evidence from classifyOutsideReview (B1's INV-1
classifier). codex-sol-scope-termination failed on 'apply_patch verification
failed: invalid hunk' because the skill-load check matched any 'invalid';
it now matches Codex 0.160's skill-loader diagnostics only.
Codex 0.160 refuses to create its helper aliases (codex-linux-sandbox among
them) when CODEX_HOME sits under its temp dir, and the runner put the
hermetic home under the shard TMPDIR. Periodic run 37151477069 shows the
warning and 'Unable to spawn codex-linux-sandbox ... No viable candidates
found in PATH' for every exec_command in codex-sol-scope-termination.
The decision-brief format puts a Pros / cons block with 'A) ... (recommended)'
in the question text and the same marker on the option label. The matrix
counted both and failed all six skills in periodic run 37151477069 with
'expected exactly one (recommended) option, found 2'. The question-preference
hook reads labels only, so the gate now checks the native question: a
Recommendation line in the question text and exactly one label ending in
(recommended). Fixtures move to the native question shape and add the real
spec capture plus a marker-only-in-text negative control.
The memory lane's new db-unreachable status (network or DNS failure, config
intact) is transient, so gbrain-refresh keeps rendering brain-aware blocks
for it exactly as it does for timeout instead of suppressing them.
A copy fails where a symlink dangled, so the Kiro router and upgrade copies
are written only when their render exists (as every other runtime root
already does). test/qa-lazy-sections' extracted Kiro installer now supplies
_link_runtime_dists (C2) and the SKILL.md copy helpers (C3).
Copilot CLI treats a preToolUse exit 2 as deny (its hooks reference), and
#2413 established exit 2 plus hookSpecificOutput as the shape Claude Code
enforces, so the deny output stays as on main; only the matcher and the
in-place upgrade of older 'Skill' entries change.
gstack-gbrain-install read package.json with jq but never checked for it,
so on a machine without jq a successful install failed with "cannot read
version". gstack-gbrain-source-wireup hard-failed without jq ("brew
install jq" is not actionable on git-bash), so the wireup was skipped on
every run. Both now read the JSON with bun, which they already require.
Co-authored-by: benjamin beres <benjamin.beres@bienpreter.com>
The v1.27.0.0 migration passed a bare repo name to gh repo rename / gh
repo edit, which always fails (gh wants [HOST/]OWNER/REPO), then step 2
rewrote ~/.gstack-artifacts-remote.txt to the never-renamed repository.
- Qualify both names with the owner from the recorded remote URL (else
the signed-in gh user) and surface gh's error.
- Step 2 moves the remote file but rewrites the URL only once the rename
is confirmed; a later successful retry rewrites it then.
- A pending journal now counts as state to migrate, so the #1383 retry
actually re-runs step 1 (it used to see no legacy file and declare the
migration done).
- The v1.91.17.0 migration (placeholder name) repairs installs already
hit: when the remote names gstack-artifacts-<user> that does not exist
but gstack-brain-<user> does, it restores the old URL in the remote
file and ~/.gstack's origin and says so. It only calls gh for such a
remote and never fails the upgrade.
Co-authored-by: Brandon Pugsley <aibpaem@gmail.com>
INV-1 consumers in this lane's templates: /ship's readiness note, its
PR body Pre-Landing Review section and /review's completion rule now say
an outside review reporting unverified or unavailable is missing
coverage, never a pass. The PR body's Plan Completion section prints
F1's not-run line instead of the old 'No plan file detected.' The /ship
union-size cap moves to 1.415 for these lines (measured 1.4148).
/sync-gbrain Step 3.5 and the --full auto-dream decision read CYCLE from
gbrain doctor --json --fast, which skips the DB checks that carry
cycle_freshness, so the answer was always "unknown". Both now read
gbrain doctor --json --scope=brain (DB checks, no skill-file walk), parse
its JSON even when doctor exits 1 for a failing check, and match the
issue that names this source: "never completed" is never, "last cycled
Nh ago" is completed. When the installed gbrain does not report the
check, they say "unknown: installed gbrain does not expose
cycle_freshness" (lib readCycleStatus carries the reason to the --full
SKIP row).
The source-probe fixture that pinned the --fast call and a made-up
message format now answers --scope=brain with gbrain's real message.
