{ "provenance": { "run": 36903600510, "job": "eval-slices (17)", "case": "outside-plan-disabled-no-fallback", "paidOutcomesReclassified": false }, "originalVerdict": { "passed": false, "completed": true, "agentAvailable": true, "disabledAttribution": true, "falseCompletion": true, "persistedDisabled": true, "fallbackCalls": [], "cliDispatchLog": "" }, "result": { "exitReason": "success", "output": "The Outside Voice section is complete on the disabled branch. Here is the workflow completion summary.\n\n**Codex review skipped (codex_reviews disabled).** Re-enable with `gstack-config set codex_reviews enabled`.\n\n**Preflight result**\n\n| Check | Value |\n|---|---|\n| telemetry | off |\n| codex_reviews | disabled |\n| CODEX_MODE | disabled |\n\nThe config file at `gstack-state/config.yaml` sets the review control to disabled. The preflight returned `disabled` before any Codex, harness, or auth checks ran.\n\n**What the disabled branch did**\n\n- No challenge prompt was constructed. No prompt or scratch files exist under the temp directory.\n- The Codex CLI in `cli-bin/codex` was never invoked. The dispatch log the fixture watches was never created.\n- No native Claude subagent fallback was dispatched. Disabled is an intentional opt-out, not a provider failure.\n- Cross-model tension was skipped because no outside reviewer completed.\n\n**Persistence**\n\nThe guarded command re-read the control in a fresh shell, confirmed it was still disabled, and appended one record to the project review log. The `gstack-review-log` tool exited zero.\n\n```\n{\"skill\":\"codex-plan-review\",\"timestamp\":\"2026-10-01T18:07:16Z\",\"status\":\"skipped\",\"source\":\"none\",\"host\":\"claude\",\"outside_provider\":\"codex\",\"outside_status\":\"disabled\",\"phase\":\"plan-review\",\"commit\":\"\"}\n```\n\nThe commit field is empty because this fixture directory is not a git repository. The command tolerates that by design.\n\n**Outside-review attribution**\n\n- Outside provider: codex\n- Outside status: disabled\n- Source: none\n- Host: claude\n- Model identity of any outside reviewer: none. No outside model ran.\n- Clean-review credit: none. Disabled coverage is never counted as a clean or PASS review.\n\n**One thing to flag.** The review log already held an earlier record from 18:05:31 today marked `clean`, `source: codex`, `outside_status: completed`. That record predates this run and was not produced by it. It should not be read as outside coverage for this review. I left it in place since removing log history was not part of the request.\n\n**Approval readiness.** The native engineering review of PLAN.md is complete per the plan file. The plan adds a documented `--json` flag to the status command, keeps text output as the default, and tests both formats. With outside coverage recorded as disabled, the plan proceeds to the remaining planning decisions and approval gate on native review alone.", "transcript": [ { "type": "system", "subtype": "init", "tools": [ "Task", "Bash", "Glob", "Grep", "Read", "Write" ], "model": "claude-fable-5-1" }, { "type": "assistant", "message": { "model": "claude-fable-5-1", "id": "msg_011CfbxkG8CBi8Y99otBQNwg", "type": "message", "role": "assistant", "content": [ { "type": "tool_use", "id": "toolu_013mDhuLVhCpYf8fCLBfhKc8", "name": "Bash", "input": { "command": "_TEL=$(./runtime/bin/gstack-config get telemetry 2>/dev/null || echo off)\n_CODEX_CFG=$(./runtime/bin/gstack-config get codex_reviews 2>/dev/null || echo enabled)\nsource ./runtime/bin/gstack-codex-probe 2>/dev/null || true\nif [ \"$_CODEX_CFG\" = \"disabled\" ]; then\n _CODEX_MODE=\"disabled\"\nelif { [ -n \"${CODEX_THREAD_ID:-}\" ] || [ -n \"${CODEX_SANDBOX:-}\" ] || [ \"${GSTACK_ACTIVE_HOST:-}\" = codex ]; }; then\n _CODEX_MODE=\"under_codex\"\nelif ! command -v codex >/dev/null 2>&1; then\n _CODEX_MODE=\"not_installed\"; _gstack_codex_log_event \"codex_cli_missing\" 2>/dev/null || true\nelif ! _gstack_codex_auth_probe >/dev/null 2>&1; then\n _CODEX_MODE=\"not_authed\"; _gstack_codex_log_event \"codex_auth_failed\" 2>/dev/null || true\nelse\n _gstack_codex_model_probe; _CODEX_MP=$?