data(corpus): archive June 2026 SynthID strength-study subjects

Back docs/synthid.md section 2.2 with the actual test set: the per-image
oracle-verified subjects were only in a local working dir, while the doc claimed
they were recorded in data/synthid_corpus/. Ingest the key pos+cleaned pairs so
the claim holds.

- pos: openai_1/2/3 originals (gpt-image, openai-verify) + gemini_1/2/3/4
  originals (Gemini app, gemini-app); all probe as C2PA-SynthID present.
- cleaned: OpenAI at strength 0.05 (openai_2 only s010 captured) + Gemini at 0.15
  --max-resolution 1536; oracle: SynthID NOT detected. Metadata stripped, so no
  C2PA on the cleaned rows.
- Excluded the third-party issue #14 image (pic3): oracle-verified but not
  committed to the public corpus.
- docs/synthid.md 2.2: state OpenAI n=4 = 3 archived + 1 external-only.
- CLAUDE.md: drop the drift-prone "~65 MB" corpus size from the sdist note.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Victor Kuznetsov
2026-06-03 17:09:58 -07:00
parent 5ec8269949
commit 8523f48fb6
17 changed files with 21 additions and 4 deletions
+1 -1
View File
@@ -14,7 +14,7 @@ You are a **principal Python engineer** maintaining a CLI tool and library for r
## Test and lint
- **CI** (`.github/workflows/test.yml`): runs on push to `main` + every PR. A `lint` job (ubuntu: `ruff check` + `ruff format --check`) plus a `test` matrix (ubuntu/macos/windows x py3.10/3.12) that does `uv sync --frozen --extra dev` then `pytest`. The matrix installs only core + dev (no `gpu` extra), so the GPU/model-running tests skip there and it exercises the metadata/identify/visible/cv2-eraser surface on all three OSes. Keep `uv.lock` valid (don't break `--frozen`) when editing `pyproject.toml`. `publish.yml` stays release-only and now verifies the release tag matches the `pyproject.toml` version (fails the build on a mismatch) before building. **Release flow:** bump the version in `pyproject.toml` + `src/remove_ai_watermarks/__init__.py` + `uv.lock` (the project's own `[[package]]` entry, ~line 2868), commit `chore(release): vX.Y.Z`, `git tag -a vX.Y.Z -m vX.Y.Z` (annotated — `git tag` without `-m` errors here), push `main` + the tag, then `gh release create vX.Y.Z`**PyPI publish triggers on the GitHub Release `published` event, NOT on the tag push**, so the tag alone does not publish. **Sdist must exclude `data/`** (`[tool.hatch.build.targets.sdist] exclude = ["/data"]`): hatchling's default sdist bundles all VCS-tracked files, so the committed `data/` test corpora (synthid_corpus images ~65 MB + the visible-mark captures) pushed the **0.8.0** sdist past PyPI's per-project file-size limit (400 "File too large") — the wheel uploaded but the sdist was rejected, so 0.8.0 shipped wheel-only and 0.8.1 carried the fix. The wheel only ships `src/` (via `[tool.hatch.build.targets.wheel] packages`), so it was never affected. **A failed PyPI upload of one artifact still leaves the other live and you cannot re-upload the same version** — fix the build and cut the next patch. **Build backend is pinned `hatchling<1.28`** (`[build-system] requires`): hatchling 1.28+ emits **Metadata-Version 2.5** (PEP 639), which the twine bundled in `pypa/gh-action-pypi-publish@release/v1` rejects (`"'2.5' is not a valid Metadata-Version"`) — this **failed the v0.8.3 PyPI upload on 2026-06-01** (tag-match + build passed, the upload step failed; nothing was uploaded, so the version stayed empty on PyPI). 1.27.x emits 2.4, which uploads fine (0.8.2 shipped on it). The pin is unpinned `requires = ["hatchling"]` no longer safe because `uv build` pulls the latest hatchling. Lift the pin only once the publish action's twine is ≥ 6.1.0 (2.5-aware) or the workflow moves to `uv publish`.