/sync-gbrain --dream and the --full auto-build ran gbrain's full dream
cycle (~35 minutes, LLM phases) when the call graph needs only the
resolve_symbol_edges phase. The stage now runs
gbrain dream [--source <id>] --phase resolve_symbol_edges when the
installed gbrain accepts that phase (detected by behavior: gbrain
validates --phase before printing --help). Otherwise it skips the forced
dream and says the full cycle costs about 35 minutes and how to run it,
instead of starting it.
Co-authored-by: liutiming <timingliu@outlook.com>
A deleted Conductor worktree leaves its gstack-code-<hash> source behind
and gbrain's autopilot fails on it forever. Local absence is not proof a
source is dead (machines sharing a federated brain register their own
paths, and its pages may be the only copy of uncommitted work), so gstack
never removes one automatically.
- Each sync counts consecutive misses for gstack code sources whose path
is missing, prints "path unavailable" once per source with the review
command, and records which repository each synced source belongs to.
- New gstack-gbrain-sync --prune-gone-worktrees (with --dry-run, whose
plan it always prints first) removes a source only when its path was
missing on two consecutive syncs, its parent is readable, recomputing
deriveCodeSourceId() for that path on this host yields its id, and the
repository's git common dir still exists and no longer lists the
worktree. It re-checks the path right before removing (through the
#1734-guarded safeSourcesRemove) and logs each removal.
The stage reported "curated artifacts pushed" whenever gstack-brain-sync
exited 0, but a git push is not gbrain indexing. After a successful push
the stage now reads the maintained artifacts source's page count
(GSTACK_BRAIN_SOURCE_ID, else the source whose path is the artifacts
worktree or state root): zero pages is ERR with the fix command; a
missing source or an unavailable count says so instead of claiming
indexing.
Co-authored-by: Jimmy Zeisweiss <4261258+jzeisweiss@users.noreply.github.com>
The generator lane's C1 resolves D from $GSTACK_ROOT instead of
$GSTACK_DESIGN, so the test now exports GSTACK_ROOT as well; it still fails
on main (no dist in the roots) and passes with and without the C1 change.
`gbrain import` ran without --source-id, so transcripts from every project
landed in the shared (often federated) default source.
- Each transcript partition imports with --source-id into its originating
repository's own source (gstack-transcripts-<repo>, built with
constrainSourceId, now exported from lib/gbrain-sources.ts). The source
is registered machine-local and --no-federated before its first import,
and the registration is cached in state. Partitions import one after
another (PGLite is a single writer); a failing source no longer blocks
the others, except a timeout, whose checkpoint must survive.
- If gbrain cannot register the source, that partition stays local and
unstamped, and the run says why (even under --quiet).
- --include-unattributed sends repo-less transcripts only to the
machine-local gstack-transcripts-unattributed source, keeps them on the
machine when the brain is remote (Postgres, Supabase or remote-HTTP),
and never writes them to the publishable ~/.gstack/transcripts staging.
- A page's recorded source is sticky: pages stamped before this release
("default") keep importing there, so no source gains a duplicate.
- The staging dir name carries -src-<id> so a resumed import keeps its
source.
Test fakes that recorded only the last import now record every import of
one run, and answer `gbrain sources`; remote-http scan tests use an
attributed transcript, since unattributed ones no longer stage there.
Co-authored-by: Sinabina <sinabina@Sinabinas-MacBook-Pro-4.local>
Callers run '_gstack_codex_timeout_wrapper ... codex exec - < file'. Bash keeps
stdin for a backgrounded command inside a pipeline but not behind a
redirect, so the pipe form passed on the old watchdog; the redirect form
reproduces the lost prompt.
The PreToolUse question-preference hook breaks Conductor's native
AskUserQuestion round-trip even when it only defers (#2207), and setup
auto-installed it on every Conductor workspace setup. Now a Conductor setup
without an explicit opt-in never installs it and removes an existing one
(the question-log and AUQ-error hooks stay), printing how to keep it
(gstack-config set plan_tune_hooks yes). An explicit opt-in still installs
it. gstack-settings-hook remove-source gains --event to scope the removal.
Test migration: setup-plan-tune-hooks-noninteractive pinned the retired
Conductor auto-opt-in.
