* chore(scripts): retire hollow and legacy paid package scripts behind one-release stubs (W8a, DX-4, CEO-31) test:codex*, test:evals*, test:e2e*, test:gate, test:periodic, eval:bg, eval:bg:all, eval:flake-rank, eval:watch and test:audit now print their replacement and exit 1 via scripts/retired-command.ts. CONTRIBUTING.md carries the same table; test/retired-commands.test.ts pins both. Eval CLI empty-state hints point at eval:bg:pr. * chore: delete dead update-readme-throughput, eval-watch, orphan fixtures and QA_FUNCTIONAL_INPUTS (W8b, CEO-24) Retired with named behavior: - update-readme-throughput.ts + readme-throughput test: replaced a README anchor that no longer exists from a JSON file that was never produced; the script was a no-op. Guarantee withdrawn (nothing to protect). - eval-watch.ts + its dashboard tests: rendered ~/.gstack-dev/e2e-live.json and _partial-e2e.json, written only by unsharded runs, so it showed nothing for every supported (sharded) entry point. Guarantee withdrawn; live progress is the gstack-detach log or gh run watch. Manual-review rendering stays covered by eval-list and eval-summary tests. - Orphan fixtures (autoplan-pending-artifact-ae.json, autoplan-existing-app/, autoplan-sign-in-ui/, parity baselines v1.47.0.0/v1.57.7.0/v1.69.1.0): no test, touchfile or script reads them; superseded baselines stay in git history. - QA_FUNCTIONAL_INPUTS: exported, never imported. * refactor(test-free): delete dead WORKER_HOSTILE list and buildShardArgs parallel mode Neither had a production caller: full-suite mode runs shard processes, so the worker quarantine was inert and --parallel was never passed (W8b). * docs(test-value): narrow prompt-byte contract to machine-read tokens (D2) Define prompt-byte contract as machine-read tokens (markers, field names, command lines, enum values, file paths, security-boundary strings) and add a sentence-pin glossary entry: convert to structural checks or delete when a behavioral eval covers the behavior. * test(ratchet): count free tests that slice a paid test's source A free test that binds readFileSync(<paid test file>) and cuts it with .slice() tests the paid harness's code out of context even when it imports a lib/ symbol. Record the 15 existing files with reasons; new ones fail with fix text. Self-test covers positive and negative shapes. * test(browse): un-quarantine compare-board; all 16 board tests pass headless (W8d, CEO-24) The GSTACK_COMPARE_BOARD_TESTS opt-in hid a headless mismatch that no longer reproduces: all 16 tests pass on Bun 1.4.0 with the bundled headless Chromium, solo, repeated, and beside other in-process browser files. Protected behavior (the comparison-board DOM contract the plan-design-review/office-hours/design-consultation feedback loop polls) is checked on every free run again. * test: replace silent existsSync early returns with explicit skips or assertions (W8d) - browse/test/build.test.ts: server-node.mjs checks skip only when the bundle is absent and GSTACK_EXPECT_BINARIES is unset; the free CI lane and test:ubicloud build it and set the flag, so a dropped build step fails with the build command instead of passing with no assertions. - gstack-update-check: VERSION is tracked; the guard could only hide a bug. - gen-skill-docs host leakage/frontmatter checks assert the host tree exists (the module-level render always produces it). - cso-docker staged-runtime test uses test.skipIf so reports show it as skipped, not passed. * test(ship): convert ship-workflow-clarity sentence pins to structural checks Add test/helpers/prompt-structure.ts (between, expectTokens, expectAbsent, expectOrdered, expectMentions) with fix text on failure. ship-workflow-clarity now pins headings, step order and machine-read tokens (commands, fields, enum and status strings); safety rules are meaning-level keyword checks. Wording is judged by the 'ship/SKILL.md workflow' judge in skill-llm-eval. Sentence pins: 90 -> 0. * ci: add platform-qualification lane for opt-in ML, gitleaks and Swift tests (W8d, CEO-24) security-bench + security-live-playwright L4 (SECURITY_BENCH), the real gitleaks 8.30.1 memory-ingest cases (GSTACK_TEST_GITLEAKS) and the DebugBridge Swift build invariants (GSTACK_TEST_SWIFT) self-skip in every lane today. No scheduled lane has their prerequisites, so per CEO-24 they move to an owned dispatch + quarterly workflow instead of being deleted. Each job was run locally (ML 10 pass, gitleaks 130 pass; Swift needs macOS). test/platform-qualification-workflow.test.ts pins gate variable, job and file together. * fix(scripts): capture-baseline and preflight-agent-sdk no longer act on --help or typos (W8e) capture-baseline parses its flags strictly: --help prints usage, an unknown or valueless flag exits 2, and only a valid invocation writes a fixture (--help used to write test/fixtures/parity-baseline-current.json). preflight-agent-sdk gains --help, rejects unknown flags, and runs the live SDK query (API spend) only with --live. * test(evals): register the three keyless periodic paid files with case ids (W1b) skill-e2e-auq-consistency, skill-e2e-auq-verbose-vs-carved-ab and codex-e2e-recommendation-substance now carry touchfiles, a periodic tier and kind rule (one trial, unchanged), so editing one selects its own case instead of restoring the full PR gate. The verbose A/B case also registers the vendored pre-cut fixture it reads, and review-army-migration-safety registers the SQL fixture it reads. * feat(evals): narrow PR fallback for free-only inputs (W1a, CEO-13/20, ENG-13) The PR profile now exempts the duration seeds, every free-lane workflow (explicit list; inventory test fails on an unclassified workflow, .yaml and workflow_call included), scripts/ubicloud/** and fixtures declared in the explicit FREE_FIXTURES map. Each remaining unknown file carries a label and fix (needs touchfile entry / add to FREE_ONLY_PR_FILES / real unknown dependency). evals.yml itself still restores the full gate. * ci: delete ci-image.yml; the eval workflows already build and push the same content-hash tag (W8f) evals.yml, evals-periodic.yml and evals-marathon.yml each compute the identical hashFiles() tag and build/push it (with :buildcache and :latest) when missing, so ci-image's push trigger and weekly cron were no-ops (30-day median 0.5 min, 36/36 success). ci-image-tag-binding now pins the three eval workflows. * ci(evals): key periodic/marathon concurrency on ref+event; branch periodic dispatch skips the gate census (W2a, ENG-9, CEO-04) * refactor(paid): drop ~160 unused imports; leaf paid-types/paid-select modules break the paid-* import cycle (W8c) * ci(quality-gate): per-PR concurrency, free runner, drop unscoped bun audit (W2a, W8f) - Concurrency keys on pull_request.number || run_id, so back-to-back main pushes no longer cancel each other's credential scan. - ubuntu-24.04 instead of a billed 8-vCPU Ubicloud runner for a ~1 min job. - bun audit --audit-level=critical ran on every PR regardless of diff, so a newly published advisory turned unrelated PRs red, with its own ignore policy. dependency-review (lockfile PRs, fail >= high) and the weekly OSV sweep remain the dependency gates. * chore(test-free): refresh the free duration seed from the audit's Ubicloud recording Adds the 19 files merged after the last refresh, including the 115 s claude-overlay-setup that packed as ~1 s and doubled a shard (W6a). The seed is re-recorded on the final tree at the end of this wave. * ci: move tiny ubicloud-standard-2 jobs to free ubuntu-24.04 runners (W8f) actionlint, skill-docs, dependency-review, version-gate and pr-title-sync are sub-minute jobs; GitHub-hosted runners are free for this public repo. * feat(test-free): pessimistic unseeded packing, seed growth ratchet and CI health summary - Unseeded files pack at the seed's p99 instead of p75 (W6a). - --ci-plan warns in the job summary past 5 unseeded files; --ci-verify lists shards that outran their prediction by 1.5x (and 30 s) plus every flaky pass absorbed by the serial retry (W6a, W7a job summary). - test/free-seed-ratchet.test.ts fails when a seeded file over 60 s is not on scripts/free-test-seed-allowlist.json, when an entry is stale, and when the allowlist grows versus its merge-base copy unless the new entry is an annotated exception with a todo (CEO-10, DX-7). free-plan runs it with full history so the shrink check is real in the required lane. - Every message names the fix command and docs anchor (DX-6). * feat(evals): state PR coverage mode, counts, reuse and fallback files in the summary and comment (CEO-13) * test: make the tracked-tree skill-doc freshness check local-only; tidy skill-docs header (W8f) Every free CI shard regenerates the tracked SKILL.md files before running tests, so the --dry-run freshness assertion compared the regenerated tree with itself and could not fail there. It now skips under GitHub Actions; skill-docs.yml's git diff --exit-code is CI's freshness gate. Removes a stale concurrency comment in skill-docs.yml. * ci(free-tests): install zsh so the bash+zsh portability arms run (W6f) ~42 zsh-arm tests (aside-probe-shell, qa-browser-preservation, generated-docs-fences) skipped in CI because zsh is not in the runner image. All 141 tests in those files pass with zsh present. * feat(evals): executors write negative receipts at the execution boundary (CEO-25, ENG-6) A completed single-trial rule/judge shard that did not pass now writes its negative receipt beside the pass receipts in the slice artifact, so a cancelled run's FAIL still blocks an older PASS when its report never runs. Receipts merge negatives first and order by (run attempt, completedAt); a same-second FAIL/PASS tie resolves to FAIL. The runner call site is a one-line hunk in scripts/test-paid-shards.ts. * docs(cso): state that contained runtime/scanner execution is unavailable today The scanner catalog is empty while its build inputs await review and the runtime catalog holds no qualified profile until the private evaluator exists, so /cso runs static assessment only. AGENTS.md, README and docs/cso-release-qualification.md now say so; docs/cso-scanners.md already did. * test(helpers): expectMentions splits on sentence ends only Clauses joined by ';' or ':' are one rule; splitting there made a reworded rule fail for punctuation. * test(plan-ceo): convert skill-ceo-section-ordering sentence pins Safety and authority rules (never/do not/stop/only/without/wait/approval) are meaning-level expectMentions checks; other sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, option rows, placeholders and machine-read lines (auto-decide annotation, Mode:/approved decisions format, STATUS/SOURCE fields, CROSS-MODEL marker, gstack-ceo-mode-handoff) stay as tokens; ordering checks unchanged. Behavior is covered by the periodic PTY case in skill-e2e-plan-ceo-review-section-loading.test.ts. Sentence pins: 210 -> 23. * test(helpers): expectMentions treats wrapped lines as one sentence Templates hard-wrap prose; only sentence ends and blank lines separate rules. * test(gen-skill-docs): convert sentence pins to meaning checks or drop them Safety/authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks; other English sentences are dropped (wording is judged by the per-skill workflow judges in skill-llm-eval and the E2E cases in touchfiles-data). Commands, config keys, markers (PLAN MODE EXCEPTION, NO UNRESOLVED DECISIONS, Gate outcome), field names and alternation-based meaning regexes stay. Removed the now-empty 'contains opt-in AskUserQuestion text' test (only pinned a sentence; the resolver's AskUserQuestion wiring is covered by the codex second-opinion tests in the same describe). Lane E's existsSync hunks are untouched. Sentence pins: 216 -> 65 (remaining lines carry machine tokens). * ci(windows): shard the Windows lane via --ci-plan/--ci-run/--ci-verify; move native campaigns to native-qualification.yml - windows-free-tests.yml: a Linux plan job curates and packs the Windows-safe files into 6 shards, one strict serial shard per windows-latest job, and a Linux aggregate verifies exact coverage and every result (8.1 min on one runner