- **CI** (`.github/workflows/test.yml`): runs on push to `main` + every PR. A `lint` job (ubuntu: `ruff check` + `ruff format --check`) plus a `test` matrix (ubuntu/macos/windows x py3.10/3.12) that does `uv sync --frozen --extra dev` then `pytest`. The matrix installs only core + dev (no `gpu` extra), so the GPU/model-running tests skip there and it exercises the metadata/identify/visible/cv2-eraser surface on all three OSes. Keep `uv.lock` valid (don't break `--frozen`) when editing `pyproject.toml`. `publish.yml` stays release-only and now verifies the release tag matches the `pyproject.toml` version (fails the build on a mismatch) before building. **Release flow:** bump the version in `pyproject.toml` + `src/remove_ai_watermarks/__init__.py` + `uv.lock` (the project's own `[[package]]` entry, ~line 2868), commit `chore(release): vX.Y.Z`, `git tag -a vX.Y.Z -m vX.Y.Z` (annotated — `git tag` without `-m` errors here), push `main` + the tag, then `gh release create vX.Y.Z`**PyPI publish triggers on the GitHub Release `published` event, NOT on the tag push**, so the tag alone does not publish. **Sdist must exclude `data/`** (`[tool.hatch.build.targets.sdist] exclude = ["/data"]`): hatchling's default sdist bundles all VCS-tracked files, so the committed `data/` test corpora (the multi-hundred-MB synthid_corpus images + the visible-mark captures) pushed the **0.8.0** sdist past PyPI's per-project file-size limit (400 "File too large") — the wheel uploaded but the sdist was rejected, so 0.8.0 shipped wheel-only and 0.8.1 carried the fix. The wheel only ships `src/` (via `[tool.hatch.build.targets.wheel] packages`), so it was never affected. **A failed PyPI upload of one artifact still leaves the other live and you cannot re-upload the same version** — fix the build and cut the next patch. **Build backend is pinned `hatchling<1.28`** (`[build-system] requires`): hatchling 1.28+ emits **Metadata-Version 2.5** (PEP 639), which the twine bundled in `pypa/gh-action-pypi-publish@release/v1` rejects (`"'2.5' is not a valid Metadata-Version"`) — this **failed the v0.8.3 PyPI upload on 2026-06-01** (tag-match + build passed, the upload step failed; nothing was uploaded, so the version stayed empty on PyPI). 1.27.x emits 2.4, which uploads fine (0.8.2 shipped on it). The pin is unpinned `requires = ["hatchling"]` no longer safe because `uv build` pulls the latest hatchling. Lift the pin only once the publish action's twine is ≥ 6.1.0 (2.5-aware) or the workflow moves to `uv publish`.
- `bash maintain.sh` — uv-outdated, uv-secure, ruff check/fix, ruff format, pyright, pytest -n auto
- **Strict pyright is clean across `src/` (0 errors).** The cv2/torch/diffusers boundary files (`gemini_engine`, `region_eraser`, `doubao_engine`, `humanizer`, `invisible_engine`, `noai/watermark_remover`) carry a documented per-file `# pyright:` relax pragma that turns off only the unknown-type / untyped-third-party rules — those libs ship no usable types, so strict typing there fights the ecosystem. Pure-logic files stay fully strict; `typings/piexif/__init__.pyi` is a local stub so `metadata.py`/`extractor.py` resolve piexif. Public ndarray-returning signatures on the relaxed engines are still annotated `NDArray[Any]` so strict consumers (`cli.py`) stay clean. When touching a relaxed file, prefer fixing real issues over widening the pragma; keep the pragma scoped to genuinely-untyped boundaries. (`uv-secure` is clean since idna was bumped 3.11 -> 3.16, fixing GHSA-65pc-fj4g-8rjx.)
- **Full-project `uv run pyright` (no path) OOMs/crashes node on this ML-heavy repo** (emits a `libnode` stack frame, no summary) — a known environment limit, not a code error. Gate with `uv run --extra dev --extra gpu pyright src/` (completes, authoritative) or scope to changed files; also run `uv run ruff check` and `uv run pytest` directly.
Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 2.4 MiB

Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 7.6 MiB

Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 1.7 MiB

Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 7.3 MiB

Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 8.5 MiB

Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 2.3 MiB

Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 7.1 MiB

Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 2.3 MiB

Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 2.1 MiB

Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 9.6 MiB

Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 9.3 MiB

Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 8.2 MiB

Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 1.4 MiB

Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 8.6 MiB

+14
View File
@@ -24,3 +24,17 @@ d20d4cc936dbdfe909c52502039a9e84ba93d97b42b24a0acee5b7d6c71930ae,d20d4cc9-Gemini
c86973424817f62510e2a312b85c52e05adf47ace87a8e717fd442607596f501,c8697342-aistudio_lake.png,pos,Google AI Studio (Nano Banana),gemini-2.5-flash-image,1024,1024,png,,,gemini-app,2026-05-24T21:39:09Z,"API/playground: SynthID pixel CONFIRMED (Gemini-app oracle) + visible sparkle, but NO C2PA/IPTC -> synthid_source blind spot"
1f81827c06d67cf6f6c7f5d53ec8f9738183942a6d1d2717b161fea0fdcc540a,1f81827c-Designer.png,pos,Microsoft Designer,dall-e (Designer),1024,1024,png,"OpenAI, Microsoft",yes,c2pa-metadata,2026-05-24T22:18:40Z,C2PA issuer OpenAI+Microsoft; synthid_source=OpenAI (DALL-E surface inherits OpenAI SynthID+C2PA)
f6dd47a5ffd319aea21bf10dcf9877097666420b02c2620080bac12b03976e7e,f6dd47a5-4ef377bd-gpt-image-2-cleaned.png,cleaned,"our pipeline (invisible/SDXL, native-res default)",stabilityai/stable-diffusion-xl-base-1.0,1254,1254,png,,,openai-verify,2026-05-25T20:50:38Z,"cleaned from 4ef377bd via v0.5.3 'all' at native 1254x1254 (prod-equivalent); openai.com/verify: SynthID NOT detected. Re-confirms #10 native-res default defeats OpenAI SynthID (closes #15 root cause). Note: native res OOMs on 20GB MPS, auto-fell back to CPU."
05b836ecfe40fd689177fda74384ae4fdcc446505bbc4281cd3cbb6523eb669e,05b836ec-openai_1_original.png,pos,ChatGPT,gpt-image,1122,1402,png,OpenAI,yes,openai-verify,2026-06-04T00:07:53Z,June 2026 strength-study subject; openai.com/verify: SynthID detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
794e023ea7ae321267fe5af76f4080c98a84a9865669c0733ebfb9757b8638df,794e023e-openai_2_original.png,pos,ChatGPT,gpt-image,1024,1536,png,OpenAI,yes,openai-verify,2026-06-04T00:07:53Z,June 2026 strength-study subject; openai.com/verify: SynthID detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
28ff8732b037f98a4ef5bc277bbcdaa32e5eb9ccbd00b6c8c616e46ef68ae8a0,28ff8732-openai_3_original.png,pos,ChatGPT,gpt-image,1448,1086,png,OpenAI,yes,openai-verify,2026-06-04T00:07:53Z,June 2026 strength-study subject; openai.com/verify: SynthID detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
4affd7f27767a445db6abf741355743ba8d95108ad922c9fff045feed8492236,4affd7f2-gemini_1_original.png,pos,Gemini app,gemini,2816,1536,png,Google LLC,yes,gemini-app,2026-06-04T00:08:05Z,June 2026 strength-study subject; Gemini-app Verify with SynthID: detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
8c1a6fb03ef3d45a1f958fb3401e4264e409ff88c2a793061db7f29023454d0e,8c1a6fb0-gemini_2_original.png,pos,Gemini app,gemini,2816,1536,png,Google LLC,yes,gemini-app,2026-06-04T00:08:05Z,June 2026 strength-study subject; Gemini-app Verify with SynthID: detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
