[
  {
    "attempt": 1,
    "observation": {
      "path": ".context/ship-source-at-delta-paid-20260910-v1/evals/job-19/shards/skill-e2e-plan-design-plan-mode/pty-count/ship-source-at-delta-paid-20260910-v1-19/plan-design-review-1789070167941-FXkUaH/observation.json",
      "sha256": "c4c5b5d07ac05fb375f213618c32c54cdebfb93c5f62a29d8b585b4ce1516c95"
    },
    "observed": {
      "state": "plan_skill_observation_terminal",
      "scopeGateQuestionObserved": false,
      "scopeGateAutoSelectObserved": false,
      "nativeScope": "Latest owned native poll, refreshed while observing; not an exhaustive terminal journal.",
      "nativePolledAt": 1789070167941
    },
    "opts": {
      "seed": "\n# Plan: Marketing landing page\n\n## Layout\nAll headings, taglines, and body copy will be center-aligned for a\n\"clean modern look.\" The hero h1 sits 8px above the subhead; the CTA\nbutton has the same visual weight as the \"Learn more\" link beside it.\n\n## Pages\n- / (hero, 3-column features grid, testimonials carousel, footer)\n- /pricing (3 tier cards)\n\n## States\nOnly the happy path is designed. No empty states, no error states,\nno loading states. Mobile: \"stacks on mobile.\"\n",
      "skillName": "plan-design-review",
      "sessionId": "f0f35985-473e-4433-bee1-dcbd190e1243",
      "commandStartedAt": 1789070054491
    },
    "transcript": {
      "status": "ready",
      "calls": [],
      "assistantMessages": [
        {
          "sessionId": "05addfcd-cf52-4f31-814d-8cceceb5a49c",
          "text": "Scope gate: plan mode is active but no plan file exists yet and nothing has been drafted in this conversation, so I need to confirm the review target before running anything.",
          "timestamp": "2026-09-10T19:54:22.029Z"
        },
        {
          "sessionId": "f0f35985-473e-4433-bee1-dcbd190e1243",
          "text": "I'll run the /plan-design-review skill against this draft plan.",
          "timestamp": "2026-09-10T19:54:20.796Z"
        },
        {
          "sessionId": "f0f35985-473e-4433-bee1-dcbd190e1243",
          "text": "Now reading DESIGN.md and TODOS.md for design-related conventions.",
          "timestamp": "2026-09-10T19:55:09.551Z"
        },
        {
          "sessionId": "f0f35985-473e-4433-bee1-dcbd190e1243",
          "text": "Pre-review audit complete: DESIGN.md is detailed and the gstack designer plus Codex are both available. Now writing the initial plan artifact with the draft's requirements copied verbatim and gaps flagged as pending, then rating it.",
          "timestamp": "2026-09-10T19:55:25.027Z"
        },
        {
          "sessionId": "f0f35985-473e-4433-bee1-dcbd190e1243",
          "text": "**Pre-review audit findings**\n\n- **UI scope:** two pages, six sections (hero, features grid, testimonials carousel, footer, pricing tiers, nav implied). Design review applies.\n- **DESIGN.md exists** and is specific: Industrial/Utilitarian direction, dark mode default, amber-500 accent on zinc, Satoshi display, DM Sans body, JetBrains Mono as the personality font, 4px spacing scale, 12-col grid, one authored motion moment. The draft contradicts it in several places (\"clean modern look\", center-aligned everything, generic card grids).\n- **Prior design reviews:** none logged for this branch. No design TODOs touch a landing page.\n- **Existing leverage:** DESIGN.md tokens, the grain texture rule, and the Sept 8 decision that the live-feed pulse is the one authored motion moment (a hero motion would need to reconcile with that).\n\n**Step 0A: Initial design rating: 2/10**\n\nIt is a 2 because the plan names sections but makes no design decisions. The only two concrete numbers it gives (8px h1-to-subhead gap, CTA equal weight to a text link) are both wrong by DESIGN.md's own scale and by hierarchy principles. Everything else is a vibe: \"clean modern look\", \"stacks on mobile\", \"happy path only\". It also picks three of the seven hard-rejection patterns outright: generic 3-column features grid as first impression, purposeless carousel, and pricing made of stacked cards.