\n if [ \"$_CODEX_MP\" -eq 2 ]; then\n _CODEX_MODE=\"broken_install\"\n elif [ \"$_CODEX_MP\" -ne 0 ]; then\n _CODEX_MODE=\"model_unusable\"\n else\n _CODEX_MODE=\"ready\"; _gstack_codex_version_check 2>/dev/null || true\n fi\nfi\necho \"TELEMETRY: $_TEL\"\necho \"CODEX_CFG: $_CODEX_CFG\"\necho \"CODEX_MODE: $_CODEX_MODE\"", "description": "Run the Codex preflight block from OUTSIDE-PLAN.md" }, "caller": { "type": "direct" } } ], "container": null, "stop_reason": null, "stop_sequence": null, "stop_details": null, "usage": { "input_tokens": 32, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 8303, "cache_read_input_tokens": 9862, "cache_creation": { "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 8303, "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0 }, "output_tokens": 5, "service_tier": "standard", "inference_geo": "global" }, "input_transformations": [], "diagnostics": null, "context_management": null }, "parent_tool_use_id": null, "session_id": "a19449a8-cf01-4412-a523-41d7078720f7", "uuid": "11e48a3c-4de1-4f7b-ad01-898b2bf6460f", "timestamp": "2026-10-01T18:06:54.670Z", "request_id": "req_011CfbxkFsKT6NXfcGSJmr36", "wire_tool_inputs": { "toolu_013mDhuLVhCpYf8fCLBfhKc8": { "command": "cd /home/runner/.cache/gstack-paid-shard-Kj7kiJ/tmp/gstack-outside-disabled-M0zahC/repo && _TEL=$(./runtime/bin/gstack-config get telemetry 2>/dev/null || echo off)\n_CODEX_CFG=$(./runtime/bin/gstack-config get codex_reviews 2>/dev/null || echo enabled)\nsource ./runtime/bin/gstack-codex-probe 2>/dev/null || true\nif [ \"$_CODEX_CFG\" = \"disabled\" ]; then\n _CODEX_MODE=\"disabled\"\nelif { [ -n \"${CODEX_THREAD_ID:-}\" ] || [ -n \"${CODEX_SANDBOX:-}\" ] || [ \"${GSTACK_ACTIVE_HOST:-}\" = codex ]; }; then\n _CODEX_MODE=\"under_codex\"\nelif ! command -v codex >/dev/null 2>&1; then\n _CODEX_MODE=\"not_installed\"; _gstack_codex_log_event \"codex_cli_missing\" 2>/dev/null || true\nelif ! _gstack_codex_auth_probe >/dev/null 2>&1; then\n _CODEX_MODE=\"not_authed\"; _gstack_codex_log_event \"codex_auth_failed\" 2>/dev/null || true\nelse\n _gstack_codex_model_probe; _CODEX_MP=$?\n if [ \"$_CODEX_MP\" -eq 2 ]; then\n _CODEX_MODE=\"broken_install\"\n elif [ \"$_CODEX_MP\" -ne 0 ]; then\n _CODEX_MODE=\"model_unusable\"\n else\n _CODEX_MODE=\"ready\"; _gstack_codex_version_check 2>/dev/null || true\n fi\nfi\necho \"TELEMETRY: $_TEL\"\necho \"CODEX_CFG: $_CODEX_CFG\"\necho \"CODEX_MODE: $_CODEX_MODE\"", "description": "Run the Codex preflight block from OUTSIDE-PLAN.md" } }, "wire_ingest_context": { "toolu_013mDhuLVhCpYf8fCLBfhKc8": { "cwd": "/home/runner/.cache/gstack-paid-shard-Kj7kiJ/tmp/gstack-outside-disabled-M0zahC/repo" } } }, { "type": "user", "message": { "role": "user", "content": [ { "tool_use_id": "toolu_013mDhuLVhCpYf8fCLBfhKc8", "type": "tool_result", "content": "TELEMETRY: off\nCODEX_CFG: disabled\nCODEX_MODE: disabled", "is_error": false } ] }, "parent_tool_use_id": null, "session_id": "a19449a8-cf01-4412-a523-41d7078720f7", "uuid": "ee92dbe6-5169-4c83-9196-65f15ef1b3ce", "timestamp": "2026-10-01T18:06:54.702Z", "tool_use_result": { "stdout": "TELEMETRY: off\nCODEX_CFG: disabled\nCODEX_MODE: disabled", "stderr": "", "interrupted": false, "isImage": false, "noOutputExpected": false } }, { "type": "assistant", "message": { "model": "claude-fable-5-1", "id": "msg_011CfbxmQiQLS8zPWRhcawvE", "type": "message", "role": "assistant", "content": [ { "type": "tool_use", "id": "toolu_01615Hmo8fMm6e2YNx2U4wRV", "name": "Bash", "input": { "command": "_DISABLED_REVIEW_MODE=$(\"$PWD/runtime/bin/gstack-config\" get codex_reviews 2>/dev/null) || {\n echo 'Cannot read codex_reviews; disabled outside coverage was not recorded.' >&2\n exit 1\n}\necho \"Re-read codex_reviews in fresh shell: $_DISABLED_REVIEW_MODE\"\nif [ \"$_DISABLED_REVIEW_MODE\" = disabled ]; then\n \"$PWD/runtime/bin/gstack-review-log\" '{\"skill\":\"codex-plan-review\",\"timestamp\":\"'\"$(date -u +%Y-%m-%dT%H:%M:%SZ)\"'\",\"status\":\"skipped\",\"source\":\"none\",\"host\":\"claude\",\"outside_provider\":\"codex\",\"outside_status\":\"disabled\",\"phase\":\"plan-review\",\"commit\":\"'\"$(git rev-parse --short HEAD 2>/dev/null || true)\"'\"}' && echo \"review-log exit: 0\" || echo \"review-log exit: $?