{ "source": "Captured source-G synthetic eval session,2026-09-08; actual prior viewport plus following VT redraw.", "cols": 120, "rows": 40, "initial": [ "", "❯ /plan-design-review ", " ", " Ran 1 shell command", "", "● Scope gate: plan mode active — auto-selecting B (reviewing PLAN.md in the working directory).", "", " Skipping routing injection — this is a review fixture repo. Now running the pre-review audit.", " ", " Read 2 files, ran 1 shell command", "", "● Now let me read the review sections file as required by the skill.", "", " Read 1 file, ran 1 shell command", " ", "● No prior learnings found. Cross-project config is not set — will ask once I have the user's attention.", "", " Pre-Review System Audit:", " - DESIGN.md: exists and comprehensive (spacing, typography, color, interaction patterns all specified)", " - UI scope: APP UI classifier — account-settings form with Profile + Notifications sections", " - 5 gaps explicitly listed in the plan; all have corresponding spec in DESIGN.md", " - No prior design reviews in the review log", " - No TODOS.md exists", "", " Step 0 Assessment:", "", " Initial score: 5/10. The plan correctly identifies 5 real gaps and preserves strong accessibility and responsive specs", " inherited from the existing behavior description. A 10/10 would specify HOW each gap is resolved (concrete component", " changes, token values, before/after layout), not just name the problem. The DESIGN.md already has all correct values;", " the plan just needs to reference them.", "", " Writing the initial plan file now before asking Step 0D.", "", "✽ Undulating… (1m 59s · ↓ 5.4k tokens)", " ⎿  Tip: Use /btw to ask a quick side question without interrupting Claude's current work", " ✔ Update installed · Restart to update", "────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────", "❯ ", "────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────", " ⏸ plan mode on (shift+tab to cycle) · esc to interrupt · ← for agents" ], "cursor": { "x": 2, "y": 37 }, "update": "\u001b[H\u001b[3G14\u001b[6G-\u001b[8G**Initial\u001b[18Gscore:**\u001b[27G5/10\u001b[32G—\u001b[34Gplan\u001b[39Gcorrectly\u001b[49Gnames\u001b[55G5\u001b[57Ggaps\u001b[62Gbut\u001b[66Gdoes\u001b[71Gnot\u001b[75Gspecify\u001b[83GHOW\u001b[87Geach\u001b[92Gis\u001b[95Gresolved.\r\u001b[1B \u001b[3G15\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B16\u001b[6G##\u001b[9GStep\u001b[14G0:\u001b[17GDesign\u001b[24GScope\u001b[30GAssessment\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B17\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B18\u001b[6G**Initial\u001b[16Grating:\u001b[24G5/10**\r\u001b[1B \u001b[3G19\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B20\u001b[6GThe\u001b[10Gplan\u001b[15Gearns\u001b[21Ga\u001b[23G5\u001b[25Gbecause:\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B21 - It correctly id\u001b[24Gn\u001b[27Gfies\u001b[32G5 real,\u001b[40Gspecific\u001b[49Ggaps (Visual Hiera\u001b[68Gchy, Spacing, Color, Typography,\u001b[101GMotion)\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B22\u001b[6G-\u001b[8GIt\u001b[11Gpreserves\u001b[21Gstrong\u001b[28Gaccessibility\u001b[42Gand\u001b[46Gresponsive\u001b[57Gspecs\u001b[63Gfrom\u001b[68Gthe\u001b[72Gexisting\u001b[81Gbehavior\u001b[90Gdescription\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B23 -\u001b[8GDESIGN.md exist\u001b[24G and\u001b[29Gsupplies\u001b[38Gcorrect\u001b[46Gvalues\u001b[53Gfor\u001b[57Gall\u001b[61G5\u001b[63Ggaps\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B24\r\u001b[1B \u001b[3G25 A 