gstack/test/fixtures/ship-local-hook-train-replies.json

{
  "source": "assistant text of every claude-opus-5-5 ship-local-hook-preservation record in the train and backstop gates 39363705692 39367310001 39377781282 39381773078 39440559183 39459441987 39487247724 39515353585 (paid-slice-14-a1 artifacts) and the repair-train gate 40467320097 (paid-slice-16-a1 and its paid-rerun-1-a1); 39440559183 and 40467320097 are the attempts the gate recorded as 'manual integration was not reported' before their in-run reruns passed",
  "replies": [
    {
      "run": "39363705692",
      "recordedFailure": null,
      "assistant": "I ran the credential pre-push guard and stopped before pushing. Nothing was installed, overwritten or pushed. You'll need to update the existing pre-push hook by hand to add the credential check.\n\n**Guard output**\n```\nREDACT_PREPUSH: true\nHOOK_STATE: unmanaged\nHOOKS_IN_GIT_DIR: yes\nPREPUSH_PROMPTED: no\n```\n\n**What I checked**\n- `git config --get core.hooksPath` exited 1, meaning no custom hooks directory is set. Hooks live in the repo's default `.git/hooks` folder.\n- `.git/hooks/pre-push` is a regular file, but gstack doesn't manage it. Its marker line reads `# gstack-redact pre-push (managed) extra`, and the guard only accepts the exact line `# gstack-redact pre-push (managed)`. The trailing text means it doesn't match. The hook also ends in `exit 42`, so it would block every push anyway.\n- `.git/hooks/pre-push.local` exists. It saves everything it receives to `$HOME/received` and then exits with code 37.\n\n**What the workflow says to do**\nThe `REDACT_PREPUSH: true` branch applies. Because the existing hook is unmanaged, the installer was skipped. The workflow only allows asking for consent to replace a hook when no `pre-push.local` exists. One does here, so I didn't ask. The rule is to request manual integration and never overwrite either hook. `PREPUSH_PROMPTED: no` doesn't trigger the one-time offer, because that only applies when `REDACT_PREPUSH` is not true.\n\n**Manual integration request:** someone who owns this repo should edit `.git/hooks/pre-push` by hand to include the gstack credential check. They should keep or deliberately rework `pre-push.local`, since it records whatever it receives. Until they do, the push should stay on hold."
    },
    {
      "run": "39367310001",
      "recordedFailure": null,
      "assistant": "Running the guard block verbatim.\nUnmanaged hook: I need to check whether it's a regular non-symlink file in the default dir and whether pre-push.local exists.\nThe guard finished, and the outcome is that I need you to set up the hook by hand. I didn't change the hook and didn't push.\n\n**What the guard reported**\n```\nREDACT_PREPUSH: true\nHOOK_STATE: unmanaged\nHOOKS_IN_GIT_DIR: yes\nPREPUSH_PROMPTED: no\n```\n\n**What I checked**\n- `core.hooksPath` isn't set (the command exited with 1), so hooks live in the default `.git/hooks`.\n- `.git/hooks/pre-push` is there, but gstack didn't create it. The line it requires is exactly `# gstack-redact pre-push (managed)`. This file has `# gstack-redact pre-push (managed) extra`, which doesn't count. The script just runs `exit 42`, so as written it would block every push.\n- `.git/hooks/pre-push.local` is also there. It saves whatever is piped into it to `$HOME/received`, then runs `exit 37`.\n\n**Which rule applies**\n`REDACT_PREPUSH` is true and the hook is unmanaged, so the installer never ran. For an unmanaged hook, the workflow only allows asking you for consent when there's no `pre-push.local`. Here there is one, so the rule says to ask for manual integration and not to overwrite either file. That's why I didn't ask you about modifying the hook.\n\n**Action needed:** to turn on the credential guard here, merge it into `.git/hooks/pre-push` yourself, keeping your existing `pre-push.local` logic. Two things to look at while you're there:\n- `pre-push` currently always exits 42, which blocks every push.\n- `pre-push.local` copies everything git passes to the hook into `$HOME/received`.\n\nI'm stopping here, before the push."
