{
  "provenance": {
    "source": "8525fd4abad1e54de1aaaa9a5692202d4b13bd25",
    "cli": "2.1.251",
    "capture": "autoplan-1789466203822-FVeXkH",
    "publicOnly": true,
    "note": "Exact public same-file Write/Edit requests and acknowledgments plus current pre-Edit bytes. Full 67-event public replay is retained privately; no parent reasoning reconstructed."
  },
  "commandStartedAt": 1789466173791,
  "file": "/tmp/gstack-owned-display-2pr8geye/gstack-paid-shard-5gxzVY/tmp/gstack-native-review-state-DV26SF/projects/gstack-autoplan-chain-S3FSi5/ceo-plans/2026-09-15-user-dashboard.md",
  "events": [
    {
      "sessionId": "8b3c0536-62bf-439a-9dfe-4be71d114eee",
      "timestamp": "2026-09-15T10:05:15.079Z",
      "toolUseId": "toolu_01AevK5q5DhuZFdyBYovE6oz",
      "kind": "use",
      "name": "Write",
      "input": {
        "file_path": "/tmp/gstack-owned-display-2pr8geye/gstack-paid-shard-5gxzVY/tmp/gstack-native-review-state-DV26SF/projects/gstack-autoplan-chain-S3FSi5/ceo-plans/2026-09-15-user-dashboard.md",
        "content": "---\nstatus: ACTIVE\n---\n# CEO Plan: User Dashboard Page\nGenerated by /plan-ceo-review (via /autoplan, auto-decided) on 2026-09-15\nBranch: main | Mode: SELECTIVE EXPANSION\nRepo: gstack-autoplan-chain-S3FSi5 (local fixture, no remote)\n\n## Plan under review\n/tmp/gstack-owned-display-2pr8geye/gstack-paid-shard-5gxzVY/tmp/gstack-hermetic-941983-Ahj6nL/with-skills/.claude/plans/jiggly-sparking-deer.md\n(`## Implementation plan` section: original plan + \"Accepted scope additions (autoplan CEO Step 0, 2026-09-15)\")\nSource plan: .claude/plans/ui-heavy-feature.md (sha256 2fdf0ece…)\n\n## Vision\n\n### 10x Check\nThe 10x version makes the dashboard the member's live inbox: pushed updates\ninstead of refetch, a ranked \"do this next\" action, inline completion without\nleaving the page, and a command palette. Not adopted: personalization/ranking is\nexcluded by the source plan, live updates need server infrastructure that does\nnot exist, and none of it is needed to hit the 45s login-to-first-completed-task\ntarget. The per-panel `PanelResult` envelope and independent panel components are\nthe seam these would plug into later.\n\n### Platonic Ideal\nNot applicable (SELECTIVE EXPANSION; EXPANSION only).\n\n## Scope Decisions\n\n| # | Proposal | Effort | Decision | Reasoning |\n|---|----------|--------|----------|-----------|\n| CEO-1 | `GET /api/dashboard` returns per-panel `PanelResult` envelope with `snapshotAt`, parallel fan-out, per-source timeout | M (human ~half day / CC ~25 min) | ACCEPTED (TASTE, provisional) | Highest completeness: one round trip, one flaky source never blanks the page, snapshot threaded to bulk-read. Alternative B (three client calls to existing endpoints, zero new server code) is close and goes to the final gate. |\n| CEO-2 | Keep modal confirmation for \"Mark all as read\" | S | ACCEPTED (keep original) | Undo would need an un-read mutation API, which the contracts exclude. Modal wraps the existing dialog primitive. |\n| CEO-H1/H2 | Defer toast or modal to cut file count | — | SKIPPED (keep both) | Both are part of the mark-all-read flow; a11y policy requires a live region for nonblocking feedback. |\n| E1 | Relative timestamps with absolute `<time dateTime>` + title | S | ACCEPTED | In blast radius; freshness is the point of a feed. |\n| E2 | Header unread-count badge / document title count | S | DEFERRED | Touches the shared nav shell, outside this plan's blast radius. |\n| E3 | Undo for mark-all-read | M | DEFERRED | Needs a new mutation API; excluded by contracts. |\n| E4 | Single-key shortcuts for quick actions | M | DEFERRED | No shortcut registry exists; screen-reader conflict risk. |\n| E5 | Per-panel Retry + stale-while-error banner | S | ACCEPTED | A failed refetch must not erase loaded content. |\n| E6 | Layout-matched skeletons; shimmer off under prefers-reduced-motion | S | ACCEPTED | Prevents layout shift; reduced motion is already policy. |\n| E7 | \"View all\" links to existing full pages; dashboard never paginates | S | ACCEPTED | Latest-20 needs an exit; the full pages own older-page navigation. |\n| E9 | Silent refetch on tab visibility if last fetch >60s | S | ACCEPTED | Members leave the tab open; stale data misleads the \"what's next\" read. |\n| E10 | Empty-state CTAs routing into quick actions | S | ACCEPTED | Empty states are onboarding moments; a blank panel does nothing for the 45s target. |\n| 10x | Live updates, ranked actions, command palette | L | DEFERRED | Outside scope; ranking excluded by the plan. |\n| Instr. | Named analytics events for the dashboard funnel | S | ACCEPTED (made explicit) | Already required by the contracts; named so Eng can test them. |\n\n## Accepted Scope (added to this plan)\n- `GET /api/dashboard` per-panel `PanelResult<T>` envelope; parallel fan-out with ~2s per-source timeout; one failing source never fails the response; 401 for unauthenticated; no CSRF on the read; `notifications.snapshotAt` for the bulk-read call.\n- E1 relative + absolute timestamps on activity and notification rows.\n- E5 per-panel Retry; stale-while-error banner on failed refetch after a prior success.\n- E6 layout-matched skeletons; shimmer disabled under reduced motion.\n- E7 \"View all\" links to the existing full activity / notifications pages.\n- E9 silent refetch on `visibilitychange` when last fetch >60s.\n- E10 empty-state copy and CTAs (activity → \"Create your first item\"; notifications → \"You're all caught up\"; no eligible actions → \"Nothing to do right now\" + workspace home link).\n- Instrumentation events: `dashboard_viewed`, `dashboard_panel_state`, `dashboard_quick_action_clicked`, `dashboard_mark_all_read` (opened/confirmed/cancelled/succeeded/failed), `dashboard_view_all_clicked`.\n\n## Deferred to TODOS.md\n(TODOS.md does not exist in the repo and plan mode forbids creating it; these are\nlisted in the plan's \"Deferred to TODOS.md\" section and will be written to\nTODOS.md on approval.)\n- E2 header unread badge + document title count (shared nav shell).\n- E3 undo mark-all-read (requires un-read mutation API).\n- E4 keyboard shortcuts for quick actions (requires shortcut registry).\n- 10x: live updates (push/SSE), personalized action ranking, command palette.\n\n## Reviewer Concerns\n(populated after the Spec Review Loop)\n"
      },
      "messageId": "msg_011Cf534Fsf9Hb4J5afh7JVm",
      "requestId": "req_011Cf534EtsMdoqLJMunXcuh"
    },
    {
      "sessionId": "8b3c0536-62bf-439a-9dfe-4be71d114eee",
      "timestamp": "2026-09-15T10:05:19.609Z",
      "toolUseId": "toolu_01AevK5q5DhuZFdyBYovE6oz",
      "kind": "result",
      "content": "File created successfully at: /tmp/gstack-owned-display-2pr8geye/gstack-paid-shard-5gxzVY/tmp/gstack-native-review-state-DV26SF/projects/gstack-autoplan-chain-S3FSi5/ceo-plans/2026-09-15-user-dashboard.md (file state is current in your context — no need to Read it back)",
      "isError": false
    },
    {
      "sessionId": "8b3c0536-62bf-439a-9dfe-4be71d114eee",
      "timestamp": "2026-09-15T10:09:09.622Z",
      "toolUseId": "toolu_019VrPSLDZPo5eyvbrk3Jo1Q",
      "kind": "use",
      "name": "Edit",
      "input": {
        "replace_all": false,
        "file_path": "/tmp/gstack-owned-display-2pr8geye/gstack-paid-shard-5gxzVY/tmp/gstack-native-review-state-DV26SF/projects/gstack-autoplan-chain-S3FSi5/ceo-plans/2026-09-15-user-dashboard.md",
        "old_string": "| CEO-1 | `GET /api/dashboard` returns per-panel `PanelResult` envelope with `snapshotAt`, parallel fan-out, per-source timeout | M (human ~half day / CC ~25 min) | ACCEPTED (TASTE, provisional) | Highest completeness: one round trip, one flaky source never blanks the page, snapshot threaded to bulk-read. Alternative B (three client calls to existing endpoints, zero new server code) is close and goes to the final gate. |",
