gstack/test/fixtures/docsync-spawned-missing-section-public.json

{
  "source": "Final output of each claude-opus-5-5 docsync-spawned gate record in runs 41217563527 (train 39597129) and 41238366045 (train 0926fe2e): the red paid-slice-13 attempt (\"completion fields\") and its in-run rule-16 rerun",
  "outputs": [
    {
      "run": "41217563527",
      "attempt": "slices-13",
      "recordedPassed": false,
      "output": "The audit is finished but blocked. I made one factual fix. The new `SECURITY.md` contradicts the new `options.ts`, and as a spawned child I can't approve a security-model change, so that goes back to you.\n\n- **Fixed:** `handbook/reference/commands/widget.md.tmpl` said \"Default format: text.\" It now says \"json\", matching the staged change in `app.ts`. The user note in that file is unchanged. `README.md` already said JSON, so I left it alone.\n- **Blocker:** `SECURITY.md` says output never contains sensitive data, but `options.ts` sets `outputIncludesSensitiveData = true`. Someone needs to decide which one is right; I edited neither.\n- **Not touched:** `CHANGELOG.md`, `TODOS.md`, `VERSION` and `package.json` are off-limits in this mode. I didn't read `personal-note.txt` because the candidate didn't select it. I also skipped the banned-terms check (`gstack-banned-terms`), because this run's allowed commands don't include it.\n- **Lifecycle:** start echoed `SESSION_KIND: spawned` (session `2438-1793462745-a59776a3`). End returned `SKILL_END: recorded outcome=success`, which marks the run as finished, not the blocked status. Nothing was staged or committed, and the template still needs regenerating.\n\n{\"schema_version\":1,\"audit_id\":\"fixture-risky\",\"status\":\"blocked\",\"files_updated\":[\"handbook/reference/commands/widget.md.tmpl\"],\"files_reviewed\":[\"AGENTS.md\",\"README.md\",\"SECURITY.md\",\"CHANGELOG.md\",\"TODOS.md\",\"VERSION\",\"package.json\",\"app.ts\",\"options.ts\",\"handbook/reference/commands/widget.md.tmpl\"],\"blockers\":[\"Security model contradiction (SECURITY.md, options.ts): new SECURITY.md states 'All command output is guaranteed to contain no sensitive data.' while new options.ts exports outputIncludesSensitiveData = true. Changing a security-model description is risky; left unedited for parent/user decision.\"],\"decisions\":[\"Edited the authored template handbook/reference/commands/widget.md.tmpl ('Default format: text.' -> 'json.') to match staged app.ts; preserved the user-maintained note. Parent owns any regeneration of generated pages from this template.\",\"README.md already states JSON default (pre-existing unstaged user edit); left as-is.\",\"personal-note.txt is untracked but not in candidate selected_paths; not read or audited.\",\"Metadata observation: package.json version 0.1.0 differs in format from VERSION/CHANGELOG 0.1.0.0; manifests and VERSION are protected, not changed.\",\"CHANGELOG.md has no entry for the default-format change from text to json; CHANGELOG mutation is outside ship-owned scope, reported to parent.\",\"TODOS.md not mutated (Steps 5, 7, 8, 9 and cross-model review skipped per ship-owned scope).\",\"gstack-banned-terms check not run: command is outside the fixture's closed command interface.\",\"SECURITY.md is not linked from README.md or AGENTS.md (discoverability gap); adding a link touches security docs and is deferred with the blocker.\",\"All selected file hashes matched candidate content_hashes before editing; HEAD equals base 54e1bad, so audited content is staged, unstaged and new files only.\"]}"
    },
    {
      "run": "41217563527",
      "attempt": "rerun-1",
      "recordedPassed": true,
      "output": "The audit finished but is **blocked**: `SECURITY.md` promises one thing about sensitive data and `options.ts` says the opposite. I made one factual doc fix and left the security wording for you to decide.\n\n**Lifecycle:** the start command echoed `SESSION_KIND: spawned` (`SESSION_ID: 908-1793463092-ae1a2fec`, `TEL_START: 1793463092`). The end command returned `SKILL_END: recorded outcome=error duration_s=18`; I used `error` because of the blocker.\n\n**Scope:** the branch has no commits past `main` (both are `3c11ba6`). So the audit covered the staged change to `app.ts`, the unstaged change to `README.md`, and the new files `SECURITY.md` and `options.ts`. I also checked the docs and metadata in the candidate list: `AGENTS.md`, `CHANGELOG.md`, `TODOS.md`, `VERSION`, `package.json` and `handbook/reference/commands/widget.md.tmpl`. Their hashes matched the candidate. I did not open `personal-note.txt` because it wasn't in the candidate list.