Co-authored-by: Phil Hie <philhie@outlook.com>
The census recognized only JS/TS-style names, so pytest and minitest
(test_*.py|rb), XCTest (Tests/ dirs, FooTests.swift), Terraform
(*.tftest.hcl) and Bats (*.bats) suites counted as zero, and a committed
build directory counted as authored code (and its Test/ subdirs as test
LOC). is_test now knows those conventions and never treats prose as a
test, generated output is skipped in the numstat pass, TEST_FILES_CHANGED
uses is_test, and TEST_FILES_TOTAL uses the same filename conventions
minus generated paths. Merges #2812, #2809 and #2037's patterns (#2037's
retro template edits target a block the metrics bin replaced).
Co-authored-by: Jino <dgfrty00@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: snig-17 <santosh.m.tiwari@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Sholto McNeilage <sholto@nodenarrative.com.au>
Outside reviews are on by default and use whatever Codex login exists
(#965). The first automatic Codex review on a machine now prints one
non-blocking notice: the provider (config.toml model_provider, else openai),
where the credential comes from (CODEX_API_KEY, OPENAI_API_KEY, the ChatGPT
login or the key saved by codex login; never the value), that reviews stay
on, and how to turn them off (gstack-config set codex_reviews disabled). A
marker in the gstack state root keeps it to once per machine. Tests that run
the generated command now use private state roots. Also shortens the
no-sandbox provenance line.
The duration step parsed 'ps -o lstart=' with BSD-only 'date -jf', so on
Linux session_duration_s was always unknown. It now falls back to GNU
'date -d', and never parses an empty start (GNU reads that as midnight).
Ported onto the current block instead of #2704's ~/.gstack/sessions
mtime, which bypassed the state root.
Co-authored-by: Evgenii Lopatin <e75533@gmail.com>
Under Git Bash, a native Windows Python first on PATH cannot open an MSYS
/c/... path, so gbrain-refresh always summarized the detection as
'local-status: unknown' and brain-aware blocks were suppressed. bash now
opens the file and Python reads stdin; the grep fallback without Python is
unchanged. Verified on Linux with a stub Python that refuses path opens; not
run on Windows.
Co-authored-by: maxpetrusenkoagent <max.petrusenko.agent@gmail.com>
The Windows SDK's winbase.h raises C5105, which /W4 /WX promotes to error
C2220, so every MSVC build of the native /cso helper failed, and setup
mapped every probe failure to 'install Visual Studio 2022 Build Tools'.
Both compile lines add /wd5105 (only that diagnostic), and setup keeps the
probe's output: a probe that found MSVC but failed to compile reports
windows-msvc-compile with the compiler's first error. Not run on Windows:
the mapping test stubs powershell.exe; the ps1 assertion runs everywhere.
Co-authored-by: AlinValentin7 <AlinValentin7@users.noreply.github.com>
bumpPref computed every entry's confidence from approved_count, so a
rejected entry, which never gains approvals, stayed at 0: show ranked
rejections by insertion order and the taste-drift warning could not
fire from real use. Confidence now uses the entry's own bucket count.
Also salvaged by Garry's #2971.
Co-authored-by: Jayesh Betala <jayesh.betala7@gmail.com>
gstack-skill-end writes duration_s as a quoted string, and the per-skill
average stripped everything from the leading quote, so every average
read 0s. The awk now drops a leading quote before extracting digits.
Co-authored-by: Ryan Alberts <ryan.a.alberts@gmail.com>
Prompts went to Codex as one argv string ('codex exec "$(cat file)"'), which
fails over 32 KB on Windows (and over 128 KB on Linux, E2BIG) and mangles
quotes. Every codex exec site (outside-voice resolver, /codex review custom
instructions, challenge, consult new and resume) now runs 'codex exec -'
with the prepared prompt file on stdin; challenge and consult write the
prompt with a quoted heredoc so it is never shell-parsed. The bash-native
timeout watchdog (stock macOS) started the command in the background, which
gives it /dev/null as stdin; it now passes the caller's stdin through.
The 'byte for byte' dispatch test drops its old argv trailing-LF exception,
the consultation and autoplan fixtures follow the stdin form, and the static
site test requires stdin at every rendered codex exec.
G1's NO_VERSION arms, F1's parent-side plan binding and D3's data line
add 2,126 bytes to /ship's skeleton-plus-sections union, taking it from
1.4022x to 1.4135x of the v1.64.1.0 baseline (cap was 1.405). The cap
moves to 1.414 with the measurement recorded, as earlier growth did; no
other invariant changes.