        "new_string": "| CEO-1 | `GET /api/dashboard` returns per-panel `PanelResult` envelope (`NotificationsResult` carries `snapshotAt`), parallel fan-out, hard 2s per-source deadline with abort | M (human ~half day / CC ~25 min) | ACCEPTED (TASTE, provisional) | In force unless overturned at the final gate. Highest completeness: one round trip, one flaky source never blanks the page, snapshot threaded to bulk-read. Alternative B (three client calls to existing endpoints, zero new server code) is close. If B wins: no server handler; `snapshotAt` must come from the existing notifications list response (confirm it exposes one); the plan's Backend section reverts to \"no new endpoint\". |"
      },
      "messageId": "msg_011Cf53P1WjgFKxAYtLZviAK",
      "requestId": "req_011Cf53NztnNGuQkcxc354mA"
    },
    {
      "sessionId": "8b3c0536-62bf-439a-9dfe-4be71d114eee",
      "timestamp": "2026-09-15T10:09:12.534Z",
      "toolUseId": "toolu_019VrPSLDZPo5eyvbrk3Jo1Q",
      "kind": "result",
      "content": "The file /tmp/gstack-owned-display-2pr8geye/gstack-paid-shard-5gxzVY/tmp/gstack-native-review-state-DV26SF/projects/gstack-autoplan-chain-S3FSi5/ceo-plans/2026-09-15-user-dashboard.md has been updated successfully. (file state is current in your context — no need to Read it back)",
      "isError": false
    },
    {
      "sessionId": "8b3c0536-62bf-439a-9dfe-4be71d114eee",
      "timestamp": "2026-09-15T10:09:34.774Z",
      "toolUseId": "toolu_01Qx85vgF3VkxDNuxZs1uf3N",
      "kind": "use",
      "name": "Edit",
      "input": {
        "replace_all": false,
        "file_path": "/tmp/gstack-owned-display-2pr8geye/gstack-paid-shard-5gxzVY/tmp/gstack-native-review-state-DV26SF/projects/gstack-autoplan-chain-S3FSi5/ceo-plans/2026-09-15-user-dashboard.md",
        "old_string": "| E9 | Silent refetch on tab visibility if last fetch >60s | S | ACCEPTED | Members leave the tab open; stale data misleads the \"what's next\" read. |\n| E10 | Empty-state CTAs routing into quick actions | S | ACCEPTED | Empty states are onboarding moments; a blank panel does nothing for the 45s target. |\n| 10x | Live updates, ranked actions, command palette | L | DEFERRED | Outside scope; ranking excluded by the plan. |\n| Instr. | Named analytics events for the dashboard funnel | S | ACCEPTED (made explicit) | Already required by the contracts; named so Eng can test them. |\n\n## Accepted Scope (added to this plan)\n- `GET /api/dashboard` per-panel `PanelResult<T>` envelope; parallel fan-out with ~2s per-source timeout; one failing source never fails the response; 401 for unauthenticated; no CSRF on the read; `notifications.snapshotAt` for the bulk-read call.\n- E1 relative + absolute timestamps on activity and notification rows.\n- E5 per-panel Retry; stale-while-error banner on failed refetch after a prior success.\n- E6 layout-matched skeletons; shimmer disabled under reduced motion.\n- E7 \"View all\" links to the existing full activity / notifications pages.\n- E9 silent refetch on `visibilitychange` when last fetch >60s.\n- E10 empty-state copy and CTAs (activity → \"Create your first item\"; notifications → \"You're all caught up\"; no eligible actions → \"Nothing to do right now\" + workspace home link).\n- Instrumentation events: `dashboard_viewed`, `dashboard_panel_state`, `dashboard_quick_action_clicked`, `dashboard_mark_all_read` (opened/confirmed/cancelled/succeeded/failed), `dashboard_view_all_clicked`.",
        "new_string": "| E9 | Silent refetch on tab visibility if last fetch >60s | S | DEFERRED (revised after spec review iteration 1) | Cannot move the login-anchored 45s metric; revisit if stale-data complaints appear. |\n| E10 | Empty-state copy with CTAs where an eligible action exists | S | ACCEPTED | Empty states are onboarding moments; a blank panel does nothing for the 45s target. |\n| 10x | Live updates, ranked actions, command palette | L | DEFERRED | Outside scope; ranking excluded by the plan. |\n| Instr. | Named analytics events for the dashboard funnel (settle + error, not every state change) | S | ACCEPTED (made explicit) | Already required by the contracts; named so Eng can test them. |\n| Spec | Layout per breakpoint, panel state machine, mark-all-read edge cases and copy, toast a11y spec, flag-gated login redirect, rollout criteria, test list | S-M | ACCEPTED (made explicit) | Required by the contracts (\"must be specified and added\"); spec reviewer found them missing from both inputs. Not expansions. |\n\n## Accepted Scope (added to this plan)\n- `GET /api/dashboard` per-panel envelope (`PanelResult<T>`; `NotificationsResult` with `snapshotAt`); no `cursor`, no per-source `forbidden`; parallel fan-out with hard 2s per-source deadline and abort; one failing source never fails the response; 401/403 at request level; no CSRF on the read; p95 ≤ 500ms healthy, ≈2s ceiling degraded.\n- Layout: quick actions lead on `sm`; two columns on `md`; three on `lg`. Quick actions are anchors styled as buttons.\n- Panel state machine: loading → success | empty | error; success → stale on failed refetch; Retry re-requests the aggregate endpoint.\n- E1 relative + absolute timestamps on activity and notification rows.\n- E5 per-panel Retry; stale-while-error banner on failed refetch after a prior success.\n- E6 layout-matched skeletons; shimmer disabled under reduced motion.\n- E7 \"View all\" links to the existing full activity / notifications pages.\n- E10 empty-state copy and CTAs (activity → \"Create your first item\" if eligible; notifications → \"You're all caught up\"; no eligible actions → \"Nothing to do right now\" + workspace home link).\n- Mark all as read: control present only when notifications loaded and unread > 0; modal copy defined; success = local mark + silent refetch + toast; failure = toast, control stays.\n- Toast: shared `ToastProvider`/`useToast`, `role=\"status\"` polite live region, Dismiss button, 6s auto-dismiss paused on hover/focus, max 3, no motion under reduced motion.\n- Instrumentation: `dashboard_viewed`, `dashboard_panel_settled`, `dashboard_panel_error`, `dashboard_quick_action_clicked`, `dashboard_view_all_clicked`, `dashboard_mark_all_read`.\n- Rollout: `dashboard_landing` flag per member cohort gates the post-login redirect and the route; criteria and RTL/endpoint/Playwright/axe test list specified in the plan."
      },
      "messageId": "msg_011Cf53Pwb8rDKVZRAsVcx5q",
      "requestId": "req_011Cf53Pvm1pGKr1m9C8vATq"
    }
  ],
  "before": "---\nstatus: ACTIVE\n---\n# CEO Plan: User Dashboard Page\nGenerated by /plan-ceo-review (via /autoplan, auto-decided) on 2026-09-15\nBranch: main | Mode: SELECTIVE EXPANSION\nRepo: gstack-autoplan-chain-S3FSi5 (local fixture, no remote)\n\n## Plan under review\n/tmp/gstack-owned-display-2pr8geye/gstack-paid-shard-5gxzVY/tmp/gstack-hermetic-941983-Ahj6nL/with-skills/.claude/plans/jiggly-sparking-deer.md\n(`## Implementation plan` section: original plan + \"Accepted scope additions (autoplan CEO Step 0, 2026-09-15)\")\nSource plan: .claude/plans/ui-heavy-feature.md (sha256 2fdf0ece…)\n\n## Vision\n\n### 10x Check\nThe 10x version makes the dashboard the member's live inbox: pushed updates\ninstead of refetch, a ranked \"do this next\" action, inline completion without\nleaving the page, and a command palette. Not adopted: personalization/ranking is\nexcluded by the source plan, live updates need server infrastructure that does\nnot exist, and none of it is needed to hit the 45s login-to-first-completed-task\ntarget. The per-panel `PanelResult` envelope and independent panel components are\nthe seam these would plug into later.\n\n### Platonic Ideal\nNot applicable (SELECTIVE EXPANSION; EXPANSION only).