10/10\u001b[14Gwould:\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B26\u001b[6G-\u001b[8GSpecify\u001b[16Gthe\u001b[20Gexact\u001b[26Gchange\u001b[33Gfor\u001b[37Geach\u001b[42Ggap\u001b[46G(concrete\u001b[56Gtoken,\u001b[63Gbefore\u001b[70G→\u001b[72Gafter)\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B27 -\u001b[8GAdd inte\u001b[18Gction state table\u001b[36G(loading,\u001b[46Gempty,\u001b[53Gerror,\u001b[60Gsuccess,\u001b[69Gpartial)\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B28\u001b[6G-\u001b[8GStoryboard\u001b[19Gthe\u001b[23Guser\u001b[28Gjourney\r\u001b[1B \u001b[3G29\u001b[6G- Call out which DESIGN.md tokens each fix applies\u001b[57G\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B30\u001b[6G-\u001b[8GResolve\u001b[16Gall\u001b[20Gimplementation\u001b[35Gambiguities\u001b[47Gbefore\u001b[54Ga\u001b[56Gdeveloper\u001b[66Gpicks\u001b[72Git\u001b[75Gup\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B31\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B32 **DESIGN.md status:** Pres\u001b[33Gnt and detailed. Spacing scale, c\u001b[67Glor system, typography,\u001b[91Ginteract\u001b[100Gon patterns,\u001b[113Gand\u001b[117Gc\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B \u001b[5G omponent\u001b[15Gbehavior \u001b[25Gre all specified. This review cal\u001b[59Gbrates against it.\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B33\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B34 **Ex\u001b[11Gsting design l\u001b[26Gverage:**\u001b[36G\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B35 -\u001b[8GButton, Field, InlineStatus,\u001b[37GErrorSummary,\u001b[51GConfirmationDialog\u001b[70Gcomponents\u001b[81Greused\u001b[88Gas-is\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B36\u001b[6G-\u001b[8GFocus\u001b[14Gring:\u001b[20G2px\u001b[24Gsolid\u001b[30G#1d4ed8,\u001b[39Goffset\u001b[46G2px\u001b[50G(already\u001b[59Gspecified)\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B37 -\u001b[8G8px ba\u001b[15Ge spacing\u001b[25Gscale\u001b[31Galready\u001b[39Gestablished\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B38\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B39 ---\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B40\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B41 ## Review Passes\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B42\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B43\u001b[6G*(Populated\u001b[18Gprogressively\u001b[32Gas\u001b[35Gthe\u001b[39Greview\u001b[46Gproceeds)*\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B44\u001b[K\r\u001b[1B╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌\r\u001b[1B Do you wa\u001b[12Gt to create gstack-test-plan-design.md?\r\u001b[1C\u001b[1B❯ 1. Yes\u001b[11G\u001b[K\r\u001b[3C\u001b[1B2.\u001b[7GYes,\u001b[12Gand\u001b[16Gswitch\u001b[23Gto\u001b[26Gaccept\u001b[33Gedits\u001b[39G(auto-approve\u001b[53Gfile\u001b[58Gedits\u001b[64Gand\u001b[68Gcommon\u001b[75Gfile\u001b[80Gcommands)\u001b[90Gfor this session; Yes,\u001b[113Gan\u001b[116G\u001b[K\r\u001b[1B always allow access to /tmp/gstack-paid-shard-jPAIoN/tmp/gstack-e2e-plan-design-ga2LJt for this session\u001b[K\r\u001b[1B \u001b[4G3.\u001b[7GNohift+tab)\r\u001b[1B\u001b[K\r\u001b[1C\u001b[1BEsc to canc\u001b[14Gl ·\u001b[18GTab to amend\u001b[K\u001b[40;1H\u001b[35;2H", "completed": "\u001b(B\u000f\u001b[?1000h\u001b[?1002h\u001b[?1003h\u001b[?1006h\u001b]0;◐ Claude Code\u0007\u001b[H\u001b[3G\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1BRan\u001b[7G1\u001b[9Gshell\u001b[15Gcommand\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B\u001b[K\r\u001b[1B●\u001b[3GScope\u001b[9Ggate:\u001b[15Gplan\u001b[20Gmode\u001b[25Gactive\u001b[32G—\u001b[34Gauto-selecting\u001b[49GB\u001b[51G(reviewing\u001b[62GPLAN.md\u001b[70Gin\u001b[73Gthe\u001b[77Gworking\u001b[85Gdirectory).