today). --windows-only now combines with the CI modes; the plan binds the curated file set (W6e). - Every Windows plan and --list run prints the curated count with its top exclusion reasons in the job summary; a free ratchet fails when the curated subset drops below its floor, with the fix (W6e). - The four Dia/cookie diagnostic dispatch campaigns move to the dispatch-only native-qualification.yml with one exclusive `mode` choice input, so their red dispatch runs no longer read as a red PR lane (W8f). Their workflow pins move to test/windows-native-workflows.test.ts; the boolean-exclusivity guard is replaced by the choice input. * feat(paid): per-slice CI job ceilings and an in-process slice deadline with not_run/hung outcomes and checkpoints (W2c, ENG-2) * fix(pass-rates): segment trial history strictly by EVAL_POLICY version Reader-compatibility floor for EVAL_POLICY v2 (ENG-14/CEO-35/DX-12). Only trials under the reader's own policy version feed labels and alarms; older policy trials stay visible but are never scored or used as a drift baseline; trials from a newer policy are ignored with a printed count and fix text. Reverting the later v2 writer commits leaves a reader that cannot pool v2 records into v1 series (the pre-PR reader at2db0b3adoes: it reports a mixed fixture as FAILING with drift alarms). * docs: one contributor command table; retired commands, seed sources and current workflows (W8g, DX-5, DX-13, CEO-12) - CONTRIBUTING.md gains 'Which command do I run?' (task -> command -> cost/time -> needs, including branch validation via gh workflow run); CLAUDE.md, AGENTS.md and TESTING_INTERNALS.md link to it instead of repeating command lists. Tier tables drop retired commands and stale per-run dollar estimates. - Retired names (test:evals, test:e2e, eval:bg, eval:flake-rank, eval:watch, ...) are gone from CLAUDE.md, CONTRIBUTING.md, TESTING_INTERNALS.md, ARCHITECTURE.md and USING_GBRAIN_WITH_GSTACK.md. - The flake-ledger claim now says what happens: CI uploads flake-ledger-* artifacts; eval:pass-rates reads only the local ledger. - TESTING_INTERNALS states that only test:ubicloud --record-durations produces an acceptable duration seed (DX-13). - CI section: quality gate no longer runs bun audit; dependency-review's real trigger; the platform-qualification lane. - docs/test-audit-2026-09.md gets a corrections section for its stale claims. - TODOS.md: audit follow-ups (post-merge metrics, stub removal, name reclaim, diff-aware planner); eval-watch shard-awareness and the image freshness tripwire closed as won't-do. * feat(evals): recover receipts of cancelled PR runs (W1c, CEO-14/34, ENG-4/5/7) A new recover-receipts job runs base-ref code with actions: read, restores the PR's store, merges the receipts of completed cancelled evals.yml runs for this PR (provenance-checked, at most 5, oldest first, negatives first), reconstructs completed panel negatives with panelVerdict() (partial panels get no credit) and keeps a recovery.json checkpoint that never advances past an unresolved run. plan-slices keeps contents: read, takes the store as an artifact, turns reuse off when recovery degraded or a run is unresolved, and carries the whole store to slices-report so nothing is lost. Any gh problem degrades to no recovered receipts with a named reason. * feat(evals): classify this wave's free-only tools and workflows for PR selection platform-qualification.yml, retired-command.ts, test-health-report.ts, bump-harness-version.ts and eval-bg.ts never run inside a paid case. * feat(evals): debounce PR push bursts before planning paid slices (W1d, CEO-15, ENG-11, DX-7) A tiny ubuntu-24.04 job waits 90 s only on synchronize when another run for the PR started in the last 15 minutes; cancel-in-progress supersedes, and a run that outlives the wait reports "superseded by <sha>" and plans nothing. Labels: evals-no-debounce skips the wait, evals-fresh disables receipt reuse. * perf(test): move the real-process browser settlement cases out of test-free-shards.test.ts (W6b) The 19 owned-browser settlement modes were 85 s of the file's 95 s and could not be packed apart from the fast runner unit cases. They move to a shared fixture with two files (lifecycle 47 s, ownership 39 s); the unit file drops to 10 s. Same modes, same assertions. * chore(evals): delete the finished validation_phase dispatch and its inline planner (W8f) Retirement (CEO-24): the protected behavior was a one-off cookie-repair validation subset (eight dependent cases) and a quality/behavior split of the census; that validation is complete, so the guarantee is withdrawn. Branch validation dispatches evals.yml with evals_all. * perf(test): inject the office-hours record grace in non-cooperative deadline tests * perf(test): shrink aside-render process slack via GSTACK_RENDER_SLACK_MS in timeout tests * perf(test): make the memorable lock give-up configurable for lock-contention tests * perf(test): check install-timeout knob normalization through its own setup lines * perf(test): inject a 2 s storage-reset deadline in the late isolated dispatch test * perf(test): shorten the slow gbrain fake to 1 s, still past the 300 ms probe timeout * ci(free-tests): run only cso-docker-integration in the free CSO Docker job (F16) cso-node-lifecycle-integration and cso-stack-cold-integration need GSTACK_CSO_TEST_STACK images and always skipped there; they stay in the CSO runtime workflows through test:cso:docker. * test(gen-skill-docs,plan-ceo): split mixed sentence pins into tokens and rules Sentences that wrap a backticked or bold token keep the token (expectTokens) and, when they state a safety rule, a keyword check; short safety sentences (25-39 chars) get the same treatment. * test(plan-ceo): convert ceo-workflow-clarity.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: periodic PTY case skill-e2e-plan-ceo-review-section-loading and the plan-ceo workflow judges. Sentence pins: 13 -> 1. * test(plan-eng): convert eng-review-routing.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: plan-eng E2E cases (skill-e2e-plan-eng-*) and the plan-eng workflow judge. Sentence pins: 28 -> 6. * test(plan-eng): convert eng-scope-entry-ap.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: plan-eng E2E cases (skill-e2e-plan-eng-*) and the plan-eng workflow judge. Sentence pins: 16 -> 5. * test(plan): convert plan-scope-selection.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: plan-review E2E cases and workflow judges in skill-llm-eval. Sentence pins: 19 -> 2. * test(qa): convert qa-lazy-sections.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: qa/qa-only E2E cases (skill-e2e-qa-*) and the qa workflow judge. Sentence pins: 71 -> 11. * test(qa): convert qa-browser-preservation.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: qa/qa-only E2E cases (skill-e2e-qa-*) and the qa workflow judge. Sentence pins: 25 -> 11. * test(qa): convert qa-probe-gates.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: qa/qa-only E2E cases (skill-e2e-qa-*) and the qa workflow judge. Sentence pins: 20 -> 5. * test(qa): convert qa-checkpoint-evidence.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: qa/qa-only E2E cases (skill-e2e-qa-*) and the qa workflow judge. Sentence pins: 7 -> 5. * test(qa): convert qa-evidence.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: qa/qa-only E2E cases (skill-e2e-qa-*) and the qa workflow judge. Sentence pins: 4 -> 3. * test(design): convert design-consultation-contract.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: design-consultation E2E/judge cases in touchfiles-data. Sentence pins: 44 -> 11. * test(outside-voice): convert run-in-background-guidance.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: outside-voice E2E cases and plan-review workflow judges. Sentence pins: 35 -> 5. * test(spec): convert spec-template-invariants.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: spec E2E/judge cases in touchfiles-data. Sentence pins: 36 -> 21. * perf(evals): 420 s census slice budget; case-shard skill-e2e-qa-workflow; seed its case walls (W5c) * feat(evals): evals.yml dispatch contract for eval:bg (CEO-17/29, DX-1, ENG-8/12) workflow_dispatch gains base_ref, base_sha, expected_sha, nonce and pr_receipts. The nonce appears in run-name so the dispatcher resolves its own run; evals_all=false runs the PR profile against base_sha/base_ref; a checkout that differs from expected_sha fails before any paid work with a named fix; pr_receipts reads that PR's receipts read-only through the recover-receipts artifact path (never the cache) and never saves. * ci(windows): pack the Windows lane with Windows-measured durations (W6e) The first sharded run (37221451711) finished in 6.0 min: the Linux seed has browse/test/cookie-import-native-job.test.ts at ~0 s (its cases skip on Linux) but it takes 122 s on Windows, so one shard ran 242 s against an 84 s prediction. The plan now reads scripts/free-test-durations-windows.json; a record_durations dispatch times every Windows-safe file alone and uploads it. * test(free): settlement case files import the runner rule they exercise Keeps the split files out of the test-of-test ratchet: the retry-eligibility rule is a direct runner import passed to the shared fixture. * fix(marathon): no hollow plan-decision-classification shard; office-hours marathon scenario scoped to the pilot (W2f) * test(free): satisfy the typecheck:test ratchet in the seed ratchet test * refactor(ci-history): one shared GitHub history reader with the CI flake-ledger reader Extract pass-rates' gh fetch layer into scripts/lib/ci-history.ts (CEO-09) and add the W7a reader: paged run listings that fail whole on any page error, per-run artifact downloads (cached, size-capped, data only), flake-ledger parsing, the pre-registered flaky-file rule (> 5% of main free-tests runs over a window of at least 20 runs, widened to the newest 20 runs when the window is thinner), a job-summary table, and named unavailable reasons with next steps. * feat(test-health): test:health report of the audit success metrics scripts/test-health-report.ts (CEO-09/06/22/32, DX-8/9/12/13) prints every success metric with its counting rule from CI history: PR full-fallback rate, reused PR trial records, PR-lane spend per merged PR and per validated revision, cancelled slice-minutes per week, push-to-verdict p50/p95, census expected failed trials per run with raw failure rate per kind/class and P(lane red) under the recorded panels vs single-trial aggregation, INFRA re-dispatches, quarantine evidence (insufficient evidence distinct from healthy), free flaky-pass rate, free/Windows wall, free serial time and the net-complexity line. An unreadable input prints 'unavailable: <reason>; next: <step>', never 0. --enforce fails on a flaky file (W7a) or > 5 unseeded free files (CEO-10); unavailable checks never fail and keep the issue open. * test(review): convert review-workflow-clarity.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: review E2E cases (skill-e2e-review*) and the review workflow judge in skill-llm-eval. Sentence pins: 85 -> 17. * test(review): convert review-entry-and-design-clarity-au.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: review E2E cases (skill-e2e-review*) and the review workflow judge in skill-llm-eval. Sentence pins: 15 -> 4. * test(review): convert review-enum-lifecycle.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: review E2E cases (skill-e2e-review*) and the review workflow judge in skill-llm-eval. Sentence pins: 8 -> 0. * test(ship): convert ship-control-flow.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: ship E2E cases (skill-e2e-ship*, skill-e2e-workflow) and the 'ship/SKILL.md workflow' judge. Sentence pins: 74 -> 9. * test(ship): convert ship-skip-requeue.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: ship E2E cases (skill-e2e-ship*, skill-e2e-workflow) and the 'ship/SKILL.md workflow' judge. Sentence pins: 28 -> 3. * test(ship): convert ship-plan-completion-invariants.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: ship E2E cases (skill-e2e-ship*, skill-e2e-workflow) and the 'ship/SKILL.md workflow' judge. Sentence pins: 28 -> 12. * test(ship): convert ship-reentry-gates.