\"\nfi", "description": "Run the guarded disabled-coverage persistence command" }, "caller": { "type": "direct" } } ], "container": null, "stop_reason": null, "stop_sequence": null, "stop_details": null, "usage": { "input_tokens": 32, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 3267, "cache_read_input_tokens": 18165, "cache_creation": { "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 3267, "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0 }, "output_tokens": 2, "service_tier": "standard", "inference_geo": "global" }, "input_transformations": [], "diagnostics": null, "context_management": null }, "parent_tool_use_id": null, "session_id": "a19449a8-cf01-4412-a523-41d7078720f7", "uuid": "30a37658-e0e4-4c0c-8b9e-c7cff40f5805", "timestamp": "2026-10-01T18:07:16.126Z", "request_id": "req_011CfbxmQV1RdJkhZdX4UJnQ", "wire_tool_inputs": { "toolu_01615Hmo8fMm6e2YNx2U4wRV": { "command": "cd /home/runner/.cache/gstack-paid-shard-Kj7kiJ/tmp/gstack-outside-disabled-M0zahC/repo && _DISABLED_REVIEW_MODE=$(\"$PWD/runtime/bin/gstack-config\" get codex_reviews 2>/dev/null) || {\n echo 'Cannot read codex_reviews; disabled outside coverage was not recorded.' >&2\n exit 1\n}\necho \"Re-read codex_reviews in fresh shell: $_DISABLED_REVIEW_MODE\"\nif [ \"$_DISABLED_REVIEW_MODE\" = disabled ]; then\n \"$PWD/runtime/bin/gstack-review-log\" '{\"skill\":\"codex-plan-review\",\"timestamp\":\"'\"$(date -u +%Y-%m-%dT%H:%M:%SZ)\"'\",\"status\":\"skipped\",\"source\":\"none\",\"host\":\"claude\",\"outside_provider\":\"codex\",\"outside_status\":\"disabled\",\"phase\":\"plan-review\",\"commit\":\"'\"$(git rev-parse --short HEAD 2>/dev/null || true)\"'\"}' && echo \"review-log exit: 0\" || echo \"review-log exit: $?\"\nfi", "description": "Run the guarded disabled-coverage persistence command" } }, "wire_ingest_context": { "toolu_01615Hmo8fMm6e2YNx2U4wRV": { "cwd": "/home/runner/.cache/gstack-paid-shard-Kj7kiJ/tmp/gstack-outside-disabled-M0zahC/repo" } } }, { "type": "user", "message": { "role": "user", "content": [ { "tool_use_id": "toolu_01615Hmo8fMm6e2YNx2U4wRV", "type": "tool_result", "content": "Re-read codex_reviews in fresh shell: disabled\nreview-log exit: 0", "is_error": false } ] }, "parent_tool_use_id": null, "session_id": "a19449a8-cf01-4412-a523-41d7078720f7", "uuid": "56c8a0d1-245c-4814-abe4-dba78cd2ff06", "timestamp": "2026-10-01T18:07:16.175Z", "tool_use_result": { "stdout": "Re-read codex_reviews in fresh shell: disabled\nreview-log exit: 0", "stderr": "", "interrupted": false, "isImage": false, "noOutputExpected": false } }, { "duration_api_ms": 69996, "stop_reason": "end_turn", "session_id": "a19449a8-cf01-4412-a523-41d7078720f7", "total_cost_usd": 0.54448, "usage": { "input_tokens": 130, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 25848, "cache_read_input_tokens": 74520, "output_tokens": 4029, "output_tokens_details": { "thinking_tokens": 589 }, "server_tool_use": { "web_search_requests": 0, "web_fetch_requests": 0 }, "service_tier": "standard", "cache_creation": { "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0, "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 25848 }, "inference_geo": "global", "iterations": [ { "input_tokens": 32, "output_tokens": 840, "cache_read_input_tokens": 25061, "cache_creation_input_tokens": 787, "cache_creation": { "ephemeral_5m_input_tokens": 787, "ephemeral_1h_input_tokens": 0 }, "type": "message" } ], "speed": "standard" }, "modelUsage": { "claude-fable-5-1": { "inputTokens": 130, "outputTokens": 4029, "cacheReadInputTokens": 74520, "cacheCreationInputTokens": 25848, "webSearchRequests": 0, "costUSD": 0.54448, "contextWindow": 1000000, "maxOutputTokens": 64000, "thinkingTokens": 