\n\nA 10 for THIS plan: hero specified as one composition (Satoshi hero at clamp(40px, 6vw, 72px), left-aligned editorial layout per DESIGN.md, amber CTA dominant, `lg` 24px gap to subhead, one authored motion moment). Each section named with one job and its content hierarchy. Pricing with a recommended tier anchor and monospace numbers. Every state covered: font loading fallback, form submit/error/success, pricing fetch, reduced-motion. Per-viewport spec at 375 / 768 / 1200 with 44px touch targets. Contrast, focus, keyboard, and nav wayfinding specified.\n\n**Step 0B:** DESIGN.md exists. All design decisions will be calibrated against your stated design system.\n\n**Step 0C:** Reuse DESIGN.md tokens wholesale. Do not invent a second palette or type scale for marketing.",
          "timestamp": "2026-09-10T19:55:53.783Z"
        }
      ]
    },
    "tools": [
      {
        "sessionId": "f0f35985-473e-4433-bee1-dcbd190e1243",
        "timestamp": "2026-09-10T19:54:21.207Z",
        "toolUseId": "toolu_01DWy6hp7CYVw9aGRUvQNLjJ",
        "kind": "use",
        "name": "Skill",
        "input": {
          "skill": "plan-design-review"
        },
        "messageId": "msg_011CevLxuR2JMt5KUGXQstiz",
        "requestId": "req_011CevLxsWB7i5qao2rojyCq"
      },
      {
        "sessionId": "f0f35985-473e-4433-bee1-dcbd190e1243",
        "timestamp": "2026-09-10T19:54:23.693Z",
        "toolUseId": "toolu_01DWy6hp7CYVw9aGRUvQNLjJ",
        "kind": "result",
        "content": "Launching skill: plan-design-review",
        "isError": false
      }
    ]
  },
  {
    "attempt": 2,
    "observation": {
      "path": ".context/ship-source-at-delta-paid-20260910-v1/evals/job-19/shards/skill-e2e-plan-design-plan-mode/pty-count/ship-source-at-delta-paid-20260910-v1-19/plan-design-review-1789070310129-HaFAXh/observation.json",
      "sha256": "e26744b329f787fac6eb4cc3ce61e6df1f4002ba151330cf73501fc68a0172bd"
    },
    "observed": {
      "state": "plan_skill_observation_terminal",
      "scopeGateQuestionObserved": false,
      "scopeGateAutoSelectObserved": false,
      "nativeScope": "Latest owned native poll, refreshed while observing; not an exhaustive terminal journal.",
      "nativePolledAt": 1789070310129
    },
    "opts": {
      "seed": "\n# Plan: Marketing landing page\n\n## Layout\nAll headings, taglines, and body copy will be center-aligned for a\n\"clean modern look.\" The hero h1 sits 8px above the subhead; the CTA\nbutton has the same visual weight as the \"Learn more\" link beside it.\n\n## Pages\n- / (hero, 3-column features grid, testimonials carousel, footer)\n- /pricing (3 tier cards)\n\n## States\nOnly the happy path is designed. No empty states, no error states,\nno loading states. Mobile: \"stacks on mobile.\"\n",
      "skillName": "plan-design-review",
      "sessionId": "1b39171b-a08f-4ecc-b4c4-cbd9c26759fa",
      "commandStartedAt": 1789070179256
    },
    "transcript": {
      "status": "ready",
      "calls": [],
      "assistantMessages": [
        {
          "sessionId": "05addfcd-cf52-4f31-814d-8cceceb5a49c",
          "text": "Scope gate: plan mode is active but no plan file exists yet and nothing has been drafted in this conversation, so I need to confirm the review target before running anything.",
          "timestamp": "2026-09-10T19:54:22.029Z"
        },
        {
          "sessionId": "f0f35985-473e-4433-bee1-dcbd190e1243",
          "text": "I'll run the /plan-design-review skill against this draft plan.",
          "timestamp": "2026-09-10T19:54:20.796Z"
        },
        {
          "sessionId": "f0f35985-473e-4433-bee1-dcbd190e1243",
          "text": "Now reading DESIGN.md and TODOS.md for design-related conventions.",
          "timestamp": "2026-09-10T19:55:09.551Z"
        },
        {
          "sessionId": "f0f35985-473e-4433-bee1-dcbd190e1243",
          "text": "Pre-review audit complete: DESIGN.md is detailed and the gstack designer plus Codex are both available. Now writing the initial plan artifact with the draft's requirements copied verbatim and gaps flagged as pending, then rating it.",
          "timestamp": "2026-09-10T19:55:25.027Z"
        },
        {
          "sessionId": "f0f35985-473e-4433-bee1-dcbd190e1243",
