gstack/test/fixtures/design-crop-gutter-ap.json

{
  "sourceHead": "5e7b66c7f41942ea2b0840405385612cec046d78",
  "screen": "     f2 with icon and explicit text; all text meets AA | PENDING |\n 62  \n 63 +## Approved design decisions                                                                                       \n 64 +                                                                                                                   \n 65 +### Decision 1 (Pass 1, D2 → 1A): Save is the single visual anchor of the header                                   \n 66 +Save renders as the only filled button (#1d4ed8 background, white text). Reset,                                    \n 67 +Cancel, and Export render as neutral ghost buttons. Use the existing Button                                        \n 68 +variants; no new variant. Ghost buttons keep 44px targets and a border/text                                        \n 69 +contrast of at least 3:1 so they stay obviously clickable without hover.                                           \n 70 +                                                                                                                   \n 71 +Read order the header now produces (first, second, third):                                                         \n 72 +                                                                                                                   \n 73 +```text                                                                                                            \n 74 +Persistent app navigation                                                                                          \n 75 +main                                                                                                               \n 76 +  Account settings (h1)                       ← 1st: where am I                                                    \n 77 +  Manage your display name, email address,    ← context                                                            \n 78 +  and notification preferences.                                                                                    \n 79 +  [ Save ]  Reset  Cancel  Export             ← 2nd: Save (filled) then ghosts                                     \n 80 +  InlineStatus (blank | Unsaved changes | Saved at HH:mm)  ← 3rd: state                                            \n 81 +  Profile (h2)                                                                                                     \n 82 +    Display name  [__________]                                                                                     \n 83 +    Email         [__________]                                                                                     \n 84 +  Notifications (h2)                                                                                               \n 85 +    Weekly digest  (switch)                                                                                        \n 86 +    Product tips   (switch)                                                                                        \n 87 +```                                                                                                                \n 88 +                                                                                                                   \n 89  ## Pass scores\n 90  Recorded as passes run. Format: initial → after approved fixes.\n 91  \n╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌╌\n Do you want to make this edit to gstack-test-plan-design.md?\n ❯ 1. Yes\n   2. Yes, and switch to accept edits (auto-approve file edits and common file commands) for this session; Yes, and\n      always allow access to /tmp/gstack-paid-shard-90X2Ul/tmp/gstack-e2e-plan-design-iqHQUu for this session\n   3. Nohift+tab)\n\n Esc to cancel · Tab to amend\n",
  "hook": {
    "cwd": "/tmp/gstack-paid-shard-90X2Ul/tmp/gstack-plan-count-Wg2rCj",
    "expected": "/tmp/gstack-paid-shard-90X2Ul/tmp/gstack-e2e-plan-design-iqHQUu/gstack-test-plan-design.md",
    "sessionId": "e9aa75df-769b-4622-b1ed-d42278bbac8e",