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: ship E2E cases (skill-e2e-ship*, skill-e2e-workflow) and the 'ship/SKILL.md workflow' judge. Sentence pins: 16 -> 4. * test(ship): convert ship-document-release-dispatch.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: ship E2E cases (skill-e2e-ship*, skill-e2e-workflow) and the 'ship/SKILL.md workflow' judge. Sentence pins: 11 -> 4. * test(ship): convert ship-apple-gate.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: ship E2E cases (skill-e2e-ship*, skill-e2e-workflow) and the 'ship/SKILL.md workflow' judge. Sentence pins: 7 -> 0. * test(ship): convert ship-skip-actor.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: ship E2E cases (skill-e2e-ship*, skill-e2e-workflow) and the 'ship/SKILL.md workflow' judge. Sentence pins: 6 -> 1. * test(ship): convert ship-template-redaction.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: ship E2E cases (skill-e2e-ship*, skill-e2e-workflow) and the 'ship/SKILL.md workflow' judge. Sentence pins: 5 -> 4. * test(ship): convert ship-publication-gates.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: ship E2E cases (skill-e2e-ship*, skill-e2e-workflow) and the 'ship/SKILL.md workflow' judge. Sentence pins: 5 -> 2. * test(ship): convert ship-review-loop.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: ship E2E cases (skill-e2e-ship*, skill-e2e-workflow) and the 'ship/SKILL.md workflow' judge. Sentence pins: 3 -> 1. * test(ship): convert ship-version-sync.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: ship E2E cases (skill-e2e-ship*, skill-e2e-workflow) and the 'ship/SKILL.md workflow' judge. Sentence pins: 5 -> 2. * test(ship): convert ship-pr-liveness-policy.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: ship E2E cases (skill-e2e-ship*, skill-e2e-workflow) and the 'ship/SKILL.md workflow' judge. Sentence pins: 4 -> 0. * test(plan-review): convert plan-review-cases.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: plan-review E2E cases and workflow judges in skill-llm-eval. Sentence pins: 58 -> 15. * test(autoplan): convert autoplan-phase-order.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: autoplan E2E cases (skill-e2e-autoplan-*) and the autoplan workflow judge. Sentence pins: 42 -> 11. * test(autoplan): convert autoplan-phase-handoff.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: autoplan E2E cases (skill-e2e-autoplan-*) and the autoplan workflow judge. Sentence pins: 20 -> 4. * test(autoplan): convert autoplan-snapshot.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: autoplan E2E cases (skill-e2e-autoplan-*) and the autoplan workflow judge. Sentence pins: 21 -> 5. * test(outside-voice): convert outside-voice-preflight.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: outside-voice E2E cases and plan-review workflow judges. Sentence pins: 26 -> 9. * test(ask-format): convert resolver-ask-user-format.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: AUQ E2E cases (skill-e2e-auq-*); prompt-injection rule kept as a meaning check. Sentence pins: 32 -> 15. * test(skills): convert binding-template-drift.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: workflow judges in skill-llm-eval. Sentence pins: 19 -> 13. * test(skills): convert carve-plan-fixture.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: workflow judges in skill-llm-eval. Sentence pins: 20 -> 6. * test(land-and-deploy): convert land-and-deploy-postfail.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: land-and-deploy E2E cases and its workflow judge. Sentence pins: 21 -> 14. * test(land-and-deploy): convert land-and-deploy-ci-gate.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: land-and-deploy E2E cases and its workflow judge. Sentence pins: 5 -> 4. * test(land-and-deploy): convert land-and-deploy-flow.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: land-and-deploy E2E cases and its workflow judge. Sentence pins: 5 -> 3. * test(office-hours): convert office-hours-completion.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: office-hours E2E cases (skill-e2e-office-hours*). Sentence pins: 16 -> 1. * test(plan-ceo): restore the stale closing-route guard The negative check for 'Closing hooks' / 'return to section' guards a retired route token, not a sentence; the first conversion pass dropped it. * ci(test-health): weekly test-health workflow with an honest tracking issue New test-health.yml (CEO-18/DX-9): Monday 10:00 UTC after the periodic census plus dispatch, free ubuntu-24.04 runner, permissions contents:read + actions:read + issues:write only. Runs bun run test:health --since-days 7 --enforce; an enforced failure upserts one tracking issue, a run with unavailable inputs keeps it open and lists them, and it closes only when every enforced check has evidence and passes. Only main runs touch the issue. * feat(evals): an edited paid test file runs its own gate cases in the PR lane (DX-11) A gate case outside the audited fast profile is selected when its single owning paid test file changed and the runner can select it by name (its Bun test is named by the case id). The manifest records directCases and validation accepts only recorded, name-addressable ones; the runner and planner read the file->cases map from test-pr-profile. Cases the runner cannot address stay deferred with the fix. An inventory test covers every owned gate case. Touches one hunk each in test-paid-shards.ts and lib/paid-plan.ts, and pr-shared-input-selection.test.ts's ship-skip pin. * ci(osv): tracking issue for scheduled reds and a 14-day suppression expiry test F11/W8f: a failed main OSV scan now upserts one tracking issue and a clean scan closes it (scheduled reds notified no one during the August backlog). A free test fails 14 days before any .osv-scanner.toml ignoreUntil (all four expire 2026-11-30), with the fix: upgrade and delete, or re-justify and move the date. * test(ship,review): keep guards against retired fail-open instructions 'skip silently' on reviewer failure and 'do not block /ship on subagent failure' were harmful instructions, not prose style; keep them absent with the shortest distinctive phrase. * feat(eval-select): default to the pr profile DX-10: eval:select previews the PR lane's selection by default, matching test:pr and eval:bg:pr; --profile full (or EVALS_PROFILE=full) keeps the plain touchfile selection. * test(evals): type-clean the recovery gh fake (typecheck:test ratchet) * chore(windows): record the Windows duration seed (run 37221963236) 573 Windows-safe files timed alone on windows-latest; cookie-import-native-job is 102 s there. Six shards now predict 154 s each. * feat(evals): eval:bg dispatches the pushed ref to CI or runs locally under a 1.5x-planned cap (W5d, CEO-17/29, DX-1/2/3/7, ENG-12/19) * feat(runners): --help on both shard runners via the shared flag loop; paid runner header describes today's planner/executor/report (W8e) * test(windows): drop the stale Playwright exclusion and force-include probe-proven files (W6e) A temporary windows-latest probe (run 37221995077) ran each of the 97 files excluded for 'launches Playwright browser' or 'raw /tmp/ path' alone: all 17 Playwright files pass (Chromium is installed and Bun drives it there), and 41 of the /tmp files pass with executed cases. The Playwright pattern is removed and the 41 files are force-included with the probe as their reason; the 36 real failures stay excluded. The curated subset grows from 573 to 631 files and the ratchet floor follows. Windows curation moves to scripts/lib/windows-curation.ts (the runner drops to 2000 lines). * test(free): one install fixture cloned from a read-only seed (W6c, ENG-1) Merge test/helpers/setup-codex-scope-fixture.ts into install-fixture.ts. The checkout is built once per test file into a read-only seed and cloned per fixture with copy-on-write where the filesystem has it (full copy otherwise), restoring each file's own mode; clones never hard-link the seed because put() and tests write in place. Callers register afterAll(cleanupSeed); Bun's runner fires no exit event, so seeds of killed runs are swept by pid. test/install-fixture.test.ts is the ENG-1 tripwire: put/setVersion/chmod in one clone leave the seed and a sibling unchanged, and clones share no inodes with the read-only seed. * test(free): split claude-overlay-setup by describe (W6b) The 115 s serial file becomes default/lifecycle/installs files (5/4/3 tests, unchanged bodies) sharing test/helpers/claude-overlay-fixture.ts, so the shard packer can balance them. * test(cso): convert cso-contracts.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: cso E2E/judge cases (skill-e2e-cso*, cso-eval). Sentence pins: 16 -> 8. * test(cso): convert cso-preserved.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: cso E2E/judge cases (skill-e2e-cso*, cso-eval). Sentence pins: 10 -> 3. * test(cso): convert cso-eval.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: cso E2E/judge cases (skill-e2e-cso*, cso-eval). Sentence pins: 7 -> 4. * test(browser): convert aside-driver.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: Aside/browse E2E cases; the installer ban stays a meaning check. Sentence pins: 27 -> 9. * test(browser): convert third-party-actions.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: Aside/browse E2E cases; the installer ban stays a meaning check. Sentence pins: 17 -> 2. * test(skills): convert skill-validation.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: workflow judges in skill-llm-eval. Sentence pins: 19 -> 6. * test(skills): convert workflow-excerpt.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: workflow judges in skill-llm-eval. Sentence pins: 37 -> 10. * test(skills): convert question-tuning-registry-path.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: workflow judges in skill-llm-eval. Sentence pins: 4 -> 0. * test(skills): convert host-conformance.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: workflow judges in skill-llm-eval. Sentence pins: 4 -> 4. * test(memory): convert memory-ingest-landing.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: memory-ingest free tests that run the binary. Sentence pins: 11 -> 9. * test(windows): exclude the skip-only claude-overlay setup files from the Windows subset Their real-setup cases are describe.skipIf(win32); after the split their bin/ spawns live in the shared helper, so the source scan stopped seeing them. * test(skills): convert agents-digest.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: the owning skills' E2E cases and workflow judges; CLI/hook output and fixture-data pins in the tail were left alone. Sentence pins: 1 -> 0. * test(skills): convert brain-preflight.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: the owning skills' E2E cases and workflow judges; CLI/hook output and fixture-data pins in the tail were left alone. Sentence pins: 2 -> 1. * test(skills): convert codex-skill-isolation.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: the owning skills' E2E cases and workflow judges; CLI/hook output and fixture-data pins in the tail were left alone. Sentence pins: 1 -> 0. * test(skills): convert office-hours-review.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: the owning skills' E2E cases and workflow judges; CLI/hook output and fixture-data pins in the tail were left alone. Sentence pins: 2 -> 1. * test(skills): convert onboarding-moved-literals.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: the owning skills' E2E cases and workflow judges; CLI/hook output and fixture-data pins in the tail were left alone. Sentence pins: 2 -> 2. * test(skills): convert open-gstack-browser-liveness.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: the owning skills' E2E cases and workflow judges; CLI/hook output and fixture-data pins in the tail were left alone. Sentence pins: 3 -> 2. * test(skills): convert plan-floor-review.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: the owning skills' E2E cases and workflow judges; CLI/hook output and fixture-data pins in the tail were left alone. Sentence pins: 3 -> 2. * test(skills): convert plan-review-report-recording.