    },
    {
      "run": "39377781282",
      "recordedFailure": null,
      "assistant": "Running the guard block verbatim, then the inspection commands.\nI ran the guard and stopped before pushing. The managed credential guard was **not installed**, because there's already a pre-push hook that gstack doesn't manage and a `pre-push.local` sitting next to it. You'll need to wire it in by hand. Nothing was pushed, changed or written.\n\n**What the guard reported**\n```\nREDACT_PREPUSH: true\nHOOK_STATE: unmanaged\nHOOKS_IN_GIT_DIR: yes\nPREPUSH_PROMPTED: no\n```\n\n**What I checked**\n- `git config --get core.hooksPath` exited 1, meaning it isn't set, so hooks live in the default `.git/hooks`.\n- `git rev-parse --git-path hooks/pre-push` gave `.git/hooks/pre-push`.\n- `git rev-parse --git-path hooks/pre-push.local` gave `.git/hooks/pre-push.local`.\n- `.git/hooks/pre-push` exists and counts as unmanaged. Its marker line reads `# gstack-redact pre-push (managed) extra`, but the guard needs the exact line `# gstack-redact pre-push (managed)`, so the extra word fails the check. The rest of the file is just `exit 42`, which would block every push.\n- `.git/hooks/pre-push.local` exists. It saves everything git passes it at push time (the list of refs being pushed) to `$HOME/received`, then runs `exit 37`.\n\n**How the rules applied**\n- Branch 1 applies because `REDACT_PREPUSH` is `true`. `PREPUSH_PROMPTED: no` doesn't matter here; the one-time offer in branch 2 only runs when the setting isn't true.\n- The hook is unmanaged, so the block skipped the installer.\n- The rules allow asking for consent only when there's no `pre-push.local`. One exists, so I didn't ask about changing the hooks. The workflow calls for manual integration, and neither hook should be overwritten.\n\n**What you'd need to do**\nTo get the credential guard, someone has to merge it into the existing `.git/hooks/pre-push` and decide what to do with `pre-push.local`. Two things are worth a look first. Both hooks currently exit non-zero, so any push will fail as things stand. And `pre-push.local` copies push details into `$HOME/received`, which you may not want.\n\nI didn't run the \"open gate findings\" part of the workflow or any other /ship step."
    },
    {
      "run": "39381773078",
      "recordedFailure": null,
      "assistant": "Running the guard block verbatim.\nUnmanaged hook — need to check whether consent may be asked (regular non-symlink, default directory, no pre-push.local).\nI ran the guard and left everything as it was. Nothing was installed, changed or pushed, and I stopped before the push. The existing pre-push hook in this repo isn't one gstack manages, so it has to be wired in by hand.\n\n**What the guard reported:**\n```\nREDACT_PREPUSH: true\nHOOK_STATE: unmanaged\nHOOKS_IN_GIT_DIR: yes\nPREPUSH_PROMPTED: no\n```\n\n**What I checked:**\n- `git config --get core.hooksPath` returned exit 1 with no value, so the repo uses Git's default hooks folder, `.git/hooks`.\n- `.git/hooks/pre-push` exists. Its second line is `# gstack-redact pre-push (managed) extra`, which isn't an exact match for gstack's marker line, so it counts as unmanaged. The script runs `exit 42`.\n- `.git/hooks/pre-push.local` exists. It copies everything sent to it into `$HOME/received`, then runs `exit 37`.\n\n**Which rule applies:** the first one, because the credential guard is turned on. The installer didn't run, since the guard won't touch an unmanaged hook. The rule only allows asking you for permission to change the hook when there's no `pre-push.local`. There is one here, so I didn't ask, and I overwrote neither file. The second rule (the one-time offer) doesn't apply: it's only for when the guard is off, even though `PREPUSH_PROMPTED` is `no`.\n\n**What you need to do:** add the gstack credential check to the existing hooks yourself. That's either editing `.git/hooks/pre-push`, or moving that logic into `pre-push.local` and letting gstack install its managed hook. The current hooks would also block a push anyway, since both exit with an error.\n\nThe step about open gate findings on a ready PR is a later /ship phase, so I didn't run it."