    "transcriptPath": "/tmp/gstack-paid-shard-90X2Ul/tmp/gstack-hermetic-3157466-nVT3Zd/with-skills/.claude/projects/-tmp-gstack-paid-shard-90X2Ul-tmp-gstack-plan-count-Wg2rCj/e9aa75df-769b-4622-b1ed-d42278bbac8e.jsonl",
    "seenIds": [
      "e9aa75df-769b-4622-b1ed-d42278bbac8e:toolu_01XJrCtfHgPW1YJ7fdTTqbrg",
      "e9aa75df-769b-4622-b1ed-d42278bbac8e:toolu_01EKGuPLcZtQZfUFrCJt6SVj",
      "e9aa75df-769b-4622-b1ed-d42278bbac8e:toolu_013ZnnsgVQJKTMtqari64Zwx",
      "e9aa75df-769b-4622-b1ed-d42278bbac8e:toolu_01PiMVfTP1sFjqJT7bmPNEV4"
    ],
    "pendingId": "e9aa75df-769b-4622-b1ed-d42278bbac8e:toolu_01PiMVfTP1sFjqJT7bmPNEV4",
    "completedId": "e9aa75df-769b-4622-b1ed-d42278bbac8e:toolu_013ZnnsgVQJKTMtqari64Zwx",
    "completedIds": [
      "e9aa75df-769b-4622-b1ed-d42278bbac8e:toolu_01XJrCtfHgPW1YJ7fdTTqbrg",
      "e9aa75df-769b-4622-b1ed-d42278bbac8e:toolu_01EKGuPLcZtQZfUFrCJt6SVj",
      "e9aa75df-769b-4622-b1ed-d42278bbac8e:toolu_013ZnnsgVQJKTMtqari64Zwx"
    ],
    "timestamp": "2026-09-10T13:08:42.044Z"
  },
  "ownedBefore": "# Plan: Settings Page UI redesign (design-reviewed)\n\n## Context\nThe account-settings form already ships with an approved shell, components, and\nbehavior spec (PLAN.md + DESIGN.md). The implementation drifted from DESIGN.md in\nfive places: undifferentiated Save button, uneven section spacing, an error\nsurface below WCAG AA contrast, three label font sizes, and no pending indicator\non Save. This plan brings the form back into conformance with the checked-in\ndesign system without visual exploration or component replacement.\n\nReview mode: text-only (mockups skipped by user request), native review only\n(outside voices skipped by user request), all seven design passes.\n\n## Accepted behavior (inherited unchanged from PLAN.md + DESIGN.md)\n- Single-column settings shell, 640px max width. Persistent app navigation, then\n  `main`: \"Account settings\" (h1) + description \"Manage your display name, email\n  address, and notification preferences.\" (verbatim), action group\n  Save | Reset | Cancel | Export, InlineStatus, Profile (h2) fieldset (Display\n  name, Email), Notifications (h2) fieldset (Weekly digest, Product tips).\n  h2s label fieldsets via aria-labelledby; no heading level skipped.\n- Reuse existing Button, Field, InlineStatus, ErrorSummary, ConfirmationDialog.\n  No new component family. Font stays system-ui, sans-serif, inherited by controls.\n- Defaults for a new account: account name/email, Weekly digest on, Product tips\n  off. Initial load uses the existing form skeleton. Read failure shows Retry\n  (aria-label \"Retry loading\").\n- InlineStatus: role=status, aria-live=polite, aria-atomic=true. Blank before the\n  first successful save; \"Unsaved changes\" when any field differs from saved;\n  \"Saved at HH:mm\" (local 24h) after success; revert-all or confirmed Reset\n  restores the prior text (timestamp or blank). Failed save keeps \"Unsaved\n  changes\" beside the error.\n- Save is atomic. Repeat submissions disabled while pending. Save and Export\n  mutually exclusive; Reset and Cancel disabled while either is pending; all\n  four re-enable on settle. Export downloads latest successfully saved\n  preferences as JSON; pending Export shows the inline spinner beside\n  \"Exporting…\" inside its disabled button, aria-busy=true, reduced-motion safe.\n- Errors: validation beside fields plus linked ErrorSummary (aria-describedby),\n  focus first invalid field. Network/Export failures preserve edits and show\n  Retry as a sibling button outside the live region, visible text \"Retry\",\n  aria-label \"Retry save\" / \"Retry export\". Export success clears only the\n  Export error.\n- Dialogs: Reset → \"Discard unsaved changes?\" / \"Your saved preferences will be\n  restored.\" Actions \"Keep editing\" (default) / \"Discard changes\". Cancel uses\n  the same dialog with \"Discard and leave\". Focus trapped, Escape cancels,\n  focus returns to the trigger when staying; confirmed navigation focuses the\n  destination main heading.\n- Responsive: above 640px, actions in one row. At 640px and below, full-width\n  Save first, then Reset | Cancel | Export in one equal-column row, DOM/tab\n  order preserved, fits 320px with 44px targets and no horizontal scroll.