\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1BSkipping\u001b[12Grouting\u001b[20Ginjection\u001b[30G—\u001b[32Gthis\u001b[37Gis\u001b[40Ga\u001b[42Greview\u001b[49Gfixture\u001b[57Grepo.\u001b[63GNow\u001b[67Grunning\u001b[75Gthe\u001b[79Gpre-review\u001b[90Gaudit.\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1BRead\u001b[8G2 files, ran\u001b[21G1 shell command\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B\u001b[K\r\u001b[1B●\u001b[3GNow let me read the review sect\u001b[35Gons fil\u001b[43G as required by the\u001b[63Gskill.\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1BRead\u001b[9G file, ran 1\u001b[22Gshell\u001b[28Gcommand\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B\u001b[K\r\u001b[1B●\u001b[3GNo\u001b[6Gprior\u001b[12Glearnings found. Cross-project config is\u001b[53Gnot set — will ask once I\u001b[79Ghave\u001b[84Gthe\u001b[88Guser's\u001b[95Gattention.\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1BPre\u001b[7GReview System Audit:\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B- DESIGN.md:\u001b[16Gexists and comprehensive (spacing, typography, color, interaction\u001b[82Gpatterns\u001b[91Gall\u001b[95Gspecified)\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B- UI\u001b[8Gscope:\u001b[15GAPP\u001b[19GUI\u001b[22Gclassifier\u001b[33G—\u001b[35Gaccount-settings\u001b[52Gform\u001b[57Gwith\u001b[62GProfile\u001b[70G+\u001b[72GNotifications\u001b[86Gsections\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B- 5 gaps explici\u001b[20Gly listed in the plan; \u001b[44Gl\u001b[46G have corresponding spec\u001b[71Gin DESIGN.md\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B-\u001b[5GN\u001b[7G \u001b[9Grior design reviews in\u001b[32Gth\u001b[35G review\u001b[43Glog\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B- No\u001b[8GTODOS.md\u001b[17Gexists\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1BStep\u001b[8G0 Assessment:\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1BInitial scor\u001b[16G: 5/10. The plan correctly identifies\u001b[54G5\u001b[56Greal\u001b[61Ggaps\u001b[66Gand\u001b[70Gpreserves\u001b[80Gstrong\u001b[87Gaccessibility\u001b[101Gand\u001b[105Gresponsive\u001b[116Gspecs\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1Binherited\u001b[13Gfrom\u001b[18Gthe\u001b[22Gexisting\u001b[31Gbehavior\u001b[40Gdescription.\u001b[53GA\u001b[55G10/10\u001b[61Gwould\u001b[67Gspecify\u001b[75GHOW\u001b[79Geach\u001b[84Ggap\u001b[88Gis\u001b[91Gresolved\u001b[100G(concrete\u001b[110Gcomponent\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1Bchanges,\u001b[12Gtoken\u001b[18Gvalues,\u001b[26Gbefore/after\u001b[39Glayout),\u001b[48Gnot\u001b[52Gjust\u001b[57Gname\u001b[62Gthe\u001b[66Gproblem.\u001b[75GThe\u001b[79GDESIGN.md\u001b[89Galready\u001b[97Ghas\u001b[101Gall\u001b[105Gcorrect\u001b[113Gvalues;\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1Bthe\u001b[7Gplan\u001b[12Gjust\u001b[17Gneeds\u001b[23Gto\u001b[26Greference\u001b[36Gthem.\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1BWriting\u001b[11Gthe\u001b[15Ginitial\u001b[23Gplan\u001b[28Gfile\u001b[33Gnow\u001b[37Gbefore\u001b[44Gasking\u001b[51GStep\u001b[56G0D.