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: the owning skills' E2E cases and workflow judges; CLI/hook output and fixture-data pins in the tail were left alone. Sentence pins: 4 -> 2. * test(skills): convert regression-1539-review-self-verify.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: the owning skills' E2E cases and workflow judges; CLI/hook output and fixture-data pins in the tail were left alone. Sentence pins: 4 -> 0. * test(skills): convert skill-fixture.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: the owning skills' E2E cases and workflow judges; CLI/hook output and fixture-data pins in the tail were left alone. Sentence pins: 6 -> 3. * test(skills): convert template-context-parity.test.ts sentence pins Safety and authority sentences become expectMentions keyword checks (reword freely, keep the rule); other English sentence pins are dropped. Headings, labels, placeholders, commands, field names, enum/status tokens and ordering checks stay. Behavior and wording: the owning skills' E2E cases and workflow judges; CLI/hook output and fixture-data pins in the tail were left alone. Sentence pins: 1 -> 0. * test: restore pins on renderer output and paid-fixture inputs cso-contracts (the report renderer's required empty phrase), memory-ingest (binary output), carve-plan-fixture, ship-skip-actor and cso-eval (inputs the paid harness builds) assert product or fixture output, not skill prose, so the value-bar narrowing does not apply to them. * feat(eval-policy): v2 series identity, HARNESS_VERSION guard and identity backtest W4a (CEO-27/ENG-3/DX-6), not yet wired to the writer: caseSeriesIdentitiesV2 keys a case by the bytes it owns (paid test file, fixtures, its skills' prompt files including the generated SKILL.md) plus HARNESS_VERSION, and records the full consumed-input fingerprint as provenance. scripts/harness-version.json pins the blob of every shared-harness file (GLOBAL_TOUCHFILES plus the session runners, PTY harness, e2e gate and LLM judge), one line per file; test/harness-version.test.ts fails on drift with both fixes, and scripts/bump-harness-version.ts records the decision: --bump (new series for every case) or --non-behavioral (compatibility entry, no reset). eval-trial-series --backtest replays identities over weekly main revisions and recorded trials (ENG-3/DX-12). * feat(pass-rates): weekly history is main's scheduled runs plus main dispatches W4b: pass-rates reads evals-periodic history from main only, keeping scheduled runs and main dispatches and never a branch dispatch, so back-to-back branch validation runs neither feed pass rates nor count as weeks for quarantine expiry or drift. --branch <name> still reads one branch's runs for inspection. * docs(test-audit): EVAL_POLICY v2 decision memo with the identity backtest D1 memo (CEO-33, ENG-3, DX-12, CEO-27): P(green) arithmetic, false-blocking targets, the v2 identity rule and harness guard, weekly history, W4c evidence (the named 'stochastic' cases pass 26/27 to 34/34, so they stay rule), the backtest over 29 weekly main revisions and 14,898 recorded trials, what it means for quarantine reachability, alternatives (gating vs trended, adaptive panels not adopted, buy vs build), and the rollback proof on the pre-PR reader. * feat(eval-policy): EVAL_POLICY v2 writer: case-owned series identity The v2 writer, last commit of the W4 block (DX-12/ENG-14/ENG-21): the report job's stamp now writes caseSeriesIdentitiesV2 (case-owned bytes plus HARNESS_VERSION) as series_identity, the full consumed-input fingerprint as series_fingerprint and harness_version as provenance, and EVAL_POLICY.version is 2 (approved 2026-10-04, D1). The v1 touchfile identity is removed. Rollback = revert this commit (and the W4 commits above the reader-compat floor); readers then ignore the v2 records with a printed count. * test: restore pins on paid-harness prompt inputs review-enum-lifecycle and plan-review-report-recording assert the prompt a paid case's harness builds (opts.prompt / call.prompt), a fixture contract, not skill prose. * test(security): check injected safety lines on meaning, not capitals content-security, the canary instruction and the arm judge prompt still must carry their never-follow / never-output / exact-"none" rules; the checks are case-insensitive keyword checks so emphasis can change. The UNTRUSTED envelope markers and "none" value stay exact tokens. (Hidden element stripping fails locally only because Playwright Chromium is not installed; same at base.) * test(plan-ceo): keep the outside-voice scope-summary rule as a meaning check The first codemod pass left an empty if body (TS1313). * chore(windows): re-record the Windows duration seed for the 631-file subset (run 37222668939) * ci(free-tests): summarize every shard's flake ledger in the aggregate job (W7a) The aggregate downloads flake-ledger-* (one subdirectory per shard) and appends lane C's `scripts/test-health-report.ts flake-summary` output to the job summary before strict verification. The runner's own flaky table is dropped so the ledger reader stays the single source; --ci-verify keeps the shard-overrun warning. * feat(evals): free test files anywhere and the stored-zip helper never restore the full PR gate (W1a) The CEO-23 replay found design/test free tests forcing fallback (36485436963). * feat(evals): replay recorded PR pushes through today's selector (CEO-23, ENG-18) scripts/replay-pr-selection.ts reports per push the recorded vs replayed mode and case count, dropped gate cases, retired failed cases and every miss (a failed case that depends on the diff but is no longer selected). * refactor(evals): one case-sharded carve-section-loading file with a case id and touchfiles per skill (W5a) * test(free): hold qa-deadline's full-pipe case on a FIFO, not a paused Bun stream Bun gives a child 'pipe' stdio a unix socketpair, so whether the 2 MB fill actually blocks depends on the parent's reader and the host's socket buffer sizes. CI (run 36761671811, both attempts) saw exit 0 after ~130 ms; with net.core.{w,r}mem_default=4 MiB locally the old case fails 3/3 the same way. A FIFO the test never reads is bounded by the kernel pipe buffer, so the receipt write genuinely blocks and the 5 s settlement deadline must fire. The 7 s bound now starts once the preload has queued the write. * test(free): event-driven waits in pty-output-wake close-releases-observers: the 500 ms wall race becomes an ordering check (the waiter is released while only SIGINT has been sent, before close's escalation finishes), and the Bun.spawn spy fakes only the PTY launch so a shard neighbor's in-process spawn cannot add a stray SIGTERM (CI runs 36015568981, 36036582721, 36074636848). continuous-redraws: the fixture spinner stops once the observer has made five coalesced reads, so the run reaches its work deadline with no redraw in flight. Streaming right up to the deadline raced the helper's screen drain and failed as 'PTY screen parse failed; viewport is incomplete' (5 CI runs 09-30..10-03; 4/40 locally under 8 busy loops, 0/40 after). * test(free): session-runner long-capture handshake waits for the collected Read event The fake CLI's init line arms the runner's work-phase timer, so the worker's handshake (work-ready + a >200 s timer) could pass before the runner's read loop had collected the Read event printed just before work-ready. Advancing the clock then killed the run with the Read lost: readSection false (CI run 37194511124). The worker now also waits for the runner's own progress line for that Read. Forcing the observed ordering (work-ready 200 ms before the Read line) fails the old test deterministically and passes the new one. * test(free): budget-override restores the CI variables it rewrites Its provenance cases set and then deleted CI, GITHUB_ACTIONS, GITHUB_REF_NAME, GITHUB_SHA and the GitLab CI_* names without restoring them, so in a CI shard every later file ran with CI unset. qa-only-cleanup's real browse daemons then launched Chromium without --no-sandbox, the sandbox failed on the runner, and both real-Chromium cases timed out with 'QA cleanup fixture did not become ready' (shard 12 attempt 1 of six runs on 10-04, retry alone green). Retained startup log: 'Chromium sandboxing failed!', child env with no CI. Reproduced 3/3 with CI=true, userns denied and budget-override ahead of qa-only-cleanup in one process; 0/3 after. * test(free): pr-shared-input-selection names its base and package history Every selection now passes EVALS_BASE and packageVersionOnly explicitly, so no case reads the checkout's git state. Before, 12 calls ran detectBaseBranch and the cumulative case diffed package.json against merge-base(origin/main, HEAD) — the ambient input that turned main red in runs 36572856858 and 36594314027. A PATH git spy counts 14 git calls in the old file and 0 now. * feat(evals): derive PR-lane dependents for unmapped files instead of restoring the full gate scripts/pr-dependencies.ts derives, from the checked-out tree, which paid cases consume each repository file: test import closures, repo paths and path.join segments in code/shell/skill text (whole-line comments and selection data excluded), bin script names, compiled binaries by outfile path (scripts/build.sh), package scripts, template placeholders through RESOLVERS, and host configs by host id. The global touchfiles' import closure is global. PR selection: an unmapped file with derived consumers puts the run in the new 'dependents' mode (every dependent gate case and judge, no profile cut); a tracked file under a derivable directory that nothing reaches is exempt; periodic/marathon workflows, .gitignore and tsconfig.test.json never run the PR gate. PR_FULL_GATE_FILES is the fail-closed list (deps, CI image, setup, build, evals.yml and its actions, test preload, tsconfig.json, .gitattributes, the skill generator and preamble resolvers, the eval policy). Untracked or underivable files restore the full gate with fix text. The summary and PR comment list derived dependents. * feat(evals): replay misses count derived dependents; report wave vs ordinary pushes (CEO-23) * test: drop FREE_FIXTURES entries for fixtures deleted in W8b * test: re-shape the census attribution fixture to qa-workflow and carve case shards * test: census fixture case order * ci: 420 s PR-lane slices with per-slice ceilings; periodic tracking issue only on main evals.yml joins the census lanes at the 420 s slice budget (W5c/CEO-15) and indexes each eval slice's job timeout from .plan.sliceCiTimeoutMinutes with the slice-deadline clock as its first step (W2c/ENG-2). evals-periodic.yml's tracking-issue upsert and close run only on refs/heads/main, so a branch dispatch whose gate census is skipped (CEO-04) never opens or closes #2755. * docs: integrate lane docs for the audit wave (eval-bg backends, PR fallback, policy v2, ceilings, evidence) - CLAUDE.md: 'Running evals as an agent' describes scripts/eval-bg.ts's dispatch and local backends, forcing flags, the sentinel and status; eval:select's PR-profile default; prompt-structure helper and value-bar terms. instruction-facts now requires scripts/eval-bg.ts in that section. - CONTRIBUTING.md: decision table gains test:health, eval:select default, eval:bg backends and the include_gate_census / evals_all dispatch lines; 420 s runners and per-runner ceilings; flake ledger, OSV tracking issue and expiry test, weekly test health; prompt-structure guidance. - AGENTS.md: build commands name the eval:bg backend choice and test:health. - docs/TESTING_INTERNALS.md: anchors the fix texts point to (#pr-paid-lane-fallback, #pass-rate-policy-versions, #harness-version, #flake-ledger, #duration-seed), receipts/recovery/debounce, per-slice ceilings, the slice deadline with not_run/hung and checkpoints, the eval-bg cap formula in place of the detach floors, EVAL_POLICY v2 history, carve case shards via --case. - docs/test-audit-2026-10.md: CEO-23 replay (165/168 -> 164/168 full-fallback, 0 misses), ENG-17 slice table (re-measured on this tree), D2 prose-pin metric. - TODOS.md: progress note on 'Let pass-rate history decide the rest'. - test/testing-internals-anchors.test.ts: every TESTING_INTERNALS.md#anchor named in code must match a heading. * test(free): hold qa-deadline's blocked-output-pipe receipts on a FIFO The five 'guard %s receipts survive a blocked output pipe' cases filled a paused Bun child pipe with 2 MiB. That pipe is a unix socketpair, so the fill only blocks while the host's socket buffers are smaller than the write: with net.core.