\n- A11y: 44px targets, focus-visible 2px solid #1d4ed8 outline offset 2px\n  (measured contrast > 3:1) on every control and dialog action, semantic\n  fieldsets/labels, main landmark, heading order, reduced motion respected.\n\n## Review findings (each remedy PENDING until individually approved)\n\n| # | Pass | Gap (current implementation) | Proposed remedy (DESIGN.md) | Status |\n|---|------|------------------------------|-----------------------------|--------|\n| 1 | 1 Info Arch | Save has same size/weight/color as Reset, Cancel, Export; no visible primary action | Save = only filled primary (#1d4ed8, white text); Reset/Cancel/Export = neutral ghost buttons | APPROVED (D2 → 1A) |\n| 2 | 2 States | Save pending 2-5s with no indicator; page looks frozen | Inline spinner beside \"Saving…\" inside the disabled Save button, aria-busy=true, reduced-motion support (same pattern Export already uses) | PENDING |\n| 3 | 5 Design Sys | Section gaps are 16/24/32px, no rhythm | 8px base: sections 32px, field groups 24px, label-to-input 8px | PENDING |\n| 4 | 5 Design Sys | Labels use 14/16/18px | Two roles only: 16px body/labels/helper, 20px section headings | PENDING |\n| 5 | 6 A11y | Error text on light pink at ~3:1 contrast, below WCAG AA | error.text #991b1b on error.surface #fef2f2 with icon and explicit text; all text meets AA | PENDING |\n\n## Pass scores\nRecorded as passes run. Format: initial → after approved fixes.\n\n| Pass | Initial | After | Notes |\n|------|---------|-------|-------|\n| 1 Information Architecture | 7 | 10 | Page order was already exact; approving filled Save + ghost secondaries gives the header one anchor |\n| 2 Interaction States | — | — | |\n| 3 User Journey | — | — | |\n| 4 AI Slop Risk | — | — | |\n| 5 Design System Alignment | — | — | |\n| 6 Responsive & A11y | — | — | |\n| 7 Unresolved Decisions | n/a | n/a | register only |\n\n## Implementation tasks\nPopulated only from individually approved remedies.\n\n## Verification\nPopulated with approved tasks.\n",
  "cwd": "/tmp/gstack-paid-shard-90X2Ul/tmp/gstack-plan-count-Wg2rCj",
  "config": "/tmp/gstack-paid-shard-90X2Ul/tmp/gstack-hermetic-3157466-nVT3Zd/with-skills/.claude",
  "startedAt": 1789045498100,
  "transcript": {
    "status": "ready",
    "calls": [
      {
        "sessionId": "e9aa75df-769b-4622-b1ed-d42278bbac8e",
        "toolUseId": "toolu_01XfsQLPBLynKkDxTSMykEb3",
        "questions": [
          {
            "header": "Focus areas",
            "question": "D1 — Review all 7 design passes, or focus on specific ones?\nProject/branch/task: gstack-plan-count-Wg2rCj on main, reviewing the settings-form conformance plan.\nELI10: I rated the plan 6/10. The behavior spec is thorough, but the built form still breaks the design system in five known places (which button is primary, uneven spacing, an error box that is hard to read, three label sizes, and a Save button that gives no feedback for 2-5 seconds). Each pass looks for gaps like these and any others the plan missed. Stakes if we pick wrong: focusing narrowly could leave an unlisted gap for the implementer to guess at.\nRecommendation: A because you asked for all seven dimensions and the five known gaps span four different passes.\nCompleteness: A=10/10, B=6/10\nA) All 7 passes (recommended)\n  ✅ Every known gap gets its own decision, plus a sweep for anything the plan missed\n  ✅ Produces the storyboard, state table, and decision register the implementer needs\n  ❌ Five to seven individual decision questions before the report is done\nB) Only the passes that hold the five listed gaps (1, 2, 5, 6)\n  ✅ Faster: skips Journey, AI Slop, and the decision register\n  ✅ Still resolves every gap the plan already names\n  ❌ Misses unlisted gaps and the storyboard; Pass 3 and 4 have no output\nNet: full coverage costs a few more questions; a partial pass saves minutes but leaves blind spots.",
            "options": [
              {
                "label": "All 7 passes (recommended)",
                "description": "Full review: every pass rated, one question per gap, storyboard and state table included."