\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B\u001b[K\r\u001b[1B●\u001b[3GWrite(/tmp/gstack-paid-shard-jPAIoN/tmp/gstack-e2e-plan-design-ga2LJt/gstack-test-plan-design.md)\r\u001b[1B\u001b[K\r\u001b[1B✢ Undulati\u001b[12Gg… (2m 0s ·\u001b[24G↓ 5.4\u001b[30G \u001b[32Gokens)\u001b[K\r\u001b[1C\u001b[1B ⎿  Tip:\u001b[11GUse\u001b[15G/btw\u001b[20Gto\u001b[23Gask\u001b[27Ga\u001b[29Gquick\u001b[35Gside\u001b[40Gquestion\u001b[49Gwithout\u001b[57Ginterrupting\u001b[70GClaude's\u001b[79Gcurrent\u001b[87Gwork\r\u001b[3C\u001b[1B \u001b[7G \u001b[12G \u001b[16G \u001b[23G \u001b[26G \u001b[33G \u001b[39G \u001b[53G \u001b[58G \u001b[64G \u001b[68G \u001b[75G \u001b[80G \u001b[90G \u001b[94G \u001b[99G ● high · /effort\r\u001b[1B────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────\r\u001b[1B❯ \u001b[4G\u001b[K\r\u001b[1B────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────\r\u001b[1C\u001b[1B ⏸ plan mod\u001b[14G on\u001b[18G(shift+tab to\u001b[32Gcycle)\u001b[39G·\u001b[41Gesc\u001b[45Gto\u001b[48Ginterrupt\u001b[58G·\u001b[60G←\u001b[62Gfor\u001b[66Gagents\u001b[40;1H\u001b[38;3H\u001b[?25h\u001b[?25l\u001b[H\r\u001b[1B●\u001b[3GNo prior \u001b[13Gearnings found.\u001b[29GCross-project\u001b[43Gconfig\u001b[50Gis\u001b[53Gnot\u001b[57Gset\u001b[61G—\u001b[63Gwill\u001b[68Gask\u001b[72Gonce\u001b[77GI\u001b[79Ghave\u001b[84Gthe\u001b[88Guser's\u001b[95Gattention.\r\u001b[2B \u001b[3GPre-Review System Audit:\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B-\u001b[5GDESIGN.md:\u001b[16Gexists\u001b[23Gand\u001b[27Gcomprehensive\u001b[41G(spacing,\u001b[51Gtypography,\u001b[63Gcolor,\u001b[70Ginteraction\u001b[82Gpatterns\u001b[91Gall\u001b[95Gspecified)\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B- UI scope: APP UI classifier — account-settings fo\u001b[55Gm\u001b[57Gwith Pr\u001b[65Gfile + Notifications s\u001b[88Gctions\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B-\u001b[5G5\u001b[7Ggaps\u001b[12Gexplicitly\u001b[23Glisted\u001b[30Gin\u001b[33Gthe\u001b[37Gplan;\u001b[43Gall\u001b[47Ghave\u001b[52Gcorresponding\u001b[66Gspec\u001b[71Gin\u001b[74GDESIGN.md\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B- No\u001b[8Gprior desig\u001b[21Grevi\u001b[26Gws\u001b[29Gin the review\u001b[43Glog\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B-\u001b[5GNo\u001b[8GTODOS.md\u001b[17Gexists\r\u001b[1B\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1BStep\u001b[8G0\u001b[10GAssessment:\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1BInitial\u001b[11Gscore:\u001b[18G5/10.\u001b[24GThe\u001b[28Gplan\u001b[33Gcorrectly\u001b[43Gidentifies\u001b[54G5\u001b[56Greal\u001b[61Ggaps\u001b[66Gand\u001b[70Gpreserves\u001b[80Gstrong\u001b[87Gaccessibility\u001b[101Gand\u001b[105Gresponsive\u001b[116Gspecs\r\u001b[1B \u001b[3Ginhe\u001b[9Gted from the\u001b[22Gexisting behavi\u001b[38Gr des\u001b[44Gription.\u001b[53GA 10/10\u001b[61Gwould specify HOW\u001b[79Ge\u001b[81Gch\u001b[84Ggap\u001b[88Gi\u001b[90G \u001b[92Ge\u001b[94Golved (c\u001b[104Gcrete\u001b[110Gcomponent\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1Bchanges,\u001b[12Gtoken\u001b[18Gvalues,\u001b[26Gbefore/after\u001b[39Glayout),\u001b[48Gnot\u001b[52Gjust\u001b[57Gname\u001b[62Gthe\u001b[66Gproblem.\u001b[75GThe\u001b[79GDESIGN.md\u001b[89Galready\u001b[97Ghas\u001b[101Gall\u001b[105Gcorrect\u001b[113Gvalues;\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1Bth\u001b[6G plan just n\u001b[19Geds to reference\u001b[36Gthem.\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1BWriting the\u001b[15Ginitial plan \u001b[30Gle\u001b[33Gnow before ask\u001b[50G Step 0D.