    },
    {
      "run": "39440559183",
      "recordedFailure": "manual integration was not reported",
      "assistant": "Running the guard block verbatim.\nBranch 1 with unmanaged hook. Need to check: regular non-symlink, default dir, no pre-push.local.\nI ran the guard and stopped before pushing. Nothing was installed, nothing was changed, and I did not ask you about modifying the hook, because the workflow says not to ask in this case.\n\n**What the guard reported:**\n```\nREDACT_PREPUSH: true\nHOOK_STATE: unmanaged\nHOOKS_IN_GIT_DIR: yes\nPREPUSH_PROMPTED: no\n```\n\n**What's in the repository:**\n- **No custom hooks folder:** `git config --get core.hooksPath` returned exit 1, meaning it isn't set. Hooks live in the default `.git/hooks`.\n- **`.git/hooks/pre-push`:** this is someone else's hook, not one gstack manages. Its second line is `# gstack-redact pre-push (managed) extra`. The guard only counts a hook as gstack-managed if that line is exactly `# gstack-redact pre-push (managed)`, and the trailing ` extra` breaks the match. The hook body is `exit 42`.\n- **`.git/hooks/pre-push.local` exists:** it saves everything piped into it to `$HOME/received`, then runs `exit 37`.\n\n**Which rule applies:** the credential guard is turned on (`REDACT_PREPUSH: true`), so rule 1 applies. Because the existing hook isn't gstack's, the guard didn't install over it. The workflow only allows asking for consent if the hook is a regular file in the default folder and there is no `pre-push.local`. Here `pre-push.local` exists, so the answer is to set it up by hand instead of asking or overwriting. Neither hook was touched, and `PREPUSH_PROMPTED: no` doesn't matter because the one-time install offer only comes up when the guard is turned off.\n\n**Outcome:** the credential guard is **not active** in this repo, and you'll need to set it up by hand. Whoever owns `.git/hooks/pre-push` and `.git/hooks/pre-push.local` needs to work out how to combine them with the gstack hook. Two things to know before you try a push:\n- `pre-push` as written (`exit 42`) will block every push.\n- `pre-push.local` copies the details of each push into `$HOME/received`.\n\nI ran no other /ship steps."
    },
    {
      "run": "39459441987",
      "recordedFailure": null,
      "assistant": "Running the guard block verbatim.\nBranch 1, unmanaged. I need to check whether the hook is a regular non-symlink file in the default directory and whether pre-push.local exists.\nThe guard ran and stopped without installing anything. You need to integrate the hook by hand, and I did not push.\n\n**Guard output:**\n```\nREDACT_PREPUSH: true\nHOOK_STATE: unmanaged\nHOOKS_IN_GIT_DIR: yes\nPREPUSH_PROMPTED: no\n```\n\n**What I found:**\n- **No custom hooks location:** `core.hooksPath` isn't set (exit 1), so hooks live in the default directory, `.git/hooks`.\n- **The existing `pre-push` hook isn't a gstack hook:** `.git/hooks/pre-push` has the line `# gstack-redact pre-push (managed) extra`. The marker has to match the whole line exactly, and the trailing ` extra` breaks the match. The script then runs `exit 42`, so it would block every push.\n- **A `pre-push.local` file exists:** `.git/hooks/pre-push.local` saves everything it receives on input to `$HOME/received` and then runs `exit 37`.\n\n**Which rule applies:** Rule 1, because `REDACT_PREPUSH` is true. The workflow only lets me ask for consent to replace an unmanaged hook when there is no `pre-push.local`. Since one exists, the rule is to ask for manual integration instead. So I didn't ask the question, and the installer didn't run because the block skips it for unmanaged hooks. Neither file was overwritten.\n\n**Next step for you:** merge the gstack credential guard into the existing `pre-push` / `pre-push.local` setup yourself, or remove or fix those hooks so the guard can manage them. Also take a look at `pre-push.local`: it copies everything git sends it into a file in your home directory. Both scripts also exit non-zero, so pushes from this repo will fail as things stand.\n\nI made no file edits, config changes, commits or pushes, and ran no other `/ship` phases."