45d79a683134fcba1b147b2aedb669783d474e1fb8a4df329729a0904fd1b46b,45d79a68-gemini_3_original.png,pos,Gemini app,gemini,2816,1536,png,Google LLC,yes,gemini-app,2026-06-04T00:08:05Z,June 2026 strength-study subject; Gemini-app Verify with SynthID: detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
2c33e75a2db614ce74c83cc0a6ac6c3ac735aca83ab88c9c9345843b124f7856,2c33e75a-gemini_4_original.png,pos,Gemini app,gemini,2816,1536,png,Google LLC,yes,gemini-app,2026-06-04T00:08:05Z,June 2026 strength-study subject; Gemini-app Verify with SynthID: detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
2e4ce41cfab456c1d9ea0898e47a5a1d434266ba24e88d4cc807a4180a56925f,2e4ce41c-openai_1_clean_s005.png,cleaned,"our pipeline (SDXL img2img, native)",stabilityai/stable-diffusion-xl-base-1.0,1122,1402,png,,,openai-verify,2026-06-04T00:08:05Z,cleaned at strength 0.05 native; openai.com/verify: SynthID NOT detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
f7c52cdfeb14a6be2fff449e89b0181e66e365f36635ee4fcb21567e4cb770ef,f7c52cdf-openai_3_clean_s005.png,cleaned,"our pipeline (SDXL img2img, native)",stabilityai/stable-diffusion-xl-base-1.0,1448,1086,png,,,openai-verify,2026-06-04T00:08:05Z,cleaned at strength 0.05 native; openai.com/verify: SynthID NOT detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
37b34274210888702e56eb74f4aa36578f15bf57157a3ebf394f0b8eaa820e19,37b34274-openai_2_clean_s010.png,cleaned,"our pipeline (SDXL img2img, native)",stabilityai/stable-diffusion-xl-base-1.0,1024,1536,png,,,openai-verify,2026-06-04T00:08:05Z,cleaned at strength 0.10 native (min captured for this subject); openai.com/verify: SynthID NOT detected
f99bd9a51814265a23de467d14792db903fef99678b7e7c960d0c6813ed9b0fc,f99bd9a5-gemini_1_clean_s015_max1536.png,cleaned,"our pipeline (SDXL img2img, --max-resolution 1536)",stabilityai/stable-diffusion-xl-base-1.0,2816,1536,png,,,gemini-app,2026-06-04T00:08:05Z,cleaned at strength 0.15 --max-resolution 1536; Gemini-app: SynthID NOT detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
4aa5f61c55c1f3fa9bbc49dffff8a404527722637ae694a932245629635b3f2b,4aa5f61c-gemini_2_clean_s015_max1536.png,cleaned,"our pipeline (SDXL img2img, --max-resolution 1536)",stabilityai/stable-diffusion-xl-base-1.0,2816,1536,png,,,gemini-app,2026-06-04T00:08:05Z,cleaned at strength 0.15 --max-resolution 1536; Gemini-app: SynthID NOT detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
356196dd63abf011b30b582a0408ccecb726d746065af20ad3611dde72a88725,356196dd-gemini_3_clean_s015_max1536.png,cleaned,"our pipeline (SDXL img2img, --max-resolution 1536)",stabilityai/stable-diffusion-xl-base-1.0,2816,1536,png,,,gemini-app,2026-06-04T00:08:05Z,cleaned at strength 0.15 --max-resolution 1536; Gemini-app: SynthID NOT detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
9e4160bb8e3e915d2d4593e37c71495ee7cfcec183602541166f622ebfd84403,9e4160bb-gemini_4_clean_s015_max1536.png,cleaned,"our pipeline (SDXL img2img, --max-resolution 1536)",stabilityai/stable-diffusion-xl-base-1.0,2816,1536,png,,,gemini-app,2026-06-04T00:08:05Z,cleaned at strength 0.15 --max-resolution 1536; Gemini-app: SynthID NOT detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
1 sha256 filename label source model width height format c2pa_issuer synthid_metadata verified_via added notes