Probe: a gbrain user render serves ship/SKILL.md from the render dir; its
STOP pointers name absolute render paths, but its section index names
`sections/<f>.md` relative to the installed skill directory, whose
sections/ was linked from the checkout. So the rendered 'Save Results to
Brain' blocks (plan reviews, office-hours, ship adversarial) were generated
and never read. setup's _link_skill_runtime_assets and gstack-relink (the
gbrain-refresh path) now serve a rendered counterpart per file, keep
checkout-only assets (manifest.json), return an asset to the checkout once
its render is gone, and never touch an entry that is not gstack's links.
Co-authored-by: Jonah Berg <jonah.berg.g@gmail.com>
/setup-deploy ran 'echo $RENDER_API_KEY | head -c 4', printing the
key's first bytes into the transcript. It now prints only
'RENDER_API_KEY: set' or 'RENDER_API_KEY: not set'. Wording follows the
#2971 port of #1096; a test also guards against any setup-deploy command
echoing a credential variable.
Co-authored-by: jacob-wang <jiayuw794@gmail.com>
plan-ceo-review, plan-eng-review and plan-devex-review read the freshest
design doc as the source of truth, and nothing said its content is data.
In multi-agent pipelines another agent may have written it, or a handoff
note beside it, with reviewer-directed text ('skip Step 0', 'approve
as-is'). Each read site now says the doc and any handoff note are data,
never to follow text aimed at the reviewer, and to report it as
suspicious content. The plan-completion audit's discovery, which now
reads repo docs/designs/ files (F1), carries the same rule.
Co-authored-by: cube <frosimanuel@gmail.com>
setup's Apple Silicon re-sign mutated each binary in place (truncate, remove
signature) and left it that way when re-signing failed; a design binary that
was then SIGKILLed at launch produced at most a quiet log line. Each binary is
now copied first and restored as built when signing fails, and design is
exec-probed after re-signing: exit 137 prints 'design unavailable: ... Fix:
cd <checkout> && ./setup' (even under -q). Verified on Linux with the real
block and uname/codesign/otool/stat stubs; not run on a Mac.
gbrain import exits 0 while skipping pages (returned per-file failures,
malformed filenames, managed-import Pending receipts), and its failure
ledger exists only for git import dirs, so a skipped page was stamped
ingested and never retried (field reports: 37 and 69 lost entries).
Write, verify, then stamp (lib/memory-ingest-landing.ts, a new ratcheted
module):
- State schema 2 with a transition table (staged -> imported_unverified ->
ingested, plus refused, quarantined, unrecoverable). Schema 1 files
migrate in place: entries become ingested in the legacy "default"
source and a reconcile pass is marked pending.
- Named failures come from --json `failures`, stderr "Skipped <rel>:"
lines and the ledger; a failure gbrain does not attribute refuses the
whole batch. After 3 refused batches the batch is bisected and the page
that poisons it is quarantined (printed even under --quiet).
- Landing check: one `gbrain list --source-id` per source per run and at
most 50 `gbrain get --json` content checks against a
gstack_content_sha256 frontmatter field gstack now writes. Lookup errors
and pglite_busy mean "not yet checked", never absent; pages over the cap
stay imported_unverified and are not re-imported.
- Each entry records its gbrain source_id. Remote-http mode records
"staged", never "ingested".
- The source fingerprint comes from the exact bytes parsed, so a
transcript that grows during import is not stamped as its newer self
(the old unscanned contract test is migrated; it pinned that bug).
- --reconcile mode (bounded by --limit, default 200; resumable; --dry-run;
backs up the state file) prints "reconcile: checked N, present M,
re-queued K, not yet checked L". --request-reconcile records a pending
pass without calling gbrain; the v1.91.17.0 migration (placeholder name)
uses it, and the next ingest run does one bounded pass.
- One lock for every state writer; a state-save failure fails the run.
The #1802 static pins in regression-1611 move to the new structure
(remote-http returns before importBatch; the finally honors
preserveStaging).
Co-authored-by: afshaker <andrew@phone2.io>
Stats printed CALIBRATED: true from logged-answer counts alone, while
every answer could miss SIGNAL_MAP and leave each dimension at its 0.5
seed (#2623). --derive now records inferred.signal_events, the answers
that actually moved a dimension; calibration requires at least one, and
the summary prints 'not calibrated: no recorded signals' verbatim when
there are none (or says the count is unknown for a profile derived
before this change). The psychographic redesign stays out of scope.