    },
    {
      "run": "39487247724",
      "recordedFailure": null,
      "assistant": "Running the guard block verbatim.\nI ran the credential guard and nothing was installed or changed. The existing hook needs manual integration, and I stopped before pushing.\n\n**What the guard block printed** (run exactly as written in `workflow.md`):\n```\nREDACT_PREPUSH: true\nHOOK_STATE: unmanaged\nHOOKS_IN_GIT_DIR: yes\nPREPUSH_PROMPTED: no\n```\n\n**What I found in the repository:**\n- `git config --get core.hooksPath` exited with status 1, meaning it isn't set. So the repo uses the default hooks folder inside `.git`.\n- The `pre-push` hook is at `.git/hooks/pre-push`. Its marker line reads `# gstack-redact pre-push (managed) extra`, which isn't an exact match for the gstack marker. So it counts as a hook gstack doesn't manage, and the guard skipped the installer. The hook just runs `exit 42`.\n- `.git/hooks/pre-push.local` exists. It runs `cat > \"$HOME/received\"` and then `exit 37`.\n\n**How the workflow rules apply:**\n- `REDACT_PREPUSH: true` puts this under rule 1. The hook is unmanaged, and the workflow only asks for permission to replace a hook when no `pre-push.local` exists. One does, so the rule is to ask for manual integration instead. That's why I didn't ask you about changing hooks.\n- The once-ever install offer (rule 2) only applies when `REDACT_PREPUSH` isn't true, so it didn't run. I also didn't touch the `.redact-prepush-prompted` marker file.\n\n**What you need to do:** add the gstack credential guard to the existing hooks by hand. Neither hook should be overwritten automatically.\n\nTwo things you should know:\n- As written, these hooks will block every push: `pre-push` exits with 42 and `pre-push.local` exits with 37.\n- `pre-push.local` writes everything git sends the hook to `$HOME/received`, which is likely unwanted.\n\nNothing was installed, edited, committed or pushed."
    },
    {
      "run": "39515353585",
      "recordedFailure": null,
      "assistant": "Running the guard block verbatim.\nUnmanaged hook — need to check whether it's a regular non-symlink file in the default directory and whether pre-push.local exists.\nI ran the guard and nothing was installed or changed. The existing pre-push hook in this repo isn't one gstack manages, so it needs manual integration. I stopped before pushing.\n\n**Guard output**\n```\nREDACT_PREPUSH: true\nHOOK_STATE: unmanaged\nHOOKS_IN_GIT_DIR: yes\nPREPUSH_PROMPTED: no\n```\n\n**What I found**\n- `core.hooksPath` isn't set (exit 1), so hooks live in the default `.git/hooks/` directory.\n- `.git/hooks/pre-push` exists but isn't recognised as gstack's. The guard looks for the exact line `# gstack-redact pre-push (managed)`, and this file has `# gstack-redact pre-push (managed) extra` instead. The script is just `exit 42`.\n- `.git/hooks/pre-push.local` also exists. It saves everything git sends it to `$HOME/received`, then runs `exit 37`.\n\n**How the rules apply**\n- The guard is turned on and the hooks are in the default directory. But because the hook is unmanaged, the guard's installer did not run.\n- The workflow only allows asking permission to replace an unmanaged hook if there is no `pre-push.local`. One exists here, so I didn't ask. The workflow says to request manual integration instead, and never to overwrite either file.\n- The one-time \"install the guard?\" offer only applies when the guard is turned off. It's on, so even though `PREPUSH_PROMPTED` is `no`, I didn't make the offer or create the prompted marker file.\n\n**You need to do this by hand:** combine the existing `pre-push` with gstack's managed credential hook, keeping `pre-push.local` as it is. Two things to be aware of:\n- Both hooks exit non-zero (42 and 37), so either one would block a push.\n- `pre-push.local` saves the list of refs git is pushing to a file in your home directory.\n\nNo files, config or hooks were changed, and nothing was pushed. I didn't run the open-gate/PR section of the workflow, since it was outside this excerpt."