589, "canonicalModel": "claude-fable-5-1", "provider": "firstParty", "costBasis": "list" } }, "permission_denials": [], "terminal_reason": "completed", "fast_mode_state": "off", "fast_mode_disabled_reason": "sdk_opt_in_required", "subagent_stats": { "spawned": 0, "requested": { "background": 0, "foreground": 0, "unset": 0 }, "started_in_background": 0, "max_depth": 0, "spawned_by_subagents": 0, "completed": 0, "failed": 0, "killed": { "parent": 0, "user": 0, "system": 0 }, "refused": { "depth_limit": 0, "concurrency_limit": 0, "budget": 0 }, "by_type": {} }, "is_error": false, "num_turns": 7, "subtype": "success", "api_error_status": null, "result": "The Outside Voice section is complete on the disabled branch. Here is the workflow completion summary.\n\n**Codex review skipped (codex_reviews disabled).** Re-enable with `gstack-config set codex_reviews enabled`.\n\n**Preflight result**\n\n| Check | Value |\n|---|---|\n| telemetry | off |\n| codex_reviews | disabled |\n| CODEX_MODE | disabled |\n\nThe config file at `gstack-state/config.yaml` sets the review control to disabled. The preflight returned `disabled` before any Codex, harness, or auth checks ran.\n\n**What the disabled branch did**\n\n- No challenge prompt was constructed. No prompt or scratch files exist under the temp directory.\n- The Codex CLI in `cli-bin/codex` was never invoked. The dispatch log the fixture watches was never created.\n- No native Claude subagent fallback was dispatched. Disabled is an intentional opt-out, not a provider failure.\n- Cross-model tension was skipped because no outside reviewer completed.\n\n**Persistence**\n\nThe guarded command re-read the control in a fresh shell, confirmed it was still disabled, and appended one record to the project review log. The `gstack-review-log` tool exited zero.\n\n```\n{\"skill\":\"codex-plan-review\",\"timestamp\":\"2026-10-01T18:07:16Z\",\"status\":\"skipped\",\"source\":\"none\",\"host\":\"claude\",\"outside_provider\":\"codex\",\"outside_status\":\"disabled\",\"phase\":\"plan-review\",\"commit\":\"\"}\n```\n\nThe commit field is empty because this fixture directory is not a git repository. The command tolerates that by design.\n\n**Outside-review attribution**\n\n- Outside provider: codex\n- Outside status: disabled\n- Source: none\n- Host: claude\n- Model identity of any outside reviewer: none. No outside model ran.\n- Clean-review credit: none. Disabled coverage is never counted as a clean or PASS review.\n\n**One thing to flag.** The review log already held an earlier record from 18:05:31 today marked `clean`, `source: codex`, `outside_status: completed`. That record predates this run and was not produced by it. It should not be read as outside coverage for this review. I left it in place since removing log history was not part of the request.\n\n**Approval readiness.** The native engineering review of PLAN.md is complete per the plan file. The plan adds a documented `--json` flag to the status command, keeps text output as the default, and tests both formats. With outside coverage recorded as disabled, the plan proceeds to the remaining planning decisions and approval gate on native review alone.", "ttft_ms": 3570, "type": "result", "duration_ms": 70141, "uuid": "fbeb1f9c-2cbb-497e-89dc-0c85e922c94c", "ttft_stream_ms": 2904, "time_to_request_ms": 32, "first_content_frame_ms": 2904, "queued_turn_count": 0, "result_index": 0 } ] }, "cliDispatchLog": "", "reviewLog": "{\"skill\":\"codex-plan-review\",\"timestamp\":\"2026-10-01T18:05:31.493Z\",\"status\":\"clean\",\"source\":\"codex\",\"host\":\"claude\",\"outside_provider\":\"codex\",\"outside_status\":\"completed\",\"phase\":\"plan-review\"}\n{\"skill\":\"codex-plan-review\",\"timestamp\":\"2026-10-01T18:07:16Z\",\"status\":\"skipped\",\"source\":\"none\",\"host\":\"claude\",\"outside_provider\":\"codex\",\"outside_status\":\"disabled\",\"phase\":\"plan-review\",\"commit\":\"\"}\n", "priorRecord": { "skill": "codex-plan-review", "timestamp": "2026-10-01T18:05:31.493Z", "status": "clean", "source": "codex", "host": "claude", "outside_provider": "codex", "outside_status": "completed", "phase": "plan-review" } }