              },
              {
                "label": "Passes 1, 2, 5, 6 only",
                "description": "Only the passes containing the five listed gaps. Skips Journey, AI Slop, decision register."
              }
            ],
            "multiSelect": false
          },
          {
            "header": "Routing rules",
            "question": "gstack works best when your project's CLAUDE.md includes skill routing rules. Add them? Note: plan mode is active, so if you pick A the edit and commit to CLAUDE.md happen after this review exits plan mode.",
            "options": [
              {
                "label": "Add routing rules (recommended)",
                "description": "Append a Skill routing section to CLAUDE.md and commit it, once plan mode is exited."
              },
              {
                "label": "No thanks",
                "description": "Invoke skills manually. Records routing_declined so this is not asked again for this project."
              }
            ],
            "multiSelect": false
          },
          {
            "header": "Learnings",
            "question": "gstack can search learnings from your other projects on this machine to find patterns that might apply here. This stays local (no data leaves your machine). Recommended for solo developers. Skip if you work on multiple client codebases where cross-contamination would be a concern.",
            "options": [
              {
                "label": "Enable cross-project (recommended)",
                "description": "Search learnings across all your local projects."
              },
              {
                "label": "Project-scoped only",
                "description": "Only search learnings recorded for this project."
              }
            ],
            "multiSelect": false
          }
        ],
        "answered": true,
        "failed": false,
        "answers": {
          "D1 — Review all 7 design passes, or focus on specific ones?\nProject/branch/task: gstack-plan-count-Wg2rCj on main, reviewing the settings-form conformance plan.\nELI10: I rated the plan 6/10. The behavior spec is thorough, but the built form still breaks the design system in five known places (which button is primary, uneven spacing, an error box that is hard to read, three label sizes, and a Save button that gives no feedback for 2-5 seconds). Each pass looks for gaps like these and any others the plan missed. Stakes if we pick wrong: focusing narrowly could leave an unlisted gap for the implementer to guess at.\nRecommendation: A because you asked for all seven dimensions and the five known gaps span four different passes.\nCompleteness: A=10/10, B=6/10\nA) All 7 passes (recommended)\n  ✅ Every known gap gets its own decision, plus a sweep for anything the plan missed\n  ✅ Produces the storyboard, state table, and decision register the implementer needs\n  ❌ Five to seven individual decision questions before the report is done\nB) Only the passes that hold the five listed gaps (1, 2, 5, 6)\n  ✅ Faster: skips Journey, AI Slop, and the decision register\n  ✅ Still resolves every gap the plan already names\n  ❌ Misses unlisted gaps and the storyboard; Pass 3 and 4 have no output\nNet: full coverage costs a few more questions; a partial pass saves minutes but leaves blind spots.": "All 7 passes (recommended)",
          "gstack works best when your project's CLAUDE.md includes skill routing rules. Add them? Note: plan mode is active, so if you pick A the edit and commit to CLAUDE.md happen after this review exits plan mode.": "Add routing rules (recommended)",
          "gstack can search learnings from your other projects on this machine to find patterns that might apply here. This stays local (no data leaves your machine). Recommended for solo developers. Skip if you work on multiple client codebases where cross-contamination would be a concern.": "Enable cross-project (recommended)"
        },
        "unansweredQuestionIndices": [],
        "answeredAt": "2026-09-10T13:07:42.691Z"
      },
      {