\n\n## Scope Decisions\n\n| # | Proposal | Effort | Decision | Reasoning |\n|---|----------|--------|----------|-----------|\n| CEO-1 | `GET /api/dashboard` returns per-panel `PanelResult` envelope (`NotificationsResult` carries `snapshotAt`), parallel fan-out, hard 2s per-source deadline with abort | M (human ~half day / CC ~25 min) | ACCEPTED (TASTE, provisional) | In force unless overturned at the final gate. Highest completeness: one round trip, one flaky source never blanks the page, snapshot threaded to bulk-read. Alternative B (three client calls to existing endpoints, zero new server code) is close. If B wins: no server handler; `snapshotAt` must come from the existing notifications list response (confirm it exposes one); the plan's Backend section reverts to \"no new endpoint\". |\n| CEO-2 | Keep modal confirmation for \"Mark all as read\" | S | ACCEPTED (keep original) | Undo would need an un-read mutation API, which the contracts exclude. Modal wraps the existing dialog primitive. |\n| CEO-H1/H2 | Defer toast or modal to cut file count | — | SKIPPED (keep both) | Both are part of the mark-all-read flow; a11y policy requires a live region for nonblocking feedback. |\n| E1 | Relative timestamps with absolute `<time dateTime>` + title | S | ACCEPTED | In blast radius; freshness is the point of a feed. |\n| E2 | Header unread-count badge / document title count | S | DEFERRED | Touches the shared nav shell, outside this plan's blast radius. |\n| E3 | Undo for mark-all-read | M | DEFERRED | Needs a new mutation API; excluded by contracts. |\n| E4 | Single-key shortcuts for quick actions | M | DEFERRED | No shortcut registry exists; screen-reader conflict risk. |\n| E5 | Per-panel Retry + stale-while-error banner | S | ACCEPTED | A failed refetch must not erase loaded content. |\n| E6 | Layout-matched skeletons; shimmer off under prefers-reduced-motion | S | ACCEPTED | Prevents layout shift; reduced motion is already policy. |\n| E7 | \"View all\" links to existing full pages; dashboard never paginates | S | ACCEPTED | Latest-20 needs an exit; the full pages own older-page navigation. |\n| E9 | Silent refetch on tab visibility if last fetch >60s | S | ACCEPTED | Members leave the tab open; stale data misleads the \"what's next\" read. |\n| E10 | Empty-state CTAs routing into quick actions | S | ACCEPTED | Empty states are onboarding moments; a blank panel does nothing for the 45s target. |\n| 10x | Live updates, ranked actions, command palette | L | DEFERRED | Outside scope; ranking excluded by the plan. |\n| Instr. | Named analytics events for the dashboard funnel | S | ACCEPTED (made explicit) | Already required by the contracts; named so Eng can test them. |\n\n## Accepted Scope (added to this plan)\n- `GET /api/dashboard` per-panel `PanelResult<T>` envelope; parallel fan-out with ~2s per-source timeout; one failing source never fails the response; 401 for unauthenticated; no CSRF on the read; `notifications.snapshotAt` for the bulk-read call.\n- E1 relative + absolute timestamps on activity and notification rows.\n- E5 per-panel Retry; stale-while-error banner on failed refetch after a prior success.\n- E6 layout-matched skeletons; shimmer disabled under reduced motion.\n- E7 \"View all\" links to the existing full activity / notifications pages.\n- E9 silent refetch on `visibilitychange` when last fetch >60s.\n- E10 empty-state copy and CTAs (activity → \"Create your first item\"; notifications → \"You're all caught up\"; no eligible actions → \"Nothing to do right now\" + workspace home link).\n- Instrumentation events: `dashboard_viewed`, `dashboard_panel_state`, `dashboard_quick_action_clicked`, `dashboard_mark_all_read` (opened/confirmed/cancelled/succeeded/failed), `dashboard_view_all_clicked`.\n\n## Deferred to TODOS.md\n(TODOS.md does not exist in the repo and plan mode forbids creating it; these are\nlisted in the plan's \"Deferred to TODOS.md\" section and will be written to\nTODOS.md on approval.)\n- E2 header unread badge + document title count (shared nav shell).\n- E3 undo mark-all-read (requires un-read mutation API).\n- E4 keyboard shortcuts for quick actions (requires shortcut registry).\n- 10x: live updates (push/SSE), personalized action ranking, command palette.\n\n## Reviewer Concerns\n(populated after the Spec Review Loop)\n"
}