{w,r}mem_default=4 MiB the old cases fail 13 of 15 case runs (the guard finishes before the test resumes the stream). The held stream is now a FIFO the test drains only after resume(), bounded by the kernel pipe buffer; Windows keeps the paused pipe. Bounds and assertions are unchanged. * test(free): qa-deadline waits for a written pid, not just the pid file DRIVER and LEAF write their pid with writeFileSync, so under load ready() can see the file before its digits and fail 'expected > 0, received 0' (seen once in 150 loaded runs). After any early failure the finally SIGKILLs the CLI, which orphans the detached command group; a leaf whose pid file is not yet readable then keeps the output stream open and the case hangs to its 15 s timeout (2/80 old-file runs and 3/310 FIFO-only runs under 8 busy loops; the instrumented hang showed the CLI already SIGKILLed by the finally). ready() now polls within the same 3 s bound until the file holds a positive pid. * fix(evals): a deleted file selects the dependents of the live files that still reference it PR selection treated every path absent from the head tree as an unknown dependency, so any PR that deleted a file forced the full gate. A deleted path is now placed like a live one, against the head tree: a matching touchfile selects its cases; live code, skill text or a full-gate input that still references it (path, extensionless import target, relative import, bin name, ancestor directory, compiled-binary outfile; whole-line comments and data files excluded) contributes its dependents, a full-gate referencer restores the full gate with a 'deleted but still referenced' fix, and an unreferenced deleted path has no dependents. Deleted PR_FULL_GATE_FILES entries still force the full gate. Tests that used absent paths as stand-ins for new unmapped files now use tracked root files (or an explicit tracked set); the CEO-23 replay counts misses through those references too. * docs: integrate free-suite lane docs (seed anchor, Windows lane, native qualification, install fixture, flake rules) - docs/TESTING_INTERNALS.md: '### Free suite duration seed' (the anchor the seed messages link) with DX-13, the 99th-percentile packing, --ci-plan warning, --ci-verify overruns and the CEO-10 seed ratchet; the Windows 6-job lane, its Windows-measured seed and refresh dispatch, curation and WINDOWS_CURATED_FLOOR; native-qualification.yml modes; the merged install fixture; test-only timing knobs; the flake-ledger job summary, Windows ledger names and three free-suite flake rules; zsh in the Ubicloud mirror. - scripts/test-health-report.ts links #free-suite-duration-seed, so the two seed messages share one heading (the anchor test caught the split). - CONTRIBUTING.md: Windows seed refresh and native qualification rows; seed-source pointer. AGENTS.md: Windows six-job lane. - docs/cso-release-qualification.md: the free CSO Docker job runs only cso-docker-integration.test.ts. - docs/test-audit-2026-10.md: free-suite evidence lines. - TODOS.md: CEO-11b progress note on the pre-push hook hang. * test: final duration seeds on the integrated tree; retire the emptied cookie-validation-phases file Linux seed re-recorded on Ubicloud standard-16 and the Windows seed from dispatch run 37227140871, both atc903310. The seed allowlist drops the three entries that are no longer over the ceiling. cookie-validation-phases lost its validation-phase pins with W8f and its Windows/Dia pins moved to windows-native-workflows with native-qualification.yml, so the file is deleted and the curated Windows floor rises to 638. The Windows recorder writes the seed at its default path so GSTACK_FREE_TEST_DURATIONS never leaks into timed tests. * test: re-express stale PR-lane pins against the new evals.yml contract - ci-eval-cache: the profile/fresh expressions now include evals_all=false dispatches and pr_receipts/evals-fresh; the PR store is restored only by recover-receipts (still scoped to repository_id + PR, PR events only), plan-slices takes it as an artifact and never touches the cache, saves stay PR-only, EVALS_CACHE_PR binds pr_receipts dispatches, and the report verdict artifact carries report receipts. - ci-paid-coordination: plan-slices needs only the two ubuntu coordination jobs (never the image); the fork/Dependabot clause is unchanged on plan-slices and also gates debounce and recover-receipts; only recovery holds actions: read. - qa-supervision-selection: auq-consistency and auq-verbose-vs-carved-ab (W1b) reach claude-pty-runner and pty-screen through auq-sdk-capture, exactly as auq-format-gate does. - paid-retry-supervision: the full-validation plan uses a tracked full-gate input (setup); an absent path is now a deletion placed by its references. * ci(windows): record the Windows seed at the default path * chore: HARNESS_VERSION non-behavioral decision for the audit-wave integration * v1.91.20.0 release metadata: test, eval and CI audit wave * test(compare-board): wait for the post-submit state the feedback POST settles The two post-submit assertions read the board once, but the board disables the submit button and shows the message only after its feedback POST resolves. On a loaded Ubicloud shard the read beat the round trip (FLAKY-PASS in the final free-suite run). Delaying the POST by 400 ms reproduces both failures at HEAD; polling for the settled state passes. * test(plan-eng plan-mode): run the seeded STOP-gate smoke in its own fixture project The seeded plan proposes a custom test runner, so the review's Step 0 reads the working tree's test setup. In the gstack checkout that is gstack's own sharded runner, and the case timed out at 300 s in census 37228573062 after this wave reshaped the runner. It now runs in a four-file Bun project with git history, with the product-notice suppression auto-decide-preserved's standalone fixture already uses. Local pass on Bun 1.4.0 + Claude Code 2.1.284: asked in 121 s, seed tokens observed. * test(plan-mode evidence): pin the seeded eng smoke's isolated fixture cwd and env * ci(image): Git >= 2.44 so paid shared-libs cases run the supported safe-git path bin/gstack-safe-git prefixes every /deslop-shared-libs Git read with --no-lazy-fetch, which noble's git 2.43 rejects (exit 129). The eval image therefore ran every paid shared-libs case on the unsupported-Git fallback: local history unavailable, branch HEAD unknown. shared-libs-read-only failed on exactly that in PR run 37230639146 ("Current branch HEAD: unknown. The safe-git probe failed (unknown option: --no-lazy-fetch, git 2.43.0)") and in 2 of 74 earlier PR runs. The image installs current Git from the Ubuntu Git Maintainers PPA and fails its build if --no-lazy-fetch is missing; the deliberate unsupported-Git case keeps its fake Git. * eval: pool matching branch census trials into main's pass-rate series (D1 option b) Approved 2026-10-05. eval:pass-rates also reads completed branch census runs in the weekly window. A branch trial counts only toward a series a main run also has (same case-owned bytes, HARNESS_VERSION, model and CLI), so a branch extends main's history but never starts or becomes a case's current series; weeks for quarantine expiry still count main runs only. The D1 backtest put this at 67 of 210 cases with enough trials for the entry rule, against 0 of 195 on main alone. * C2: /qa defines its outcome filename fields; QA report templates name the measured timing fields Low judge samples in failing panels named both: qa workflow (37186854666) 'an undefined {user} in the outcome filename', and qa-only workflow (37198445662) 'template asks for Duration / durationMs totals while reporting.md mandates Probe budget and Guarded command time'. The qa union stays under its 1.11 size ratio (93292 of 93294 bytes). (cherry picked from commite14c0c1de1) * C2: Browser Quick gets a feasible budget; QA loop names its directory and stop path Judge rationales on the qa-only panels (2 of the last 3) cited the 30 s Browser Quick budget: homepage + 5 targets, each a checkpoint write and a guarded command, left ~5 s per probe. Quick is now 180 s (method text: 3 minutes); the qa-only-no-fix paid check expects the same native deadline. PROBE_DIR points at its source line, a stopped loop goes to the final report steps (annotations, materialize, Markdown), and /review and /ship say that after smoke expiry only plan checks rerun in revalidation. (cherry picked from commit78d4a2a343) * qa: fit the C2 judge fixes under the qa and review size caps Brings GSTA-21's qa.ts trims (3bd625d,ce73af0) for the cherry-picked C2 wording: PROBE_DIR keeps 'owned', the stop line points at §4, and the post-expiry rule is one sentence, so /review fits its cap. qa measures 93,303 / 84,049 = 1.11010 against the same 1.1102 cap GSTA-21 set. The qa-only workflow judge passed 10 of 10 local trials on this wording (7 of 10 before the C2 fixes). * test: qa-only fixture keeps its caller-set 30 s deadline The qa-only-no-fix fixture tells the model to start the guard with 30 s (a caller limit), so its deadline assertion's default stays 30 000 ms; the product's Browser Quick default (180 s) does not apply to it. Reverts the helper and its test to their base. (cherry picked from commite36e622add) * test: qa-quick sets a caller probe limit and drains past its session budget C2 raised Browser Quick's native budget to 180 s. qa-quick is the only gate case on the native budget, and its wall went 194 s (main periodic, pre-C2) -> 254 s and 274 s (this PR's runs) -> 300 s session timeout (run 37242691913): the agent now probes every navigation target with a checkpoint, then needs ~80 s to report. Like qa-only-no-fix, the eval now sets a caller probe limit (30 s), scopes the fixture, and gives bun's outer timeout the session drain margin instead of racing the 300 s session. The product's 180 s budget and the session budget are unchanged. Diagnostic rerun passed in 195 s. (cherry picked from commitf8dc64031e) * chore: restore the audit wave's package scripts after the main merge (version 1.91.23) * qa: keep main's one-sentence post-expiry rule for /review and /ship The C2 variants ("step 4c reruns plan checks only" and "even in 4c") read to the review workflow judge as conflicting with Step 5.8's repeat-pass reruns: 6 of 10 local trials passed with the longer sentence and PR run 37248650879 failed on the shorter one. Main's "Post-expiry smoke rechecks are not-run." passed 10 of 10. qa (9/10), qa-only (10/10) and ship-managed-hook-refresh (10/10) were measured on the same tree. * v1.91.24.0: move off the slot #3036 claims
33 KiB
gstack development
Commands
bun install # install dependencies
bun run dev <cmd> # run CLI in dev mode, e.g. bun run dev goto https://example.com
bun run typecheck # strict tsc over product code (zero errors required)
bun run typecheck:test # test-code type-debt ratchet
bun run build # gen docs + compile binaries
bun run gen:skill-docs # regenerate SKILL.md files from templates
bun run skill:check # health dashboard for all skills
bun run dev:skill # watch mode: auto-regen + validate on change
bun run slop # full slop-scan report (all files)
bun run slop:diff # slop findings in files changed on this branch only
bun run audit:manifest # file slices for /claude-api prompt-audit; rerun it at each frontier-model release (CONTRIBUTING.md)
Test and eval commands, their cost and what each needs live in one table:
Which command do I run?. The two you
need most are bun run test (free acceptance) and bun run eval:bg:pr (paid,
changed coverage). Retired names such as test:evals and test:e2e print their
replacement and exit 1.