        "sessionId": "e9aa75df-769b-4622-b1ed-d42278bbac8e",
        "toolUseId": "toolu_01EsAQeRNYEWFQjexLpWrJgd",
        "questions": [
          {
            "header": "Issue 1",
            "question": "D2 — Issue 1: How should the header make Save the visible primary action?\nProject/branch/task: gstack-plan-count-Wg2rCj on main, Pass 1 Information Architecture.\nELI10: Right now Save, Reset, Cancel, and Export look identical. A user scanning the header cannot tell which one commits their edits, so some will hit Reset or Cancel by mistake and lose work, or hunt for Save. DESIGN.md already says Save is the only filled button and the rest are ghost buttons. Stakes if we pick wrong: mis-clicks on destructive neighbors and a header that reads as four equal choices.\nRecommendation: 1A because it is the exact DESIGN.md token, reuses the existing Button variants, and makes Save the one anchor in the header.\nCompleteness: 1A=10/10, 1B=7/10, 1C=3/10\n1A) Save filled #1d4ed8 with white text; Reset, Cancel, Export as neutral ghost buttons (recommended) (human: ~1h / CC: ~5min)\n  ✅ One visual anchor; the eye lands on Save before reading any label\n  ✅ Exact DESIGN.md token, so no new color or variant enters the system\n  ❌ Ghost buttons must still hit 44px targets and 3:1 border contrast; needs a check at 320px\n1B) Save filled, but keep Reset/Cancel/Export as today's filled neutral style (human: ~30min / CC: ~3min)\n  ✅ Smaller diff: only Save's variant changes\n  ✅ Save still reads as primary against three gray siblings\n  ❌ Diverges from DESIGN.md's ghost spec, so four filled shapes still compete for weight\n1C) Leave all four identical and rely on position (Save first) (human: 0 / CC: 0)\n  ✅ No code change\n  ✅ DOM order already puts Save first\n  ❌ Position alone fails the 3-second scan test and leaves the documented gap open\nNet: 1A costs a few minutes and closes the gap with the system's own tokens; anything less leaves the header ambiguous.",
            "options": [
              {
                "label": "1A Filled Save, ghost others (recommended)",
                "description": "Save #1d4ed8/white as the only filled button; Reset, Cancel, Export neutral ghost. Exact DESIGN.md spec."
              },
              {
                "label": "1B Filled Save, filled neutral others",
                "description": "Only change Save; keep the other three as filled neutral buttons. Deviates from DESIGN.md."
              },
              {
                "label": "1C Leave as is",
                "description": "No change; rely on Save being first in order. Gap stays open."
              }
            ],
            "multiSelect": false
          }
        ],
        "answered": true,
        "failed": false,
        "answers": {
          "D2 — Issue 1: How should the header make Save the visible primary action?\nProject/branch/task: gstack-plan-count-Wg2rCj on main, Pass 1 Information Architecture.\nELI10: Right now Save, Reset, Cancel, and Export look identical. A user scanning the header cannot tell which one commits their edits, so some will hit Reset or Cancel by mistake and lose work, or hunt for Save. DESIGN.md already says Save is the only filled button and the rest are ghost buttons. Stakes if we pick wrong: mis-clicks on destructive neighbors and a header that reads as four equal choices.\nRecommendation: 1A because it is the exact DESIGN.md token, reuses the existing Button variants, and makes Save the one anchor in the header.\nCompleteness: 1A=10/10, 1B=7/10, 1C=3/10\n1A) Save filled #1d4ed8 with white text; Reset, Cancel, Export as neutral ghost buttons (recommended) (human: ~1h / CC: ~5min)\n  ✅ One visual anchor; the eye lands on Save before reading any label\n  ✅ Exact DESIGN.md token, so no new color or variant enters the system\n  ❌ Ghost buttons must still hit 44px targets and 3:1 border contrast; needs a check at 320px\n1B) Save filled, but keep Reset/Cancel/Export as today's filled neutral style (human: ~30min / CC: ~3min)\n  ✅ Smaller diff: only Save's variant changes\n  ✅ Save still reads as primary against three gray siblings\n  ❌ Diverges from DESIGN.md's ghost spec, so four filled shapes still compete for weight\n1C) Leave all four identical and rely on position (Save first) (human: 0 / CC: 0)\n  ✅ No code change\n  ✅ DOM order already puts Save first\n  ❌ Position alone fails the 3-second scan test and leaves the documented gap open\nNet: 1A costs a few minutes and closes the gap with the system's own tokens; anything less leaves the header ambiguous.": "1A Filled Save, ghost others (recommended)"