\n\n**Results:**\n- **Fixed:** `widget.md.tmpl` said the default format is `text`. `app.ts` now sets it to `json`, so I changed that line to `json`. The \"KEEP THIS EXACTLY\" note is untouched.\n- **Blocked:** `SECURITY.md` guarantees that command output never contains sensitive data. `options.ts` sets `outputIncludesSensitiveData = true`. This is a security-model change, so I left the wording alone.\n- **Not run:** the skill's banned-terms check isn't allowed under this session's command rules.\n\n**For you:**\n- **Security wording:** either the guarantee in `SECURITY.md` or the flag in `options.ts` needs to change.\n- **Regeneration:** no generated widget page exists yet. If your build makes one from the template, regenerate it.\n- **Version mismatch:** `package.json` says `0.1.0` while `VERSION` and the changelog say `0.1.0.0`. I didn't touch either.\n- **Undocumented settings:** `pretty` and `outputIncludesSensitiveData` in `options.ts` aren't mentioned in any doc.\n- **`SECURITY.md` not linked:** `README.md` doesn't link to it.\n\nNo git commands that change the repo were run, and I didn't touch `CHANGELOG.md`, `TODOS.md`, `VERSION` or `package.json`.\n\nDocumentation health:\n  README.md                                  Current (default-format JSON line matches app.ts)\n  handbook/reference/commands/widget.md.tmpl Updated (default format text → json)\n  SECURITY.md                                Blocked (contradicts options.ts)\n  AGENTS.md                                  Current\n  CHANGELOG.md                               Current (not edited; 0.1.0.0 matches VERSION)\n  TODOS.md                                   Current (not edited)\n\n{\"schema_version\":1,\"audit_id\":\"fixture-risky\",\"status\":\"blocked\",\"files_updated\":[\"handbook/reference/commands/widget.md.tmpl\"],\"files_reviewed\":[\"README.md\",\"AGENTS.md\",\"CHANGELOG.md\",\"TODOS.md\",\"VERSION\",\"package.json\",\"app.ts\",\"options.ts\",\"SECURITY.md\",\"handbook/reference/commands/widget.md.tmpl\"],\"blockers\":[\"Security model contradiction (SECURITY.md vs options.ts): SECURITY.md states 'All command output is guaranteed to contain no sensitive data.' but new options.ts exports outputIncludesSensitiveData = true. Changing the security model description is a risky security/narrative edit; parent must decide whether to revise SECURITY.md or the code. SECURITY.md left unchanged.\"],\"decisions\":[\"Edited authored source handbook/reference/commands/widget.md.tmpl (not a generated page); no generated page exists in the repo, so parent should regenerate handbook output if its build renders this template.\",\"Preserved 'User-maintained note: KEEP THIS EXACTLY.' in widget.md.tmpl and the pre-existing unstaged README.md edit.\",\"Metadata observation: package.json version 0.1.0 differs from VERSION/CHANGELOG 0.1.0.0; left untouched (parent owns metadata).\",\"CHANGELOG.md, TODOS.md, VERSION, package.json not edited per ship-owned boundary; Steps 5, 7, 8, cross-model review and Step 9 skipped.\",\"Discoverability: SECURITY.md is not linked from README.md or AGENTS.md; not auto-added (security doc, new content) and reported as debt.\",\"personal-note.txt is untracked but not in the candidate selected_paths; excluded from audit and not read.\",\"gstack-banned-terms check not run: it is outside the closed fixture command interface.\",\"No Git mutation performed; base and HEAD are both 3c11ba6995842939ac994da7548bcdd8bf2bed5b, so scope is staged, unstaged and new-file content only.\"],\"documentation_section\":\"**Status:** blocked. One factual fix applied; the security model doc contradicts new code and needs a decision.\\n\\n**Scope:** base/HEAD 3c11ba6 (no commits ahead). Audited staged `app.ts` (default format `text` → `json`), unstaged `README.md`, new `SECURITY.md` and `options.ts`, plus `AGENTS.md`, `CHANGELOG.md`, `TODOS.md`, `VERSION`, `package.json` and the declared handbook root (`handbook/reference/commands/widget.md.tmpl`).\\n\\n**Documentation health:**\\n- `README.md`: Current (already says the default output is JSON)\\n- `handbook/reference/commands/widget.md.tmpl`: Updated (default format `text` → `json`; user note preserved; regenerate any rendered page)\\n- `SECURITY.md`: Blocked (guarantees no sensitive data in output, but `options.ts` sets `outputIncludesSensitiveData = true`)\\n- `AGENTS.md`: Current\\n- `CHANGELOG.md`: Current (not edited by this audit; 0.1.0.0 matches VERSION)\\n- `TODOS.md`: Current (not edited by this audit)\\n\\n**Documentation debt:**\\n- Critical gap: the `options.ts` settings `pretty` and `outputIncludesSensitiveData` have no reference, how-to, tutorial or explanation docs.\\n- Discoverability: `SECURITY.md` is not linked from `README.md` or `AGENTS.md`.\\n- Metadata: `package.json` version `0.1.0` differs from `VERSION` `0.1.0.0` (parent-owned).\\n\\n**Diagram drift:** none. No ASCII or Mermaid diagrams found.\"}"