Paid evals require ANTHROPIC_API_KEY. Codex E2E tests (test/codex-e2e.test.ts,
test/codex-e2e-sol-scope.test.ts) use Codex's own auth — the hermetic runner copies
only auth.json from ${CODEX_HOME:-~/.codex} and pins CODEX_HOME in the child
env — no OPENAI_API_KEY env var needed.
Hermetic E2E + env keys: every E2E runner spawns children through
test/helpers/hermetic-env.ts (allowlist-scrubbed env, fresh seeded
CLAUDE_CONFIG_DIR, temp GSTACK_HOME, --strict-mcp-config); per-test
env: overrides merge last onto a COMPLETE hermetic env, so they're safe.
A PTY test that types a /skill command must pass seedSkills: true.
Debug against real operator state with EVALS_HERMETIC=0. Full detail
(env-shim, seeding tripwires, wiring tests):
docs/TESTING_INTERNALS.md.
Test selection and tiers: the sharded paid runner (test:pr,
eval:bg:pr, test:gate:sharded) selects tests from git diff through the
dependency lists in test/helpers/touchfiles.ts (EVALS_ALL=1 forces
everything; eval:select previews the PR profile, --profile full the plain
touchfile selection). Classify every new E2E test in E2E_TIERS: safety guardrail or
deterministic functional test -> gate; quality benchmark, Opus model test,
non-deterministic, or external service (Codex, Gemini) -> periodic.
test/e2e-tier-alignment.test.ts enforces the tiers. CI lanes and periodic
exclusions: docs/TESTING_INTERNALS.md.
Testing
bun run test # final full free acceptance after focused repairs and source freeze
bun run eval:bg:pr # required changed PR coverage, with explicit deferrals
Follow Validation discipline in AGENTS.md: prove repairs with focused checks first, complete required selected evaluations, then run the full free suite once on the final integrated code. During repairs, focused checks replace a full-suite run before every commit.
bun run test routes through scripts/test-free-shards.ts, whose strict
per-shard classification fails a shard that lacks bun's summary line.
TREE_MUTATING lists the files that still run in their own trailing serial
shard (today only test/bootstrap-retention.test.ts). Never type
bare bun test for the suite: it walks the whole repo, loading paid eval files
and missing the strict classifier. bun run test:pr runs the selected short
live behaviors and quality judges and reports deferred broad coverage. Full free
acceptance and required PR checks must pass before publishing. See
testing policy for commands and measured targets.
Tests that need Aside itself self-skip unless a Mac has the Aside app open.
Shard packing, judge reuse and engine skips:
docs/TESTING_INTERNALS.md.
New or changed tests follow the test value bar: each one
protects behavior a real regression would break, and contract tests (SKILL.md
goldens, and prompt bytes that are a contract as defined below) stay. The bar's
source is scripts/resolvers/test-value.ts.
In this repo, prompt bytes are a contract only when software reads them (a
parser, hook, grader or another skill consumes the exact text) or a recorded
eval shows the wording matters. Tests on skill templates and generated SKILL.md
pin structure, step order, routing tables, machine-read markers and
safety-critical lines; check safety lines case-insensitively, on meaning rather
than capitals. Leave behavior to E2E cases and judges. Don't pin emphasis,
capitalization, issue numbers, or a sentence a behavioral check already covers,
and when a rewrite changes a pinned sentence, replace the pin with a structural
or meaning-level check instead of pinning the new sentence. The terms are defined
in docs/test-value-bar.md ("Prompt-byte contract",
"Sentence pin"). Use test/helpers/prompt-structure.ts (between,
expectTokens, expectAbsent, expectOrdered, expectMentions) for
template/SKILL.md checks: tokens and order exactly, safety rules as
case-insensitive keyword co-occurrence in one sentence.
Projects tune /ship's coverage gate with optional CLAUDE.md ## Test Coverage
keys, all absent by default: Minimum:, Target:, Generation cap: (default 5),
Base control: (auto or off), Base control budget: (seconds, default 90) and
Star rating: (auto or off).
Project structure
Full annotated tree: docs/PROJECT_STRUCTURE.md.
Quick map: browse/ gstack's own headless-browser CLI (the fallback
engine) plus the /browse skill, design/ design binary, make-pdf/ PDF
binary, hosts/ typed host configs, scripts/ build+DX tooling
(gen-skill-docs, resolvers — resolvers/aside.ts is the Aside contract),
test/ validation+evals, lib/ shared libraries (aside-render.ts renders
local HTML through Aside, falling back to the engine; design-catalog.ts is
the typed design anti-pattern catalog every design skill renders from), bin/
CLI utilities (gstack-render.ts is the render CLI skills call;
gstack-design-detect.ts and gstack-design-md.ts are the design detector
and open-DESIGN.md tools), extension/ Chrome
extension, one directory per skill (ship/, review/, qa/, ...),
.github/ CI, contrib/ contributor tools, docs/designs/ design documents.
SKILL.md workflow
SKILL.md files are generated from .tmpl templates. To update docs:
- Edit the
.tmplfile (e.g.SKILL.md.tmplorbrowse/SKILL.md.tmpl) - Run
bun run gen:skill-docs(orbun run buildwhich does it automatically) - Commit both the
.tmpland generated.mdfiles
The same gen:skill-docs run writes two more generated files from lib/:
review/design-checklist.md (from lib/design-catalog.ts, through
scripts/resolvers/design-checklist.ts) and lib/dom-dump.js (from
lib/dom-dump-script.ts). Edit the catalog or the script source, regenerate,
and commit both; never edit the generated file
(test/design-checklist-sync.test.ts fails on drift).
Generation uses each host's defaultModel (claude for existing hosts, gpt
for Codex) unless --model is explicit. Codex installs additionally read the
top-level model from ${CODEX_HOME:-~/.codex}/config.toml; rerun
./setup --host codex after changing that model. Note: bun run build and a
bare gen:skill-docs --host codex render the host default (gpt) — if your
Codex config.toml pins a different model, rerun ./setup --host codex
afterwards to restore your profile (single-owner persistence is filed in
TODOS.md).
Browser steps in skills are aside repl scripts per
scripts/resolvers/aside.ts, each with its $B equivalent for the fallback
engine. To add a new browse command: add it to browse/src/commands.ts and
rebuild. To add a snapshot flag: add it to SNAPSHOT_FLAGS in
browse/src/snapshot.ts and rebuild. Local-HTML rendering in a skill template
is a bun run ~/.claude/skills/gstack/bin/gstack-render.ts call; new render
options go into lib/aside-render.ts (which handles the fallback), never into
a skill's own bash.
Size budgets: generated SKILL.md files warn above 160KB (~40K tokens);
test/catalog-budget.test.ts caps the always-loaded skill catalog at
CATALOG_BUDGET_TOKEN_EQUIVALENTS (1,194 today; each new skill ratchets it); and
test/context-budget-ratchet.test.ts pins per-skill token ceilings against
test/fixtures/context-budget.json (for legitimate growth or a landed
reduction, re-run bun test/helpers/capture-context-budget.ts and commit the
refreshed fixture in the same commit). Rationale and protocol:
docs/CONTRIBUTOR_REFERENCE.md.
Merge conflicts on SKILL.md files: NEVER resolve conflicts on generated SKILL.md
files by accepting either side. Instead: (1) resolve conflicts on the .tmpl templates
and scripts/gen-skill-docs.ts (the sources of truth), (2) run bun run gen:skill-docs
to regenerate all SKILL.md files, (3) stage the regenerated files. Accepting one side's
generated output silently drops the other side's template changes.
Platform-agnostic design
Skills must NEVER hardcode framework-specific commands, file patterns, or directory structures. Instead:
- Read CLAUDE.md for project-specific config (test commands, eval commands, etc.)
- If missing, AskUserQuestion — let the user tell you or let gstack search the repo
- Persist the answer to CLAUDE.md so we never have to ask again
This applies to test commands, eval commands, deploy commands, and any other project-specific behavior. The project owns its config; gstack reads it.