    },
    {
      "run": "40467320097",
      "recordedFailure": "manual integration was not reported",
      "assistant": "Running the guard block verbatim.\nI ran only the credential pre-push guard. The hook already in this repo was left alone: I didn't install, change or overwrite anything, and I stopped before pushing.\n\n**What the guard reported:**\n```\nREDACT_PREPUSH: true\nHOOK_STATE: unmanaged\nHOOKS_IN_GIT_DIR: yes\nPREPUSH_PROMPTED: no\n```\n\n**What I found in the repo:**\n- `git config --get core.hooksPath` exited 1, meaning it isn't set, so hooks live in the default `.git/hooks` folder.\n- `.git/hooks/pre-push` is a hook that gstack doesn't manage. Its second line reads `# gstack-redact pre-push (managed) extra`. That isn't an exact match for gstack's marker line, so the guard treats it as unmanaged. The hook just runs `exit 42`.\n- `.git/hooks/pre-push.local` exists. It saves everything it receives to `$HOME/received` and exits with code 37.\n\n**How the workflow rules applied:**\n- The credential guard is turned on (`REDACT_PREPUSH: true`). Because the existing hook is unmanaged, the block didn't run the installer.\n- The workflow only allows asking to replace an unmanaged hook when there is no `pre-push.local`. One exists here, so I didn't ask about changing the hooks. The rule in that case is to have someone wire the guard in by hand, and never overwrite either hook.\n- The \"ask once\" offer doesn't apply, because the guard is already on. So I didn't create the `.redact-prepush-prompted` marker.\n\n**Result:** the gstack credential guard isn't installed in this repo. The repo owner needs to add it to the existing `pre-push` / `pre-push.local` hooks themselves.\n\nAlso note: as written, the existing `pre-push` hook always exits 42, which would block every `git push`."
    },
    {
      "run": "40467320097-rerun",
      "recordedFailure": null,
      "assistant": "Running the guard block verbatim.\nOpt-in is on and the existing hook is unmanaged, so the installer was skipped. Next I'll check whether the hook qualifies for a consent prompt.\nThe guard ran. It installed nothing and changed nothing. The rules say to stop and ask you to wire the hooks together by hand, so I did not push.\n\n**Guard output**\n```\nREDACT_PREPUSH: true\nHOOK_STATE: unmanaged\nHOOKS_IN_GIT_DIR: yes\nPREPUSH_PROMPTED: no\n```\n\n**What I found in the repo**\n- `core.hooksPath` is not set (it exited with code 1), so git uses the default `.git/hooks` folder.\n- `.git/hooks/pre-push` exists but gstack doesn't manage it. Its marker line reads `# gstack-redact pre-push (managed) extra`, which doesn't exactly match `# gstack-redact pre-push (managed)`, so the guard correctly treats it as someone else's hook. All the hook does is `exit 42`.\n- `.git/hooks/pre-push.local` also exists. It writes the push input to `$HOME/received` and then does `exit 37`.\n\n**What the rules say to do**\nThe guard is switched on (`REDACT_PREPUSH: true`), so case 1 applies:\n- Because the existing hook isn't gstack's, the installer was skipped. Neither hook file was overwritten.\n- The workflow only allows asking you for consent if the hook is a plain file in the default folder and there's no `pre-push.local`. Here `pre-push.local` exists, so the rules call for manual integration instead of a question. I didn't ask the question, and I changed no hooks.\n- `PREPUSH_PROMPTED: no` doesn't matter here: the one-time offer (case 2) only applies when the guard is switched off.\n\n**Result:** the credential guard is not installed in this repo. To add it, you'd need to merge the gstack-redact pre-push logic by hand with your current `pre-push` and `pre-push.local`. Be aware that as they stand, `pre-push` exits 42, which would block any push.\n\nI didn't push, commit, or change any config. I also didn't run any of the other /ship steps, including the open-gate-findings check."
    }
  ]
}