        },
        "unansweredQuestionIndices": [],
        "answeredAt": "2026-09-10T13:08:12.298Z"
      }
    ],
    "assistantMessages": [
      {
        "sessionId": "e9aa75df-769b-4622-b1ed-d42278bbac8e",
        "text": "Starting the /plan-design-review skill: running the preamble, then auto-selecting the plan target since plan mode is active.",
        "timestamp": "2026-09-10T13:05:14.728Z"
      },
      {
        "sessionId": "e9aa75df-769b-4622-b1ed-d42278bbac8e",
        "text": "Audit done. Writing the initial plan artifact to the path you specified, then asking the setup and focus questions in one call.",
        "timestamp": "2026-09-10T13:06:34.749Z"
      },
      {
        "sessionId": "e9aa75df-769b-4622-b1ed-d42278bbac8e",
        "text": "Pre-review audit complete: DESIGN.md found and will guide the review, existing components (Button, Field, InlineStatus, ErrorSummary, ConfirmationDialog) can be reused, but the plan scores 6/10 due to five DESIGN.md violations (primary action, spacing, error contrast, label sizes, Save pending state) that need resolving to reach a complete spec.",
        "timestamp": "2026-09-10T13:07:17.658Z"
      },
      {
        "sessionId": "e9aa75df-769b-4622-b1ed-d42278bbac8e",
        "text": "Found no prior learnings, so I'll proceed with the routing-rules edit after plan mode ends. I scored the plan's information architecture 7/10—the layout order is solid, but the four identical action buttons lack hierarchy, so I'll flag making Save the visual anchor over the other three.\n\n",
        "timestamp": "2026-09-10T13:08:01.433Z"
      },
      {
        "sessionId": "e9aa75df-769b-4622-b1ed-d42278bbac8e",
        "text": "Approved 1A. Applying it to the plan and re-rating Pass 1.",
        "timestamp": "2026-09-10T13:08:17.827Z"
      }
    ]
  },
  "provenance": {
    "capture": {
      "path": ".context/ship-source-ap-delta-paid-20260910-v1/design-crop-gutter-plan-v1/capture.json",
      "sha256": "c45bbc9f5fc18b779ebf6341bb1bc07c92c19e7317d06541cf49045fea29bb0e",
      "bytes": 3367
    },
    "screen": {
      "path": ".context/ship-source-ap-delta-paid-20260910-v1/design-crop-gutter-plan-v1/terminal.screen.log",
      "sha256": "234b0501b63c91f8bb5f4a4c9525395e3afe51b3e143a309ecc8f7f9f0f680c0",
      "bytes": 4037
    },
    "hook": {
      "path": ".context/ship-source-ap-delta-paid-20260910-v1/design-crop-gutter-plan-v1/file-permission-state.json",
      "sha256": "15dc4d4f7a2aa3cb711e0d2134f69acaea977ec128b3b1564b282a5bfc806282",
      "bytes": 1163
    },
    "ownedBefore": {
      "path": ".context/ship-source-ap-delta-paid-20260910-v1/design-crop-gutter-plan-v1/before-report.md",
      "sha256": "fc55f093aadaf47b91af112a7ddcf20148972156bf7c22947adb496efadd7227",
      "bytes": 5165
    },
    "transcriptSource": {
      "path": ".context/ship-source-ap-delta-paid-20260910-v1/design-crop-gutter-plan-v1/observation.json",
      "sha256": "e56a78ac3327daf4dca19d086f34a5ecf95b52100e6728ca2f67297c1bfc9340",
      "bytes": 25685
    },
    "replay": {
      "path": ".context/ship-source-ap-delta-paid-20260910-v1/design-crop-gutter-plan-v1/replay-v1.json",
      "sha256": "f9bdc52b65f4441f5d6a5216235fd9183fa2714742b5e72ff44db7109a924eb7",
      "bytes": 1616
    },
    "limits": [
      "Only exact current owned public hook metadata, report bytes, rendered screen and public transcript are included.",
      "The command lower bound is native process start, not asserted exact slash-command time.",
      "No private raw journal is included; live inputs and paid outcomes are unchanged."
    ]
  }
}