\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B\u001b[K\r\u001b[1B●\u001b[3GWrite(/tmp/gstack-paid-shard-jPAIoN/tmp/gstack-e2e-plan-design-ga2LJt/gstack-test-plan-design.md)\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B⎿\u001b[5G Wrote 44 lines \u001b[22Go\u001b[24G../gstack-e2e-plan-design-ga2LJt/gstack-test-plan-design.md\r\u001b[7C\u001b[1B1\u001b[10G#\u001b[12GDesign\u001b[19GReview\u001b[26GPlan:\u001b[32GSettings\u001b[41GPage\u001b[46GUI\u001b[49GRedesign\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B \u001b[8G2\u001b[10G\u001b[K\r\u001b[7C\u001b[1B4\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B 5 This is\u001b[18Ga plan-mode design review of \u001b[48Ghe Settings Page UI Redesign plan. The\u001b[87Gplan updates an existing ac\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B count-se\u001b[19Gtings form against a\u001b[40Gche\u001b[44Gked-\u001b[49Gn DESIGN.md. Five\u001b[67Gimplementation gaps are\u001b[91Gidentified i\u001b[104G the plan;\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B lementation begins.\u001b[K\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B \u001b[7G 6\u001b[K\r\u001b[7C\u001b[1B7\u001b[10G##\u001b[13GPre-Review\u001b[24GAudit\r\u001b[2C\u001b[1B 9 - **DESIGN.md:** Ex\u001b[30Gsts and comprehensive. All design\u001b[64Gdecisions\u001b[74Gcalibrate\u001b[84Gagainst\u001b[92Git.\r\u001b[6C\u001b[1B10\u001b[10G-\u001b[12G**UI\u001b[17Gscope:**\u001b[26GAPP\u001b[30GUI\u001b[33G—\u001b[35Gaccount-settings\u001b[52Gform\u001b[57Gwith\u001b[62GProfile\u001b[70Gand\u001b[74GNotifications\u001b[88Gsections.\r\u001b[1B \u001b[3G … +39 lines\u001b[K\u001b[40;1H\u001b[38;3H\u001b[?25h", "expected": [ " 14 - **Initial score:** 5/10 — plan correctly names 5 gaps but does not specify HOW each is resolved.", " 15", " 16 ## Step 0: Design Scope Assessment", " 17", " 18 **Initial rating: 5/10**", " 19", " 20 The plan earns a 5 because:", " 21 - It correctly identifies 5 real, specific gaps (Visual Hierarchy, Spacing, Color, Typography, Motion)", " 22 - It preserves strong accessibility and responsive specs from the existing behavior description", " 23 - DESIGN.md exists and supplies correct values for all 5 gaps", " 24", " 25 A 10/10 would:", " 26 - Specify the exact change for each gap (concrete token, before → after)", " 27 - Add interaction state table (loading, empty, error, success, partial)", " 28 - Storyboard the user journey", " 29 - Call out which DESIGN.md tokens each fix applies ", " 30 - Resolve all implementation ambiguities before a developer picks it up", " 31", " 32 **DESIGN.md status:** Present and detailed. Spacing scale, color system, typography, interaction patterns, and c", " omponent behavior are all specified. This review calibrates against it.", " 33", " 34 **Existing design leverage:**", " 35 - Button, Field, InlineStatus, ErrorSummary, ConfirmationDialog components reused as-is", " 36 - Focus ring: 2px solid #1d4ed8, offset 2px (already specified)", " 37 - 8px base spacing scale already established", " 38", " 39 ---", " 40", " 41 ## Review Passes", " 42", " 43 *(Populated progressively as the review proceeds)*", " 44", "╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌", " Do you want to create gstack-test-plan-design.md?", " ❯ 1. Yes", " 2. Yes, and switch to accept edits (auto-approve file edits and common file commands) for this session; Yes, and", " always allow access to /tmp/gstack-paid-shard-jPAIoN/tmp/gstack-e2e-plan-design-ga2LJt for this session", " 3. Nohift+tab)", "", " Esc to cancel · Tab to amend" ] }