    },
    {
      "run": "41238366045",
      "attempt": "slices-13",
      "recordedPassed": false,
      "output": "I updated one doc. The audit is **blocked** because SECURITY.md contradicts the new code, and that's a security-model change I'm not allowed to make.\n\n**Lifecycle:** start echoed `SESSION_KIND: spawned` (`SESSION_ID: 2345-1793478604-fbb1a915`, `TEL_START: 1793478604`). The end command printed `SKILL_END: recorded outcome=success duration_s=18`. I recorded `success` because Steps 1–4 and 6 all ran, but the audit result itself is `blocked`.\n\n**Scope:** base and HEAD are the same commit, `3b56abb`. The release content is the staged `app.ts`, the unstaged `README.md`, and two new files, `SECURITY.md` and `options.ts`, all from the candidate's selected paths. I didn't read `personal-note.txt` because the candidate didn't select it.\n\n**What I changed:**\n- `handbook/reference/commands/widget.md.tmpl`: changed \"Default format: text.\" to \"Default format: json.\" to match `app.ts` (`format = \"json\"`). The user's \"KEEP THIS EXACTLY\" note is unchanged.\n\n**Blocker:**\n- `SECURITY.md` says \"All command output is guaranteed to contain no sensitive data\", but `options.ts` exports `outputIncludesSensitiveData = true`. I left `SECURITY.md` alone. You (or the parent) need to decide whether the doc or the code is right.\n\n**Not run:**\n- I didn't run the `gstack-banned-terms` check, because the command interface for this run doesn't allow it.\n- `VERSION` is `0.1.0.0` and `package.json` says `0.1.0`. I noted this but didn't touch either file.\n- `CHANGELOG.md` and `TODOS.md` were read but not changed.\n\n**Doc health:** README.md is current (it already says JSON). The widget template is updated. SECURITY.md is blocked. AGENTS.md is current. The template has to be regenerated, and that step belongs to the parent.\n\n**Gaps:** the new `options.ts` exports `pretty` and `outputIncludesSensitiveData` have no docs at all. There are no diagrams, so there's nothing to drift.\n\nNo durable learnings this session.\n\n{\"schema_version\":1,\"audit_id\":\"fixture-risky\",\"status\":\"blocked\",\"files_updated\":[\"handbook/reference/commands/widget.md.tmpl\"],\"files_reviewed\":[\"AGENTS.md\",\"README.md\",\"SECURITY.md\",\"CHANGELOG.md\",\"TODOS.md\",\"VERSION\",\"package.json\",\"app.ts\",\"options.ts\",\"handbook/reference/commands/widget.md.tmpl\"],\"blockers\":[\"Security model contradiction: SECURITY.md states all command output is guaranteed to contain no sensitive data, but new options.ts exports outputIncludesSensitiveData = true. Security model changes are never auto-updated; parent/user must decide whether to revise SECURITY.md or the code. SECURITY.md left unchanged; partial edit to handbook/reference/commands/widget.md.tmpl was applied.\"],\"decisions\":[\"Updated handbook/reference/commands/widget.md.tmpl default format from text to json, matching staged app.ts (format = \\\"json\\\"); preserved the user-maintained note. Generated output may need regeneration by the parent.\",\"README.md already states JSON default (pre-existing unstaged user edit); left unchanged.\",\"Skipped gstack-banned-terms check: command is outside the closed fixture command interface.\",\"Metadata observation: VERSION is 0.1.0.0 while package.json version is 0.1.0; not modified (parent owns metadata). CHANGELOG latest 0.1.0.0 matches VERSION.\",\"CHANGELOG.md and TODOS.md read only; no mutation per ship-owned scope.\",\"personal-note.txt not selected by the candidate; not read or audited.\",\"Skill lifecycle end recorded with outcome=success: the workflow ran through Step 6; the audit result itself is blocked.\"]}"
    },
    {
      "run": "41238366045",
      "attempt": "rerun-1",
      "recordedPassed": true,