The auth probe only knew CODEX_API_KEY, OPENAI_API_KEY and auth.json, so a
working self-hosted or OpenAI-compatible provider configured with
[model_providers.<id>] env_key = "X" reported AUTH_FAILED and /codex
stopped. The probe now reads env_key from model_providers tables only
(comments ignored, the name must be a shell identifier before it is
dereferenced) and accepts a set variable; when none is set it names the
missing key on stderr. Ported from #2192 with the table scoping added.
Co-authored-by: hardy <932821449@qq.com>
Copilot CLI applies Claude-format matchers by tool name; its skill tool is
`skill`, which no Claude tool name maps to, so the 'Skill' matcher never
fired and Copilot ran protected skills without gstack. The hook entry now
matches 'Skill|skill', an entry an older team-init wrote is upgraded in
place, and the deny is emitted in both decision formats (Copilot reads the
top-level permissionDecision, Claude Code reads hookSpecificOutput) with
exit 0 so both parse it.
Test migration: the settings test pinned matcher 'Skill'.
Co-authored-by: neallee <neallee@gmail.com>
A more specific query used to drop the exact match: the token-OR filter
recalled every entry sharing one token, the sort used confidence alone,
and the default --limit cut silently. Entries now rank by how many
distinct query tokens they match, then confidence, then recency, and a
query that matched more than fit says '-- N more matched, raise --limit
to see them'. The hit count lives in a local map so a field stored on
disk can never become a sort key, and the type grouping uses a
null-prototype map so a row typed 'constructor' or '__proto__' cannot
crash the run. Ranking code ported from #2796; regression vectors
adapted from #2799 (its stemmer is not needed).
Co-authored-by: loulanyue <260355617@qq.com>
Co-authored-by: y$un_ <forrest.sun527@gmail.com>
The model probe matched only 400 / 'is not supported', so a retired model's
404 ('does not exist or you do not have access to it') and a custom
provider's bare 404 fell through to the inconclusive branch and reported
ready. Both now classify as MODEL_UNUSABLE with a hint naming the two causes
(retired model, or a wrong base_url) and log codex_model_retired; a
'requires a newer version of Codex' 400 points at upgrading the CLI and logs
codex_cli_outdated. Ported from #2843 onto the current probe.
Co-authored-by: Marek Cermak <marek.cermak@strv.com>
gstack-learnings-search and gstack-timeline-read ended in
'2>/dev/null || exit 0', so a missing bun or a crashed embedded script
printed nothing and exited 0, identical to 'nothing recorded'. Both now
exit 127 with '<script>: bun not found on PATH, so ... could not be
read. Fix: install Bun (https://bun.sh), then re-run ./setup.' and let
an embedded-script failure exit non-zero with its stderr. A successful
run with no matches still exits 0 with empty output. The generated
callers that print 'LEARNINGS: unavailable (...)' belong to the
generator lane.
Co-authored-by: loulanyue <260355617@qq.com>
relink skipped a hardcoded list of support-directory names that included
browse, a real skill, so toggling skill_prefix removed /browse. A top-level
directory is now a skill exactly when it carries a SKILL.md.
Co-authored-by: Jonathan Zhang <topcoder1@Mac-Studio.local>
In containers without unprivileged user namespaces every Codex command
fails, yet the review exits 0 and concludes 'no findings' (captured in
test/fixtures/codex-sandbox/). The validator now takes execution evidence:
'codex exec --json' command events and the 'codex review' stderr transcript
(a command that succeeded proves execution); sandbox failure lines on
stderr or in failed command output return unavailable(sandbox_unavailable);
exact 'could not run commands / read the diff' phrases are the last
fallback. Review text that merely discusses bwrap or namespaces still passes.
A free 'codex sandbox ... true' preflight (Linux, 10 s) runs before the paid
model probe and every automatic outside review; CODEX_MODE gains
sandbox_unavailable, and an inconclusive model probe reports unverified
instead of ready (exit code kept for stale callers). Every Codex site
(outside-voice resolver, /codex review, challenge, consult) takes its sandbox
from _GSTACK_CODEX_SANDBOX and pipes its result through the validator; a
static test parses rendered command positions for both. GSTACK_CODEX_NO_SANDBOX=1
(exactly 1, shell env only) switches to danger-full-access with a warning on
every use. Sandbox pins in existing tests move from the literal read-only to
the selected-sandbox variable; captured autoplan probes are judged against
the probe block they executed.
garrytan