24 c86973424817f62510e2a312b85c52e05adf47ace87a8e717fd442607596f501 c8697342-aistudio_lake.png pos Google AI Studio (Nano Banana) gemini-2.5-flash-image 1024 1024 png gemini-app 2026-05-24T21:39:09Z API/playground: SynthID pixel CONFIRMED (Gemini-app oracle) + visible sparkle, but NO C2PA/IPTC -> synthid_source blind spot
25 1f81827c06d67cf6f6c7f5d53ec8f9738183942a6d1d2717b161fea0fdcc540a 1f81827c-Designer.png pos Microsoft Designer dall-e (Designer) 1024 1024 png OpenAI, Microsoft yes c2pa-metadata 2026-05-24T22:18:40Z C2PA issuer OpenAI+Microsoft; synthid_source=OpenAI (DALL-E surface inherits OpenAI SynthID+C2PA)
26 f6dd47a5ffd319aea21bf10dcf9877097666420b02c2620080bac12b03976e7e f6dd47a5-4ef377bd-gpt-image-2-cleaned.png cleaned our pipeline (invisible/SDXL, native-res default) stabilityai/stable-diffusion-xl-base-1.0 1254 1254 png openai-verify 2026-05-25T20:50:38Z cleaned from 4ef377bd via v0.5.3 'all' at native 1254x1254 (prod-equivalent); openai.com/verify: SynthID NOT detected. Re-confirms #10 native-res default defeats OpenAI SynthID (closes #15 root cause). Note: native res OOMs on 20GB MPS, auto-fell back to CPU.
27 05b836ecfe40fd689177fda74384ae4fdcc446505bbc4281cd3cbb6523eb669e 05b836ec-openai_1_original.png pos ChatGPT gpt-image 1122 1402 png OpenAI yes openai-verify 2026-06-04T00:07:53Z June 2026 strength-study subject; openai.com/verify: SynthID detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
28 794e023ea7ae321267fe5af76f4080c98a84a9865669c0733ebfb9757b8638df 794e023e-openai_2_original.png pos ChatGPT gpt-image 1024 1536 png OpenAI yes openai-verify 2026-06-04T00:07:53Z June 2026 strength-study subject; openai.com/verify: SynthID detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
29 28ff8732b037f98a4ef5bc277bbcdaa32e5eb9ccbd00b6c8c616e46ef68ae8a0 28ff8732-openai_3_original.png pos ChatGPT gpt-image 1448 1086 png OpenAI yes openai-verify 2026-06-04T00:07:53Z June 2026 strength-study subject; openai.com/verify: SynthID detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
30 4affd7f27767a445db6abf741355743ba8d95108ad922c9fff045feed8492236 4affd7f2-gemini_1_original.png pos Gemini app gemini 2816 1536 png Google LLC yes gemini-app 2026-06-04T00:08:05Z June 2026 strength-study subject; Gemini-app Verify with SynthID: detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
31 8c1a6fb03ef3d45a1f958fb3401e4264e409ff88c2a793061db7f29023454d0e 8c1a6fb0-gemini_2_original.png pos Gemini app gemini 2816 1536 png Google LLC yes gemini-app 2026-06-04T00:08:05Z June 2026 strength-study subject; Gemini-app Verify with SynthID: detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
32 45d79a683134fcba1b147b2aedb669783d474e1fb8a4df329729a0904fd1b46b 45d79a68-gemini_3_original.png pos Gemini app gemini 2816 1536 png Google LLC yes gemini-app 2026-06-04T00:08:05Z June 2026 strength-study subject; Gemini-app Verify with SynthID: detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
33 2c33e75a2db614ce74c83cc0a6ac6c3ac735aca83ab88c9c9345843b124f7856 2c33e75a-gemini_4_original.png pos Gemini app gemini 2816 1536 png Google LLC yes gemini-app 2026-06-04T00:08:05Z June 2026 strength-study subject; Gemini-app Verify with SynthID: detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
34 2e4ce41cfab456c1d9ea0898e47a5a1d434266ba24e88d4cc807a4180a56925f 2e4ce41c-openai_1_clean_s005.png cleaned our pipeline (SDXL img2img, native) stabilityai/stable-diffusion-xl-base-1.0 1122 1402 png openai-verify 2026-06-04T00:08:05Z cleaned at strength 0.05 native; openai.com/verify: SynthID NOT detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