Writing SKILL templates
SKILL.md.tmpl files are prompt templates read by Claude, not bash scripts. Each bash code block runs in a separate shell — variables do not persist between blocks.
Rules:
- Use natural language for logic and state. Don't use shell variables to pass state between code blocks. Instead, tell Claude what to remember and reference it in prose (e.g., "the base branch detected in Step 0").
- Don't hardcode branch names. Detect
main/master/etc dynamically viagh pr vieworgh repo view. Use{{BASE_BRANCH_DETECT}}for PR-targeting skills. Use "the base branch" in prose,<base>in code block placeholders. - Keep bash blocks self-contained. Each code block should work independently. If a block needs context from a previous step, restate it in the prose above.
- Express conditionals as English. Instead of nested
if/elif/elsein bash, write numbered decision steps: "1. If X, do Y. 2. Otherwise, do Z."
Writing style (V1)
Default output from every tier-≥2 skill follows the Writing Style section in
scripts/resolvers/preamble/generate-writing-style.ts: jargon glossed on first
use (curated list in scripts/jargon-list.json, which the skill Reads at runtime
on the first jargon term), questions framed in
outcome terms ("what breaks for your users if...") not implementation terms,
short sentences, decisions close with user impact. Power users who want the
tighter V0 prose set gstack-config set explain_level terse (binary switch,
no middle mode). See docs/designs/PLAN_TUNING_V1.md for the full design
rationale. The review pacing overhaul that originally tried to ride alongside
writing-style was extracted to V1.1 — see docs/designs/PACING_UPDATES_V0.md.
Browser interaction
gstack drives the Aside AI browser (macOS 15+) first and falls back to its own
browser engine when Aside is absent. When you need to interact with a browser
(QA, dogfooding, inspecting a page), use the /browse skill: it probes Aside
and, on READY, drives it — the user's real browser with their real sessions —
through aside repl scripts that follow the contract in
scripts/resolvers/aside.ts ({{ASIDE_SETUP}}). Every browser skill (/qa,
/qa-only, /design-review, /canary, /benchmark, /scrape) does the same,
and web research in skills runs through Aside's agent ({{ASIDE_RESEARCH}})
before the WebSearch tool. When the probe says NEEDS_ASIDE or
ASIDE_NOT_RUNNING (Linux, Windows, a closed Aside app), the skill resolves
$B per {{BROWSE_FALLBACK}} and runs the browse binary instead — $B <command>
is a legitimate tool in that context, and cookie import, GStack Browser headed
mode, /pair-agent, and browser-skills//skillify belong to it. Local HTML a
skill generated itself (make-pdf, diagram, design previews) renders through
bin/gstack-render.ts / lib/aside-render.ts, which serve the file on
loopback and print or screenshot it in Aside, or in the engine when Aside is
absent — never point the renderer at a site. NEVER use
mcp__claude-in-chrome__* tools — they are slow, unreliable, and not what this
project uses.
Server / sidebar / extension internals: before editing browse/src/server.ts,
extension/, the sidebar PTY, any SSE endpoint, or CDP session code, read
docs/BROWSER_INTERNALS.md — sidebar message flow,
WebSocket auth, tunnel dual-listener rules, Unicode sanitization at egress,
SSE/CDP helpers, setup symlink hardening, and the sidebar security stack all
live there, each pinned by a CI tripwire.
Egress receipts at every off-machine sink (v1.63.0.0+). Every gstack-initiated
send off the machine MUST write a receipt BEFORE the send: TypeScript callers use
writeReceipt from lib/egress-receipt.ts; shell scripts source
bin/gstack-egress-lib.sh and use _receipted_curl / _receipted_git.
test/egress-receipt-wiring.test.ts fails CI on an unreceipted new sink.
Failure polarity, scanner exemptions and the _aside_exec wrapper:
docs/CONTRIBUTOR_REFERENCE.md.
Dev symlink awareness
When developing gstack, .claude/skills/gstack may be a symlink back to this
working directory (gitignored). This means skill changes are live immediately,
great for rapid iteration, risky during big refactors where half-written skills
could break other Claude Code sessions using gstack concurrently.
Check once per session: Run ls -la .claude/skills/gstack to see if it's a
symlink or a real copy. If it's a symlink to your working directory, be aware that:
- Template changes +
bun run gen:skill-docsimmediately affect all gstack invocations - Breaking changes to SKILL.md.tmpl files can break concurrent gstack sessions
- During large refactors, remove the symlink (
rm .claude/skills/gstack) so the global install at~/.claude/skills/gstack/is used instead
Skill linking and ownership (#2119): setup installs each skill as a
top-level directory (short qa or namespaced gstack-qa, per skill_prefix),
and setup and bin/gstack-relink only delete or link over an entry they can
prove is gstack's; keep those two copies of the rule in sync. Proof rules,
prune behavior and pinning tests:
docs/CONTRIBUTOR_REFERENCE.md.
Note: Vendoring gstack into a project's repo is deprecated. Use global install
./setup --teaminstead. See README.md for team mode instructions.
For plan reviews: When reviewing plans that modify skill templates or the gen-skill-docs pipeline, consider whether the changes should be tested in isolation before going live (especially if the user is actively using gstack in other windows).
Upgrade migrations: When a change modifies on-disk state (directory structure,
config format, stale files) in ways that could break existing user installs, add a
migration script to gstack-upgrade/migrations/. Read CONTRIBUTING.md's "Upgrade
migrations" section for the format and testing requirements. The upgrade skill runs
these automatically after ./setup during /gstack-upgrade.
Compiled binaries — never commit browse/dist/, design/dist/, or make-pdf/dist/
The browse/dist/, design/dist/, and make-pdf/dist/ directories contain
compiled Bun binaries (browse, find-browse, design, ~62MB each). These are
Mach-O arm64 only — they do NOT work on Linux, Windows, or Intel Macs. The
./setup script builds from source for every platform.
These directories are untracked and gitignored (.gitignore:3-6; the
browse/dist/ binaries were untracked in 64d5a3e4, v0.11.16.0; the others were
never tracked). They will NOT appear in git status. If a dist binary ever does
show up in git status, something force-added it (git add -f) — do not commit
it; unstage it and find out how it got there.
When staging files, always use specific filenames (git add file1 file2) — never
git add . or git add -A, which can sweep in build outputs and junk.
Redaction guard (PII / secrets / legal content)
lib/redact-patterns.ts + lib/redact-engine.ts (CLI bin/gstack-redact,
opt-in hook bin/gstack-redact-prepush) catch credentials, PII and legal content
before an external sink. It is a guardrail, not airtight enforcement; never
claim it stops a determined leaker. Always scan the EXACT bytes that will be
sent, and render skill docs from scripts/resolvers/redact-doc.ts. Tiers,
visibility, fences and config keys:
docs/CONTRIBUTOR_REFERENCE.md.
Commit style
Always bisect commits. Every commit should be a single logical change. When you've made multiple changes (e.g., a rename + a rewrite + new tests), split them into separate commits before pushing. Each commit should be independently understandable and revertable.
Examples of good bisection:
- Rename/move separate from behavior changes
- Test infrastructure (touchfiles, helpers) separate from test implementations
- Template changes separate from generated file regeneration
- Mechanical refactors separate from new features
When the user says "bisect commit" or "bisect and push," split staged/unstaged changes into logical commits and push.
Slop-scan: AI code quality, not AI code hiding
We use slop-scan to catch patterns where AI-generated code is genuinely worse than what a human would write. We are NOT trying to pass as human code. We are AI-coded and proud of it. The goal is code quality.
npx slop-scan scan . # human-readable report
npx slop-scan scan . --json # machine-readable for diffing
Config: slop-scan.config.json at repo root (currently excludes **/vendor/**).
Before fixing any finding, read docs/SLOP_SCAN.md:
it separates genuine quality fixes (empty catches around file ops →
safeUnlink(), process kills → safeKill()) from linter gaming we
reject (string-matching error messages, tightening best-effort cleanup).
Utilities live in lib/error-handling.ts. Don't chase the score.
Community PR guardrails
When reviewing or merging community PRs, always AskUserQuestion before accepting any commit that:
- Touches ETHOS.md — this file is Garry's personal builder philosophy. No edits from external contributors or AI agents, period.
- Removes or softens promotional material — YC references, founder perspective, and product voice are intentional. PRs that frame these as "unnecessary" or "too promotional" must be rejected.
- Changes Garry's voice — the tone, humor, directness, and perspective in skill templates, CHANGELOG, and docs are not generic. PRs that rewrite voice to be more "neutral" or "professional" must be rejected.
Even if the agent strongly believes a change improves the project, these three categories require explicit user approval via AskUserQuestion. No exceptions. No auto-merging. No "I'll just clean this up."
Checking out PRs from garrytan-agents
Fork PRs (for example from garrytan-agents/gstack) get no base-repo secrets,
so eval CI fails with empty-env auth. Unless the user says to leave it as a fork
PR, push the branch to garrytan/gstack and re-target the PR from there:
docs/CONTRIBUTOR_REFERENCE.md.
CHANGELOG + VERSION style
Choose versions autonomously; default to PATCH. Garry delegates release
version decisions to the agent. Do not ask him to choose or approve a version,
including when an already-approved version collides with another PR. This policy
overrides generic version-approval prompts in /ship and /document-release.
Prefer PATCH (X.Y.Z+1.0) for ordinary releases, including fixes, additions, refactors, test infrastructure and coordinated multi-file work. Diff size alone is not a reason to choose MINOR. Choose MINOR (X.Y+1.0.0) or MAJOR (X+1.0.0.0) only when calling the release a patch would be plainly misleading ("ridiculous"), such as an incompatible public-interface change or a genuinely new product-scale release. Make that judgment without another approval question.
Use bin/gstack-next-version to check the live release queue before publishing.
If a slot is claimed, advance to the next available version at the chosen bump
level and use bin/gstack-version-bump to synchronize release metadata. A higher
base version does not itself require a MINOR bump. Keep the PR ready for Garry to
merge; autonomous version decisions do not authorize merging, deploying or
skipping required validation.
VERSION and CHANGELOG are branch-scoped. Each shipping branch gets its own
bump and one entry, written at /ship time, that describes what THIS branch
adds versus main, for users, with no branch-internal versions or development
narrative. VERSION stays 4-digit; package.json carries the 3-digit npm
translation owned by bin/gstack-version-bump, so never hand-edit it. Read
docs/CHANGELOG_STYLE.md BEFORE writing an entry: it
holds the versioning invariant, the merge-main checks, what stays out and the
entry format. Always credit community contributions with
Contributed by @username.