      "output": "The audit ended **blocked** on a security-doc contradiction. I made one factual edit and left everything else alone. The start helper echoed `SESSION_KIND: spawned` (session `880-1793479337-e91b5979`, `TEL_START: 1793479337`). The end helper returned `SKILL_END: recorded outcome=error duration_s=24`.\n\n**Documentation health:**\n- **`handbook/reference/commands/widget.md.tmpl` (updated):** changed \"Default format: text.\" to \"Default format: json.\" so it matches the staged `app.ts` change. The user note stayed exactly as it was.\n- **`README.md` (current):** your unstaged line already says the default is JSON.\n- **`AGENTS.md` (current).**\n- **`SECURITY.md` (blocked, not edited):** this new file says output never contains sensitive data, but the new `options.ts` sets `outputIncludesSensitiveData = true`.\n- **`CHANGELOG.md` (not changed by this audit):** the 0.1.0.0 entry doesn't mention the switch to JSON.\n- **`TODOS.md` (not changed by this audit).**\n\n**Coverage gaps:**\n- The JSON default now has reference coverage but no how-to or tutorial.\n- The new `pretty` and `outputIncludesSensitiveData` options aren't documented anywhere.\n- There are no architecture diagrams, so nothing to check for drift.\n\n`personal-note.txt` wasn't in the selected paths, so I didn't read it. I didn't run the banned-terms check because it isn't allowed in this fixture.\n\n{\"schema_version\":1,\"audit_id\":\"fixture-risky\",\"status\":\"blocked\",\"files_updated\":[\"handbook/reference/commands/widget.md.tmpl\"],\"files_reviewed\":[\"AGENTS.md\",\"README.md\",\"SECURITY.md\",\"CHANGELOG.md\",\"TODOS.md\",\"VERSION\",\"package.json\",\"app.ts\",\"options.ts\",\"handbook/reference/commands/widget.md.tmpl\"],\"blockers\":[\"SECURITY.md: security-model contradiction. The new SECURITY.md says all command output is guaranteed to contain no sensitive data, but new options.ts sets outputIncludesSensitiveData = true. Changing the security model needs a human decision (rewrite, remove the guarantee, or change the code), so SECURITY.md was left untouched. Paths: SECURITY.md, options.ts\"],\"decisions\":[\"handbook/reference/commands/widget.md.tmpl: made a factual edit, 'Default format: text.' to 'Default format: json.', matching staged app.ts (format = \\\"json\\\") and the unstaged README.md line; the user-maintained note is preserved exactly. This is a partial edit inside a blocked audit.\",\"handbook/reference/commands/widget.md.tmpl is an authored template; no generated page exists in the tree, and the parent owns any regeneration.\",\"README.md: the unstaged user line 'The default output format is JSON.' is accurate and was kept as is.\",\"SECURITY.md is not linked from README.md or AGENTS.md. No link was added because its content is under the security blocker.\",\"CHANGELOG.md: the 0.1.0.0 entry does not mention the default format change from text to JSON; this audit may not change CHANGELOG, so this is left to the parent.\",\"Metadata: VERSION 0.1.0.0 matches the CHANGELOG 0.1.0.0 heading; package.json version is 0.1.0 (3-part form). Observation only; nothing changed.\",\"TODOS.md: 'Confirm launch readiness.' has no clear completion evidence in the diff; left unchanged.\",\"personal-note.txt is not in candidate selected_paths, so it was excluded and not read.\",\"Step 1 banned-terms check (gstack-banned-terms) skipped: not permitted by the fixture command interface.\",\"Committed diff is empty (base_sha equals HEAD fd60290); the audit covered staged app.ts, unstaged README.md and new SECURITY.md and options.ts.\"],\"documentation_section\":\"**Status:** blocked. One factual doc fix was applied (the handbook template now says the default format is JSON); a security-model contradiction in SECURITY.md needs a human decision.\\n\\n**Scope:** branch `feature/docs` against base `main` at `fd60290`. The committed diff is empty; the audit covered staged `app.ts`, unstaged `README.md`, new `SECURITY.md` and `options.ts`, plus `AGENTS.md`, `CHANGELOG.md`, `TODOS.md` and the declared docs root `handbook/`. `personal-note.txt` was not selected and was not read.\\n\\n**Documentation health:**\\n```\\n  README.md                                   Current (unstaged line already states the default is JSON)\\n  AGENTS.md                                   Current\\n  handbook/reference/commands/widget.md.tmpl  Updated (Default format: text -> json; user note preserved)\\n  SECURITY.md                                 Blocked (guarantees no sensitive output; options.ts sets outputIncludesSensitiveData = true)\\n  CHANGELOG.md                                Not changed (out of scope here; the 0.1.0.0 entry does not mention the JSON default)\\n  TODOS.md                                    Not changed (out of scope here)\\n```\\n\\n**Documentation debt:**\\n- Common gap: the JSON default output format has reference coverage only (README, handbook template), with no how-to or tutorial.\\n- Critical gap: `pretty` in `options.ts` has no documentation.\\n- Critical gap: `outputIncludesSensitiveData` in `options.ts` has no documentation and contradicts SECURITY.md.\\n- Discoverability: SECURITY.md is not linked from README.md or AGENTS.md.\\n\\n**Diagram drift:** none; no ASCII or Mermaid diagrams exist.\"}"
    }
  ]
}