35 f7c52cdfeb14a6be2fff449e89b0181e66e365f36635ee4fcb21567e4cb770ef f7c52cdf-openai_3_clean_s005.png cleaned our pipeline (SDXL img2img, native) stabilityai/stable-diffusion-xl-base-1.0 1448 1086 png openai-verify 2026-06-04T00:08:05Z cleaned at strength 0.05 native; openai.com/verify: SynthID NOT detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
36 37b34274210888702e56eb74f4aa36578f15bf57157a3ebf394f0b8eaa820e19 37b34274-openai_2_clean_s010.png cleaned our pipeline (SDXL img2img, native) stabilityai/stable-diffusion-xl-base-1.0 1024 1536 png openai-verify 2026-06-04T00:08:05Z cleaned at strength 0.10 native (min captured for this subject); openai.com/verify: SynthID NOT detected
37 f99bd9a51814265a23de467d14792db903fef99678b7e7c960d0c6813ed9b0fc f99bd9a5-gemini_1_clean_s015_max1536.png cleaned our pipeline (SDXL img2img, --max-resolution 1536) stabilityai/stable-diffusion-xl-base-1.0 2816 1536 png gemini-app 2026-06-04T00:08:05Z cleaned at strength 0.15 --max-resolution 1536; Gemini-app: SynthID NOT detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
38 4aa5f61c55c1f3fa9bbc49dffff8a404527722637ae694a932245629635b3f2b 4aa5f61c-gemini_2_clean_s015_max1536.png cleaned our pipeline (SDXL img2img, --max-resolution 1536) stabilityai/stable-diffusion-xl-base-1.0 2816 1536 png gemini-app 2026-06-04T00:08:05Z cleaned at strength 0.15 --max-resolution 1536; Gemini-app: SynthID NOT detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
39 356196dd63abf011b30b582a0408ccecb726d746065af20ad3611dde72a88725 356196dd-gemini_3_clean_s015_max1536.png cleaned our pipeline (SDXL img2img, --max-resolution 1536) stabilityai/stable-diffusion-xl-base-1.0 2816 1536 png gemini-app 2026-06-04T00:08:05Z cleaned at strength 0.15 --max-resolution 1536; Gemini-app: SynthID NOT detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
40 9e4160bb8e3e915d2d4593e37c71495ee7cfcec183602541166f622ebfd84403 9e4160bb-gemini_4_clean_s015_max1536.png cleaned our pipeline (SDXL img2img, --max-resolution 1536) stabilityai/stable-diffusion-xl-base-1.0 2816 1536 png gemini-app 2026-06-04T00:08:05Z cleaned at strength 0.15 --max-resolution 1536; Gemini-app: SynthID NOT detected (docs/synthid.md 2.2)
+6 -3
View File
@@ -175,12 +175,15 @@ A controlled study (June 2026, clean v0.8.6 with text/face protection OFF,
native resolution on this repo's default SDXL pipeline) measured the minimum
img2img strength that removes the SynthID pixel watermark, verified per image on
the vendor's own oracle (openai.com/verify for OpenAI, the Gemini app "Verify
with SynthID" for Google). The test set and per-image results are recorded in
`data/synthid_corpus/` (manifest `verified_via` = `openai-verify` / `gemini-app`).
with SynthID" for Google). Each subject is archived in `data/synthid_corpus/` as a
pos original plus its minimum-clearing cleaned output (manifest `verified_via` =
`openai-verify` / `gemini-app`), EXCEPT one third-party image from issue #14, which
was oracle-verified but is not committed (third-party content stays out of the
public corpus).
| Vendor | Images | Resolution(s) | Pipeline | Removed at |
|--------|--------|---------------|----------|------------|
| OpenAI (gpt-image) | n=4 | 1024x1536 .. 1600x1600 | native | **0.05** |
| OpenAI (gpt-image) | n=4 (3 archived + 1 external-only) | 1024x1536 .. 1600x1600 | native | **0.05** |
| Google (Gemini) | n=4 | 2816x1536 -> capped 1536 | `--max-resolution 1536` | **0.15** (0.05 and 0.10 do NOT clear) |
**Two findings, both oracle-verified:**