          "text": "**Pre-review audit findings**\n\n- **UI scope:** two pages, six sections (hero, features grid, testimonials carousel, footer, pricing tiers, nav implied). Design review applies.\n- **DESIGN.md exists** and is specific: Industrial/Utilitarian direction, dark mode default, amber-500 accent on zinc, Satoshi display, DM Sans body, JetBrains Mono as the personality font, 4px spacing scale, 12-col grid, one authored motion moment. The draft contradicts it in several places (\"clean modern look\", center-aligned everything, generic card grids).\n- **Prior design reviews:** none logged for this branch. No design TODOs touch a landing page.\n- **Existing leverage:** DESIGN.md tokens, the grain texture rule, and the Sept 8 decision that the live-feed pulse is the one authored motion moment (a hero motion would need to reconcile with that).\n\n**Step 0A: Initial design rating: 2/10**\n\nIt is a 2 because the plan names sections but makes no design decisions. The only two concrete numbers it gives (8px h1-to-subhead gap, CTA equal weight to a text link) are both wrong by DESIGN.md's own scale and by hierarchy principles. Everything else is a vibe: \"clean modern look\", \"stacks on mobile\", \"happy path only\". It also picks three of the seven hard-rejection patterns outright: generic 3-column features grid as first impression, purposeless carousel, and pricing made of stacked cards.\n\nA 10 for THIS plan: hero specified as one composition (Satoshi hero at clamp(40px, 6vw, 72px), left-aligned editorial layout per DESIGN.md, amber CTA dominant, `lg` 24px gap to subhead, one authored motion moment). Each section named with one job and its content hierarchy. Pricing with a recommended tier anchor and monospace numbers. Every state covered: font loading fallback, form submit/error/success, pricing fetch, reduced-motion. Per-viewport spec at 375 / 768 / 1200 with 44px touch targets. Contrast, focus, keyboard, and nav wayfinding specified.\n\n**Step 0B:** DESIGN.md exists. All design decisions will be calibrated against your stated design system.\n\n**Step 0C:** Reuse DESIGN.md tokens wholesale. Do not invent a second palette or type scale for marketing.",
          "timestamp": "2026-09-10T19:55:53.783Z"
        },
        {
          "sessionId": "1b39171b-a08f-4ecc-b4c4-cbd9c26759fa",
          "text": "I'll run the plan-design-review skill on your draft plan.",
          "timestamp": "2026-09-10T19:56:33.063Z"
        },
        {
          "sessionId": "1b39171b-a08f-4ecc-b4c4-cbd9c26759fa",
          "text": "Design binary ready, Codex present. Reading DESIGN.md, TODOS.md for design items, and the review section this skill requires.",
          "timestamp": "2026-09-10T19:57:13.495Z"
        }
      ]
    },
    "tools": [
      {
        "sessionId": "f0f35985-473e-4433-bee1-dcbd190e1243",
        "timestamp": "2026-09-10T19:54:21.207Z",
        "toolUseId": "toolu_01DWy6hp7CYVw9aGRUvQNLjJ",
        "kind": "use",
        "name": "Skill",
        "input": {
          "skill": "plan-design-review"
        },
        "messageId": "msg_011CevLxuR2JMt5KUGXQstiz",
        "requestId": "req_011CevLxsWB7i5qao2rojyCq"
      },
      {
        "sessionId": "f0f35985-473e-4433-bee1-dcbd190e1243",
        "timestamp": "2026-09-10T19:54:23.693Z",
        "toolUseId": "toolu_01DWy6hp7CYVw9aGRUvQNLjJ",
        "kind": "result",
        "content": "Launching skill: plan-design-review",
        "isError": false
      },
      {
        "sessionId": "1b39171b-a08f-4ecc-b4c4-cbd9c26759fa",
        "timestamp": "2026-09-10T19:56:33.106Z",
        "toolUseId": "toolu_01YYV2trizhmHbR9msESEDpX",
        "kind": "use",
        "name": "Skill",
        "input": {
          "skill": "plan-design-review"
        },
        "messageId": "msg_011CevM85xYADsDhoAybpvMD",
        "requestId": "req_011CevM84vmFTrEX52iVfdJp"
      },
      {
        "sessionId": "1b39171b-a08f-4ecc-b4c4-cbd9c26759fa",
        "timestamp": "2026-09-10T19:56:34.542Z",
        "toolUseId": "toolu_01YYV2trizhmHbR9msESEDpX",
        "kind": "result",
        "content": "Launching skill: plan-design-review",
        "isError": false
      }
    ]
  }
]