AI effort compression
When estimating or discussing effort, always show both human-team and CC+gstack time:
| Task type | Human team | CC+gstack | Compression |
|---|---|---|---|
| Boilerplate / scaffolding | 2 days | 15 min | ~100x |
| Test writing | 1 day | 15 min | ~50x |
| Feature implementation | 1 week | 30 min | ~30x |
| Bug fix + regression test | 4 hours | 15 min | ~20x |
| Architecture / design | 2 days | 4 hours | ~5x |
| Research / exploration | 1 day | 3 hours | ~3x |
Completeness is cheap. Don't recommend shortcuts when the complete implementation is achievable. Boil the ocean — the complete thing is the goal; only genuinely unrelated multi-quarter migrations are separate scope, never an excuse for a shortcut. See the Completeness Principle in the skill preamble for the full philosophy.
Search before building
Before designing any solution that involves concurrency, unfamiliar patterns, infrastructure, or anything where the runtime/framework might have a built-in:
- Search for "{runtime} {thing} built-in"
- Search for "{thing} best practice {current year}"
- Check official runtime/framework docs
Three layers of knowledge: tried-and-true (Layer 1), new-and-popular (Layer 2), first-principles (Layer 3). Prize Layer 3 above all. See ETHOS.md for the full builder philosophy.
Local plans
Contributors can store long-range vision docs and design documents in ~/.gstack-dev/plans/.
These are local-only (not checked in). When reviewing TODOS.md, check plans/ for candidates
that may be ready to promote to TODOs or implement.
E2E eval failure blame protocol
When an E2E eval fails during /ship or any other workflow, never claim "not
related to our changes" without proving it. These systems have invisible couplings —
a preamble text change affects agent behavior, a new helper changes timing, a
regenerated SKILL.md shifts prompt context.
Required before attributing a failure to "pre-existing":
- Run the same eval on main (or base branch) and show it fails there too
- If it passes on main but fails on the branch — it IS your change. Trace the blame.
- If you can't run on main, say "unverified — may or may not be related" and flag it as a risk in the PR body
"Pre-existing" without receipts is a lazy claim. Prove it or don't say it.
Running evals as an agent: always detach (SIGTERM-proof)
Never run a long eval as a plain backgrounded Bash task: a turn-boundary SIGTERM
kills it mid-flight. Run paid evals in the background with bun run eval:bg:pr
(diff-selected PR gate) or bun run eval:bg:release (full gate + periodic);
eval:bg:gate and eval:bg:periodic run one tier. All four run
scripts/eval-bg.ts, which prints [eval-bg] backend=<dispatch|local> … and
gstack-detach LOG <path>, then returns immediately.
- Dispatch backend (default when HEAD is clean and pushed to garrytan/gstack
and
ghcan dispatch): CI runs the lane on the pushed revision (evals.ymland/orevals-periodic.yml, verified byexpected_sha); the local log follows the run and names its URL. Dispatched runs are validation runs: fresh, never writing PR receipts. Commit and push first; uncommitted files or unpushed commits fall back to local and the log says why. - Local backend (dirty tree, unpushed commits, a fork, no
gh, or--local): the sharded runner on this machine, capped at ceil(1.5 × planned serial seconds / EVALS_JOBS) + 20 min, at most 4 h (--timeout SECSoverrides). ExportANTHROPIC_API_KEYfirst (never pass keys in argv). - Forcing:
--dispatchrefuses with the fix ("commit and push, or rerun with --local") instead of falling back;--localorGSTACK_EVAL_BG_MODE=localalways runs here. - Waiting: poll the log until
### gstack-detach EXIT=<code> ###(0 passed, 1 failed, 130 cancelled, 2 other); silence is not success. Keep checking until it appears or the user tells you to stop, and report progress at each check.bun run scripts/eval-bg.ts status <log-or-run-id>prints running, passed, failed, cancelled or incomplete (died without a sentinel). - Both backends hold the machine-wide
gstack-evalslock, so concurrent worktrees queue instead of saturating the API; logs live under~/.gstack-dev/eval-runs/. A secondeval:bg:<lane>for the same revision and base follows the queued, running or green dispatch instead of dispatching again.
Humans running evals in their own terminal don't need this. Backends, caps and knobs: docs/TESTING_INTERNALS.md.
E2E test fixtures: extract, don't copy
NEVER copy a full SKILL.md file into an E2E test fixture. SKILL.md files are
1500-2000 lines. When claude -p reads a file that large, context bloat causes
timeouts, flaky turn limits, and tests that take 5-10x longer than necessary.
Instead, extract only the section the test actually needs:
// BAD — agent reads 1900 lines, burns tokens on irrelevant sections
fs.copyFileSync(path.join(ROOT, 'ship', 'SKILL.md'), path.join(dir, 'ship-SKILL.md'));
// GOOD — agent reads ~60 lines, finishes in 38s instead of timing out
const full = fs.readFileSync(path.join(ROOT, 'ship', 'SKILL.md'), 'utf-8');
const start = full.indexOf('## Review Readiness Dashboard');
const end = full.indexOf('\n---\n', start);
fs.writeFileSync(path.join(dir, 'ship-SKILL.md'), full.slice(start, end > start ? end : undefined));
Also when running targeted E2E tests to debug failures:
- Run in foreground (
bun test ...), not background with&andtee - Never
pkillrunning eval processes and restart — you lose results and waste money - One clean run beats three killed-and-restarted runs
Publishing native OpenClaw skills to ClawHub
Native OpenClaw skills live in openclaw/skills/gstack-openclaw-*/SKILL.md.
The command is clawhub publish (NOT clawhub skill publish) — full
workflow, auth, and verification:
docs/OPENCLAW_PUBLISHING.md.
Deploying to the active skill
The active skill lives at ~/.claude/skills/gstack/. After making changes:
- Push your branch
- Fetch and reset in the skill directory:
cd ~/.claude/skills/gstack && git fetch origin && git reset --hard origin/main - Rebuild:
cd ~/.claude/skills/gstack && bun run build
If you use gbrain: the git reset --hard in step 2 reverts the brain-aware
(GBRAIN_CONTEXT_LOAD / GBRAIN_SAVE_RESULTS) blocks that gstack-config gbrain-refresh renders into the install (those generated blocks differ from
main by design). After deploying, re-run gstack-config gbrain-refresh to
restore them across all your projects' Claude sessions. It's idempotent.
Or copy the binaries directly:
cp browse/dist/browse ~/.claude/skills/gstack/browse/dist/browsecp design/dist/design ~/.claude/skills/gstack/design/dist/designcp make-pdf/dist/pdf ~/.claude/skills/gstack/make-pdf/dist/pdf
Skill routing
When the user's request matches an available skill, invoke it via the Skill tool. When in doubt, invoke the skill.
Key routing rules:
- Product ideas/brainstorming → invoke /office-hours
- Strategy/scope → invoke /plan-ceo-review
- Architecture → invoke /plan-eng-review
- Design system/plan review → invoke /design-consultation or /plan-design-review
- Full review pipeline → invoke /autoplan
- Bugs/errors → invoke /investigate
- QA/testing site behavior → invoke /qa or /qa-only
- Code review/diff check → invoke /review
- Visual polish → invoke /design-review
- Ship/deploy/PR → invoke /ship or /land-and-deploy
- Save progress → invoke /context-save
- Resume context → invoke /context-restore
Cross-session decision memory
Durable decisions and their rationale are captured in an append-only, event-sourced
store at ~/.gstack/projects/<slug>/decisions.jsonl so neither you nor the user
re-litigates a settled call or loses the "why" across sessions. This is the reliable,
file-only path: it works with gbrain OFF. (gbrain semantic recall is an optional
enhancement layered on top, never a dependency.)
- Resurface active decisions before re-deciding:
bin/gstack-decision-search(--recent N,--scope repo|branch|issue,--query KW,--all,--json). Add--semantic(with--query) to append related hits from gbrain memory when it's up; it degrades silently to the reliable file results when gbrain is off. Session start already surfaces scope-relevant active decisions via Context Recovery. If a decision is listed, treat it as settled with its rationale; if you're about to reverse it, say so explicitly. - Capture a DURABLE decision when you or the user make one:
bin/gstack-decision-log '{"decision":"...","rationale":"...","scope":"repo|branch|issue","source":"user|skill|agent","confidence":1-10}'. Reverse a prior call with--supersede <id>; expunge an accidental secret with--redact <id>; rewrite the log to the active set with--compact. Non-interactive (never prompts), injection-sanitized, and HIGH-secret-blocking on write. - Durable means: architecture choice, scope cut, tool/vendor choice, or a reversal of a prior call. NOT a turn-level edit, a phrasing tweak, or anything trivially re-derivable. Capture is curated at the source — log durable decisions only, or the store becomes noise.
GBrain Search Guidance (configured by /sync-gbrain)
GBrain is set up and synced on this machine. The agent should prefer gbrain over Grep when the question is semantic or when you don't know the exact identifier yet.
This worktree is pinned to a worktree-scoped code source via the
.gbrain-source file in the repo root (kubectl-style context). Any
gbrain code-def, code-refs, code-callers, code-callees, or query
call from anywhere under this worktree routes to that source by default —
no --source flag needed. Conductor sibling worktrees of the same repo
each have their own pin and their own indexed pages, so semantic results
match the actual code on disk in this worktree.
Two indexed corpora available via the gbrain CLI:
- This worktree's code (auto-pinned via
.gbrain-source). ~/.gstack/curated memory (registered asgstack-brain-<user>source via the existing federation pipeline).
Prefer gbrain when:
- "Where is X handled?" / semantic intent, no exact string yet:
gbrain search "<terms>"orgbrain query "<question>" - "Where is symbol Y defined?" / symbol-based code questions:
gbrain code-def <symbol>orgbrain code-refs <symbol> - "What calls Y?" / "What does Y depend on?":
gbrain code-callers <symbol>/gbrain code-callees <symbol> - "What did we decide last time?" / past plans, retros, learnings:
gbrain search "<terms>" --source gstack-brain-<user>
Grep is still right for known exact strings, regex, multiline patterns, and
file globs. Run /sync-gbrain after meaningful code changes; for ongoing
auto-sync across all worktrees, run gbrain autopilot --install once per
machine — gbrain's daemon handles incremental refresh on a schedule.
Safety: don't run /sync-gbrain while gbrain autopilot is active — the
orchestrator refuses destructive source ops when it detects a running autopilot
to avoid racing it (#1734). Prefer registering user repos with gbrain sources add --path <dir> (no --url): URL-managed sources can auto-reclone, and the
sync code walk for them requires an explicit --allow-reclone opt-in.